1
$\begingroup$

I'm trying to understand conservation of linear momentum and collisions. I've arrived at a contradiction in my derivation of final, post collision velocities for two masses – the force derivation and momentum derivation of final velocity differ and I'm looking for some expert insight into what I did wrong.

Let us have two masses $m_1$ and $m_2$ with positions $x_1<x_2$ and initial, pre collision velocities $v_{i1}>0$ and $v_{i2}=0$. The only way to cause an object to accelerate is to apply a force to it. Experimentally, when $m_1$ and $m_2$ collide, $m_1$ accelerates in the positive direction of the x-axis, and $m_1$ decelerates; final velocities are $v_{1f}<v_{1i}\approx 0$ and $v_{2f}>v_{2i}$ . So where do we get this force which causes the decelerations.

I'm thinking that while $m_1$ has a zero acceleration, it has an effective force as it gains momentum which is active during the collision. Because $\dot{v_1}=\dot{v_2}=0$, the net force is zero and we therefore have conservation of linear momentum:

$$P_{\text{initial}}=P_{\text{final}}\\=p_{1i}+p_{2i}\\=p_{1f}+p_{2f}\tag{1}$$

Because $F=\frac{dp}{dt}=m\frac{dv}{dt}$, we have

$Ft=mv=p \tag{2}$

Defining $t_1$ as the duration that $m_1$ has held a constant velocity $v_{1i}$ and and substituting $t_1,m_1,v_{1i}$ into $(2)$ we have initial force on collision $F_i=\frac{m_1v_{1i}}{t_i}$. This tells us that momentum increases with time, but initial force on collision decreases.

Defining $t_2$ as the time when the collison is over (and $t_1$ initial time of collision), we have $$ x_1(t)=\int^{t_2}_{t_1}\left[v_{1i}+\int^{t_2}_{t_1}\left[-\frac{v_{1i}}{t}\right]\right]dt^2\tag{3} $$ and

$$ x_2(t)=\int^{t_2}_{t_1}\int^{t_2}_{t_1}\left[\frac{m_1v_{1i}}{m_2t}\right]dt^2\tag{4} $$ Because at the end of the collision $x_1<x_2$, we can solve for the duration of the collision using the following mathematica code:

ta = 10
m1 = 100
m2 = 1
v1 = 2

Remove[x1]
Remove[x2]
x1[t_] := Integrate[v1 + Integrate[-v1/t, t], t]
x2[t_] := Integrate[Integrate[m1*v1/(m2*ta), t], t]

FindRoot[x1[a] - x2[a] + 10^-6, {a, 0.0001}]

Yielding $t_c\approx 0$.

From these two equations (3) and (4), we can set
$$ v_1(t)=\int^{t_2}_{t_1}\left[v_{1i}-\frac{v_{1i}}{t}\right]dt\\ v_2(t)=\int^{t_2}_{t_1}\left[\frac{m_1v_{1i}}{m_2t}\right]dt $$ Therefore, we should get $v_1f\approx v_2f \approx 0$.

But law of conservation of momentum tells us otherwise. $$ v_{2f}=\left(\frac{2m_1}{m_1+m_2}\right)v_{1i} $$

$$ v_{1f}=\left(\frac{m_1-m_2}{m_1+m_2}\right)v_{1i} $$

I really have no idea what false assumption I am making.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Actually now I realize that $t_c\approx 0$ is not true. This is the point of my error $\endgroup$ – theideasmith Oct 28 '16 at 7:42
0
$\begingroup$

Experimentally, when $m_1$ and $m_2$ collide, $v_2$ accelerates in the positive direction of the x-axis, even when $v_1$ is constant.

This does not make sense.
If you have a collision then $v_1$ must change.
In terms of momentum if $m_2$ has gained momentum because it has accelerated then $m_1$ must lose momentum and so its velocity must change.

The two forces involved are the force on mass 1 due to mass 2 and the equal in magnitude but opposite in direction force on mass 2 due to mass 1. At all times they are equal and opposite so the impulses, $\int Fdt$, (which is equal to the change in momentum) the two masses experience are also equal and opposite.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.