0
$\begingroup$

Hi I'm trying to derive the Compton scattering formula and I don't understand where I'm going wrong. I keep getting that the momentum of the outgoing photon is equal to the momentum of the incoming photon (and thus their wavelengths are the same) which I know (intuitively and from the actual formula given) is wrong. If anyone could point out where I went wrong that would be great. Thanks a lot

$E_e$ is the energy of the still electron.

my workings so far where$E_e$ is the energy of the still electron.

$\endgroup$

2 Answers 2

4
$\begingroup$

We can derive the Compton scattering formula using the 4-momentum. The 4-momentum before the collision is equal to the 4-momentum after the collision: $$\tag{1}P_{b}=P_{a}\label{1}$$ The 4-momentum before the collision is given by $P_{\gamma}+P_{e}$ and the 4-momentum after the collision is given by $P'_{\gamma}+P'_{e}$. In general case, the 4-momentum components are: $$\tag{2}p_{\mu}=\left(\frac{E}{c},\vec{p}\right)\label{2}$$ The dot product of 4-momentum with itself is: $$\tag{3}p_{\mu}\cdot p^{\mu}=\frac{E^2}{c^2}-p^2=m^2c^2\label{3}$$ Because photons are massless, the dot product of their 4-momentum is zero. We can rewrite equation (\ref{1}) in terms of photon and electron 4-momenta: $$\tag{4}P_{\gamma}+P_{e}=P'_{\gamma}+P'_{e}\label{4}$$ Rearranging equation (\ref{4}) and squaring: $$\tag{5}\left(P_{\gamma}+P_{e}-P'_{\gamma}\right)^2=\left(P'_{e}\right)^2\label{5}$$ Considering that the incoming photon is traveling along the $x$ axis, we can write its 4-momentum as $P_{\gamma}=\left(\frac{E_{\gamma}}{c},p_{\gamma},0,0\right)$. After the collision, the photon is scattered and will have a spatial momentum component in both $x$ and $y$ direction, so its 4-momentum can be written as $P'_{\gamma}=\left(\frac{E'_{\gamma}}{c},p'_{\gamma}\cdot \cos(\theta),p'_{\gamma}\cdot\sin(\theta),0\right)$. Also, considering the electron at rest before the collision, its 4-momentum is $P_{e}=\left(\frac{E_{e}}{c},0,0,0\right)$. Going back to the equation (\ref{5}) and using the 4-momentum expressions we obtain: $$\tag{6}0+m^2c^2+0+2\cdot\frac{E_{\gamma}E_{e}}{c^2}-2\left(\frac{E_{\gamma}E'_{\gamma}}{c^2}-p_{\gamma}\cdot p_{\gamma}'\cdot\cos(\theta)\right)-2\cdot\frac{E'_{\gamma}E_{e}}{c^2}=m^2c^2\label{6}$$ $$\tag{7}2\cdot\frac{E_{\gamma}E_{e}}{c^2}-2\cdot\frac{E'_{\gamma}E_{e}}{c^2}=2\left(\frac{E'_{\gamma}E_{\gamma}}{c^2}-p_{\gamma}\cdot p_{\gamma}'\cdot\cos(\theta)\right)\label{7}$$ $$\tag{8}E_{e}\left(E_{\gamma}-E'_{\gamma}\right)=E_{\gamma}E'_{\gamma}-p_{\gamma}c\cdot p_{\gamma}'c\cdot\cos(\theta)\label{8}$$ $$\tag{9}mc^2\left(\frac{hc}{\lambda}-\frac{hc}{\lambda'}\right)=\frac{hc}{\lambda}\frac{hc}{\lambda'}\left(1-\cos(\theta)\right)\label{9}$$ $$\tag{10}\left(\lambda'-\lambda\right)\frac{hc}{\lambda\lambda'}mc^2=\frac{hc}{\lambda}\frac{hc}{\lambda'}\left(1-\cos(\theta)\right)\label{10}$$ So we get the Compton scattering formula: $$\tag{11}\lambda'-\lambda=\frac{h}{mc}\left(1-\cos(\theta)\right)\label{11}$$

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

enter image description here

This is my derivation of it; hopefully you’ll find it useful. You’re work seemed right until you equated the two expressions for $P_e^2c^2$

$\endgroup$
3
  • $\begingroup$ Hi sorry how did I equate them wrong? $\endgroup$
    – Thomas
    May 27, 2017 at 15:45
  • $\begingroup$ It appears you equated them right but the left hand side of that equation (what you got from energy) is carried out in your work as if it were a vector; it should be carried out as a scalar $\endgroup$ May 27, 2017 at 16:05
  • $\begingroup$ Ok thanks I'll carry that through and see if it works. $\endgroup$
    – Thomas
    May 27, 2017 at 17:29

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.