4
$\begingroup$

The definition of torsion tensor is the following:

$$ \mathbf{T}(\mathbf{X},\mathbf{Y})=\nabla_{\mathbf{X}}\mathbf{Y}-\nabla_{\mathbf{Y}}\mathbf{X} -\left[\mathbf{X},\mathbf{Y}\right]. $$

In an holonomic base $\left[\mathbf{e}_a,\mathbf{e}_b\right]=0$ the coordinates are

$$ T{^a_{\ \ bc}}e_a=\nabla_b e_c-\nabla_c e_b=(\Gamma^a_{\ cb}-\Gamma^a_{\ bc})e_a $$

due to $ \nabla_b\mathbf{e}_c=\Gamma^a_{\ \ cb}\mathbf{e}_a$. This result is different from the general result

$$ T^a_{\ \ bc}= \Gamma^a_{bc}-\Gamma^a_{cb}. $$

Where am I wrong in this calculations?

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ This looks fine to me. $\endgroup$ – Lawrence B. Crowell Jul 10 '17 at 19:39
  • $\begingroup$ The definition is actually $\nabla_b e_c = \Gamma^a_{bc}$ $\endgroup$ – Slereah Jul 10 '17 at 19:51
  • $\begingroup$ @Slereah according to Wikipedia it is not, if i'm not mistaken wheeler too uses my convention $\endgroup$ – raskolnikov Jul 10 '17 at 20:03
  • $\begingroup$ @Slereah hawking in the structure of space time uses my $\endgroup$ – raskolnikov Jul 10 '17 at 20:04
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ The answer is of course that there are varying sign conventions for torsion/curvature and varying conventions for the definition of $\Gamma^i{}_{jk}$. $\endgroup$ – Ryan Unger Jul 11 '17 at 0:24
3
$\begingroup$

It is just a matter of convention. MTW uses the convention that you have followed. Others, like Wald, use different one. Just a nuisance.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Ok, but if I want to use my convention $\nabla_b e_c = \Gamma^a_{cb}$ and to be self consistent with the definition of $\mathbf{T}$ with covariant derivative what I have to do? Because if I leave the definition as it is written in the question I have two different expression of the torsion tensor. May I have to put a minus in front of the definition of $\mathbf{T}$? (Indeed, I have to define the torsion tensor with the opposite sign convention $\mathbf{T}(\mathbf{X},\mathbf{Y})=-\left(\nabla_{\mathbf{X}}\mathbf{Y}-\nabla_{\mathbf{Y}}\mathbf{X} -\left[\mathbf{X},\mathbf{Y}\right]\right)$) $\endgroup$ – raskolnikov Jul 11 '17 at 8:46
  • $\begingroup$ Can be a correct solution? O it's wrong? $\endgroup$ – raskolnikov Jul 11 '17 at 8:47
1
$\begingroup$

The connection (in this case the Levi-Civita conn.) $\Gamma^\alpha{}_\beta$ is a one-form. We can express it as (in a coordinate (holonomic) basis) $$\Gamma^\alpha{}_\beta \equiv \Gamma_\mu{}^\alpha{}_\beta\, dx^\mu \tag 1$$ on another hand in the case of the spin-connection we have $$\omega^I{}_J \equiv \omega_\mu{}^I{}_J\, dx^\mu \tag 2$$ There are two types of the indices on the above equations. I would call the indices that appearLHS of the equations only: $\{\alpha,\beta\}$ for eqn(1) and $\{ I,J \}$ for eqn (2) the vector space indices or transformation indices (not the standard words), and I would call the index $\mu$ on both eqn. the form index.

Consider an equation write with only the vector space indices $$ \nabla {\bf e}^a = \Gamma^a{}_b {\bf e}_a \;.$$ There are two conventions to write in term with the form index

CONVENTION 1 $$ \nabla_c {\bf e}^a = \Gamma_c{}^a{}_b {\bf e}_a =: \Gamma^a_{\underline{c}b}{\bf e}_a\;,$$ where the underline indicate that it is a form index.

CONVENTION 2 $$ \nabla_c {\bf e}^a = \Gamma^a{}_{bc} {\bf e}_a =: \Gamma^a_{b \underline{c}}{\bf e}_a\;,$$ where the underline indicate that it is a form index. In the both case $c$ is a form index.

If you notice that which index is a form index you will never confuse.

Your second equation $$T{^a_{\ \ bc}}e_a=\nabla_b e_c-\nabla_c e_b=(\Gamma^a_{\ cb}-\Gamma^a_{\ bc})e_a \tag 3$$ is obviously use the CONVENTION 2 , we can write $$T{^a_{\ \ bc}}e_a=\nabla_b e_c-\nabla_c e_b=(\Gamma^a_{\ c\underline b}-\Gamma^a_{\ b\underline c})e_a \tag 4$$ but your third equation us the CONVENTION 1 we can write it as $$ T^a_{\ \ bc}= \Gamma^a_{\underline b c}-\Gamma^a_{\underline c b}. \tag 5 $$

$T^a_{\ \ bc}$ in (4) and (5) are the same.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.