Conservation of angular momentum: particle hitting the edge of a rod I am considering a problem where there is a rod at rest on a smooth table, and a particle is incident on the end of the rod with some given speed. The particle collides with the rod and sticks to the end of the rod. I am thinking about the subsequent motion of the system. So far, I think:


*

*The centre of mass of the combined system will now continue at a constant velocity in the same direction as the incident particle, and with a speed such as to conserve the linear momentum.

*Since the centre of mass must continue on at a constant velocity, any rotation, if it occurs, must be about the centre of mass of the new/combined system.

*There must be some rotation because the speed of the particle is reduced. Therefore the incident particle has received an impulse, and must have exerted an impulse on the end of the rod. This would provide an angular impulse about the centre of mass of the system, and therfore there must be rotation about the centre of mass.


However how can this be? The initial angular momentum of the system is zero as there is no rotation, and yet afterwards there is some angular momnetum as the system has rotation. What am I missing here?
 A: The angular momentum will be conserved.  It will be different depending on which frame of reference you are in, but it will be preserved.
Assume that the particle is traveling parallel to the edge of the table, with speed V.
Assume that the end of the rod that the particle strikes is a distance H away from the edge of the table.
Now take a coordinate system with the x axis aligned on the edge of the table.
Before striking the rod, the particle, mass M, has angular velocity HMV.
After the collision, the combined system will still have angular momentum HMV.
The angular momentum of the system will have two contributions.  One contribution will be the center of mass of the system moving parallel to the path of the original particle.  The other contribution will be the rotation of the combined system about the center of mass.
Note that you could choose a coordinate system where the x axis is in line with the initial path of the particle.  In this system, the initial angular momentum is zero.  After the collision, the two contributions to the angular momentum will be in opposite directions so that the angular momentum is still zero.
