So recently, in chat, I was interested in about what if our universe contains only one CTC (thus making it unlike the Gödel metric, van Stockum dust where there can be more than one CTCs found) and that is the time dimension of the whole universe wrapped back onto itself (meanwhile the spatial dimensions are free to have any topologies so that the resulting spacetime satisfy the einstein field equations. However, I figure I should put this as a question on the main site because it seemed to cover many things.

Suppose this universe is cyclic and include a big bounce (thus both the big bang and big crunch exists), that is, it only differs with what we knew about our universe in that there is only one CTC that is due to the global time direction of the universe looping back to itself. More precisely, any comoving observers will agree that the CTC lies entirely along the time direction.

  1. It is said in the chat that there are nonlocal experiments one can perform to check for CTCs. What are some examples and are they applicable to CTC of this size?

  2. It is also discussed that the CMB in such a universe will contain complex patterns such as the face of he prophet Zarathustra. Are there some examples reference I can read about CMB pattern searches implying about the temporal topology of the universe?

  3. How can we distinguish this type of CTC spacetime with a non CTC spacetime that is also cyclic and also has big bounce as part of its history?

  4. Do such CTC suffer from usual divergence problems of smaller CTCs given how its large size and relativity will allow the fields to not get accumulated easily in a small region due to travelling many times in the CTC?

  • $\begingroup$ I think this is too vaguely defined to be answered. A CTC is always in the time direction for the observer following that curve, but not all observers will agree on the time axis. So you cannot simply say the universe has a CTC in the time direction unless you qualify it e.g. all comoving observers will agree the CTC is in the time direction. $\endgroup$ – John Rennie Mar 13 '17 at 17:58
  • $\begingroup$ @John Rennie. The light cone in GR is invariant, and timelike curves are always timelike in any coordinate system. $ds^2$ is a scalar invariant. CTCs are so for any observer. Maybe I misunderstood what you are saying. Or I'm wrong on some basic GR. Still, the questions does seem to me a little too much, it is not an easy answer. For non local tests, I'm pretty sure it would depend on the size of the universe, whether you'd ever see a CTC effect. And if he's asking from a chat, why doesn't he do some research first? And the face of Zarathustra? I can't tell if he's serious or not $\endgroup$ – Bob Bee Mar 14 '17 at 3:56

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.