I'm dealing with an asymmetric potential well which is given by, $$ \begin{array}{ll} V = 0 &\text{for} \, x < 0 \\ V = -V_0 & \text{for} \, 0 \leq x < d \\ V = 4V_0 & \text{for} \, x\geq d \end{array} $$

The task is to find the least value of $d$ for which a bound state exists. I know that $E<0$ for a bound state. I've got the equation which quantifies the energy,

$$\dfrac{\cos(kd) +\frac{\alpha}{\kappa}\sin(kd)}{-\sin(kd) + \frac{\alpha}{\kappa}\cos(kd)} = -\dfrac{\kappa}{\beta}$$ where $$\hbar\kappa = \sqrt{2m(E + V_0)}; \hbar\alpha = \sqrt{-2mE}; \hbar\beta = \sqrt{2m(4V_0-E)} \, .$$

How can I proceed to get the minimum value of $d$?

  • $\begingroup$ I would suggest the Dirac potential, but that is symmetric, if you Google "More on the Asymmetric Infinite Square Well: Energy Eigenstates with Zero Curvature", you should get an associated pdf which deals with modifying the standard well to something that resembles what your question is. $\endgroup$
    – user108787
    Commented Oct 18, 2016 at 17:17

2 Answers 2


disclaimer: There may be better ways to do this. This was just the first thing to pop into my head.

Solve your equation for d=, then differentiate and minimize.

First, because this gets messy fast, I'll use "t" to mean "$\tan(\kappa d)$." I'll do the same with "$s$" and "$c$."

$-\dfrac{\kappa}{\beta}=\dfrac{c+\dfrac{\alpha}{\kappa} s}{-s+\dfrac{\alpha}{\kappa}c}\\ .\\ =\dfrac{c+\dfrac{\alpha}{\kappa} s}{-s+\dfrac{\alpha}{\kappa}c}\cdot\dfrac{\dfrac{\kappa}{c}}{\dfrac{\kappa}{c}}\\ .\\ =\dfrac{\kappa+\alpha t}{-\kappa t+\alpha}\\ .\\ =\dfrac{-\kappa-\alpha t}{\kappa t-\alpha}\\ .\\ =\dfrac{-\kappa-\alpha t}{\kappa t-\alpha}\cdot\dfrac{\kappa}{\kappa}\\ .\\ =\dfrac{-\kappa^2-\alpha\kappa t}{\kappa(\kappa t-\alpha)}\\ .\\ =\dfrac{-\alpha(\kappa t-\alpha)-\alpha^2-\kappa^2}{\kappa(\kappa t-\alpha)}\\ .\\ \text{(This step takes a bit of trying to force a form, but it's a form like the denominator, so it shouldn't be too magical.)}\\ .\\ =\dfrac{-\alpha^2-\kappa^2}{\kappa(\kappa t-\alpha)}-\dfrac{\alpha}{\kappa}.$

From here, you have an expression with just one tangent function in it, so you can invert, differentiate, set to zero, and be on your way.

$\dfrac{-\alpha^2-\kappa^2}{\kappa(\kappa t-\alpha)}-\dfrac{\alpha}{\kappa}=-\dfrac{\kappa}{\beta}$


Assuming that the given equations are correct (with the correction $k=\kappa$). the minimum energy for a bound state is $E=0$ because this is the limit (highest energy for the wave function in the $V=0$ region for being a damped wave, i.e. where the real $\alpha$, corresponding to a damped wave, becomes zero and turns imaginary (propagating wave). Because of the higher potential $4V_0$, the damping constant $\beta$ is definitely real in the other region outside the well. With $E=\alpha=0$ the characteristic equation becomes $$\dfrac{\cos(\kappa d) }{\sin(\kappa d)} =\cot{(\kappa d)}= \dfrac{\kappa}{\beta}=\frac{1}{2}$$ From this follows $$\kappa d=arccot{(\frac{1}{2})}$$ Thus the lowest $d$ for a bound state is given by $$d=\hbar\frac{arccot{(\frac{1}{2})}}{ \sqrt{2mV_0}}$$ Note: For $arccot{(\frac{1}{2})}= arctan{(2)}$, the principal (i.e. lowest) value has to be taken.

  • $\begingroup$ I don't get why minimum energy for bound state is $E=0$. Even if $E<0$, $\alpha$ is still real and there will be still exponential damping. $\endgroup$
    – crimson
    Commented Oct 18, 2016 at 20:06
  • $\begingroup$ When $E<0$ then you have a real $\alpha$ corresponding to a damped wave. When $E=0$, $\alpha=0$, and when $E>0$, $\alpha$ becomes imaginary corresponding to a propagating wave. $\endgroup$
    – freecharly
    Commented Oct 18, 2016 at 20:32

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.