0
$\begingroup$

Before I ask this question I must include some necessary background information as follows:

In a simple quantum mechanical treatment of Hydrogen, all the states with the same value of principle quantum number $n$ are degenerate as they have the same energy. The total degeneracy of all the states with a given value of is $2n^2$ and this can be shown as follows:

First, lets consider (for reference mostly) the relevant quantum numbers for Hydrogen for this problem:

$n$: Principle quantum number ($n\ge 1$; integer values)

$\ell$: Orbital angular momentum quantum number ($0\le\ell\le n-1$; integer values)

$m_{\ell}$: Magnetic quantum number ($-\ell\le m_{\ell}\le \ell$; integer values)

$m_s$: Spin projection quantum number ($-s\le m_s\le s$; for our case $m_s=\pm \frac12$)


The table for the allowed quantum numbers are:

Table of allowed quantum numbers

From the table above you can easily see that for a given $n$ the sum of the associated $m_{\ell}$ values for each $\ell$ will give $n^2$. Or written more compactly since each $\ell$ has $2\ell + 1$ values for $m_{\ell}$:

$$\sum_{\ell=0}^{\ell=n-1}(2\ell + 1)= n^2$$

Now we note that there are two possible values for $m_s$ (which I didn't bother to put in the table as it is tedious) so we multiply the above expression by $2$ to get the answer of $2n^2$.


The above was done in the without considering Spin-Orbit coupling. When spin-orbit coupling is taken into account, each $n$, $\ell$ state gives rise to two levels with total angular momentum $j=\ell \pm \frac12$

Show that the total number of states with the same values of $n$ and $\ell$ is unchanged. This illustrates the general point that recoupling the angular momenta never changes the total number of states available.

First I will quote the solution to this and then explain which part I don't understand:

The state $n,\ell$ has a degeneracy of $2(2\ell+1)$. When it is split into two states with $j=\ell-\frac12$ and $j=\ell +\frac12$, the degeneracies of these states are $\color{red}{2\ell}$ $\,\color{red}{\text{&}}$ $\,\color{red}{2\ell + 2}$, so the total degeneracy is still $4\ell +2$. Since this holds for each value of $\ell$, it holds for the complete set of states having the same value of $n$.


Firstly, I understand why the state $n,\ell$ has a degeneracy of $2(2\ell+1)$, this is because there are two possible values of $m_{s}$ for a given $\ell$ and there are $2\ell +1$ values of $m_{\ell}$ which multiply to give $2(2\ell+1)$.

The part of the solution I don't understand is marked in red.

After the $n,\ell$ state splits into $2$ states why must these states have degeneracies $\color{red}{2\ell}$ and $\,\color{red}{2\ell + 2}$?

Put in another way; Why not split as $\ell$ and $3\ell +2$ for example which sum to give the required $4\ell +2$ or $\ell + 1$ and $3\ell +1$?

I fear I am missing something very simple here.

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

Let's start from the beginning then. $\overrightarrow{L} $ and $\overrightarrow{S} $ are vectors like any other, but they can only take integer length values that we call $\ell$ and $s$.

$m_l$ and $m_s$ are the projection of the vector in the z direction usually. $m_\ell$ can only take integer values from $-\ell$ when the vector $\overrightarrow{L} $ is parallel to z but into the opposite direction and as it gets rotated it gains +1 because it's only integers (quantum mechanics) when it's orthogonal to the z axis it's $0$ then when it's parallel it is $\ell$. so it can take $(2\ell +1)$ values.

So then $j$ is defined as $\overrightarrow{J}=\overrightarrow{L}+\overrightarrow{S} $ and $m_j$ is the projection. $j$ can take specific values $j=|\ell-s|,(|\ell-s|+1),..,|\ell+s|$ depending on the angle between these two vectors.

$m_j$ itself has $(2j+1)$ values. Where you can replace $j$ by its value.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ " they can only take integer length values that we call ℓ and s. " No, $\vec{S}$ has a half-integer quantum number, $s=\frac{1}{2}$. $\endgroup$ – Bill N May 27 '17 at 19:52
  • $\begingroup$ I mean discrete values. $\endgroup$ – Ismasou May 27 '17 at 20:29
  • $\begingroup$ @Ismasou That's some nice background material, but I don't think you're answering the question: "After the $n,\ell$ state splits into $2$ states why must these states have degeneracies $\color{red}{2\ell}$ and $\,\color{red}{2\ell + 2}$"? $\endgroup$ – BLAZE May 28 '17 at 11:41
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ It's what I commented, every $j$ state has degeneracy $2j+1$ and when $j=\ell + 1/2$ you replace $j$ by it's value in $2j+1=2(\ell +1/2)+1=2\ell +1+1 $ how more clearly do you want? $\endgroup$ – Ismasou May 28 '17 at 11:45

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.