I have just a little confusion on some formalism in QM. I have a Hamiltonian density function, $h(x)$, where the regular Hamiltonian is given by

$$ H(x) = \int d^{3} \vec{x} \ h(x) $$

I'm wondering, if I am in a situation where I need to act the Hamiltonian on some function, would this function go inside the integral or after it?

$$ H(x) \phi(x) = \int d^{3}\vec{x} \ \left[h(x)\phi(x)\right] $$ OR $$ H(x) \phi(x) = \left[ \int d^{3} \vec{x} \ h(x) \right] \phi(x) $$


I think you are just mislabeling things and getting yourself confused. You wouldn't ever write anything like

$ H(x) = \int d^3 x h(x)$

since you are performing a definite integral on the RHS of the equation with limits of $\pm \infty$ (an integral over all of space).

What you might be thinking of for the Hamiltonian is

$H(t) = \int d^3 x h(x,t)$

or a general operator in momentum space basis say:

$ \mathcal{O} (p) = \int d^4 x \mathcal{O} (x)$?

At any rate,

$H(x) \phi(x) = \int d^3 x h(x) \phi(x) $

doesn't make any sense because doing that is just like (if you were to consider it a summation) sticking terms into the summation:

$H \phi_i = ( \sum_i h_i ) \phi_i = ( \sum_i h_i \phi_i) $

which, I think, clearly is wrong. Does this clear it up?

  • $\begingroup$ Yeah, that summation part makes a lot of sense. Thanks. Also, my mistake for H(x) instead of H(t). $\endgroup$ Aug 20 '12 at 13:40

Adding on to what DJ wrote, the proper way to write the Hamiltonian acting on something else would be:

$$H(t)\phi(x) = \int d^3y\; h(y,t) \phi(x) $$

That is, we can still write it in terms of an integral, we just have to be careful about what is a dummy variable and what is a free variable.


The function h(x) under the integral is not an hamiltonian but an Hamiltonian density, and Doug is right.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.