I have heard that one can recover classical mechanics from quantum mechanics in the limit the $\hbar$ goes to zero. How can this be done? (Ideally, I would love to see something like: as $\hbar$ goes to zero, the position wavefunction reduces to a delta function and that the Schrodinger equation/Feynman path integral reduces to the Newtonian/Lagrangian/Hamiltonian equations of motion.)
The short answer: No, classical mechanics is not recovered in the $\hbar \rightarrow 0$ limit of quantum mechanics.
The paper What is the limit $\hbar \rightarrow 0$ of quantum theory? (Accepted for publication in the American Journal of Physics) found that
Our final result is then that NM cannot be obtained from QT, at least by means of a mathematical limiting process $\hbar \rightarrow 0$ [...] we have mathematically shown that Eq. (2) does not follow from Eq. (1).
"NM" means Newtonian Mechanics and "QT" quantum theory. Their "Eq. (1)" is Schrödinger equation and "Eq. (2)" are Hamilton equations. Page 9 of this more recent article (by myself) precisely deals with the question of why no wavefunction in the Hilbert space can give a classical delta function probability.
The classical limit is achieved only if the quantum system is in nice enough states. The states in which the classical limit makes sense are called coherent states. For example, the Glauber coherent states of an anharmonic oscillator are labelled by the classical phase space coordinates $(q,p)$.
If the system is in a coherent state then for every observable $A$ with $\langle A\rangle = \overline A$, the variance $\langle (A- \overline A)^2 \rangle$ tens to zero in the limit $\hbar\to 0$. Moreover, the dynamics reduces in the limit to that of a classical system on the corresponding phase space.
For Glauber coherent state this is related to the classical limit of Wigner functions; see, e.g.,
But the above statement can be proved for many classes of coherent states and many phase spaces, not only for Glauber coherent states. For the case of coherent states related to Berezin quantization, see, e.g., http://arxiv.org/pdf/math-ph/0405065
There is a large number of highly cited papers on the classical limit, e.g.,
If one is really interested this essay by Lubos Motl explains how classical fields emerge from quantum mechanical ones.
I quote the introduction:
After a very short summary of the rules of quantum mechanics, I present the widely taught "mathematical limit" based on the smallness of Planck's constant. However, that doesn't really fully explain why the world seems classical to us. I will discuss two somewhat different situations which however cover almost every example of a classical logic emerging from the quantum starting point:
Classical coherent fields (e.g. light waves) appearing as a state of many particles (photons)
Decoherence which makes us interpret absorbed particles as point-like objects and which makes generic superpositions of macroscopic objects unfit for well-defined questions about classical facts
Qmechanics' link gives a good illustration of the classical limit of the Schrodinger equation.
Re your question about position: it's possible to get the position to arbitrary accuracy in quantum mechanics. The problem is that the uncertainty principle means the momentum becomes infinitely uncertain. As $\hbar \rightarrow 0$ it becomes possible to get both the position and momentum to abitrary accuracy.
no, the wavefunction doesn't approach the delta function in the classical limit. the wavefunction packet still spreads, and gets entangled with the environment. What textbooks don't tell you is you need decoherence to get to the classical limit.
protected by Qmechanic♦ Jun 23 '16 at 9:56
Thank you for your interest in this question.
Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).
Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?