0
$\begingroup$

Is it possible to prove that a massless string has the same tension throughout, through contradiction? I've looked through several proofs online, such as

Consider a massless string being pulled horizontally towards right. The forces acting on a tiny bit of the string having mass Δm will be T1 towards right and T2 towards left.The force equation will be T2-T1=Δma where 'a' is the acceleration of the tiny bit of the string .Now since Δm=0 ∴ T2=T1 i.e tension on either side of any arbitrary mass of the string is zero.In other words tension throughout the string is constant.

Reference http://www.physicsforums.com/threads/tension-in-a-massless-string.708085/

This proof didn't make sense to me, because all it seemed to do was proove that T2=T1 when the mass was 0.

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

The proof you've shown proves that -for a given bit of the string, $\Delta m_1$- we know that the tension acting to the right, T1 must equal the tension to the left, T2 (Due to Newton's SECOND law).

Now, consider the piece of string directly the right of the first peice we were considering. Call it $\Delta m_2$. This is actually the piece of mass responsible for the force T1 onto the first mass $\Delta m_1$. Since T1 puts a force to the right on mass $\Delta m_1$ there must be an equal and opposite force acting from $\Delta m_1$ onto $\Delta m_2$, call this force T3. So we know that T3 acts to the LEFT onto $\Delta m_2$ and also that T3=T1 (Due to Newton's THIRD law).

Finally, we know there is a force T4 which acts to the RIGHT on $\Delta m_2$ and that (by the same Newton's SECOND law argument as above) must equal to T3 for a massless string.

So in summary:

T1 = T2 (Newton's Second law, your argument above) T3 = T2 (Newton's Third law between the two elements of the string) T3 = T4 (Newton's Second law applying your argument above to the second piece of string)

So you can go along this string the whole way and you will see that each element of the string has a force T acting to the left and force T acting to the right. You will see that the force to the left always equals the force to the right but furthermore, you will see that T is the same all throughout the string.

A little bit shorter proof by contradiction: Say the tension is T1 in one part of the string and T2 in another part. Well then there must be a piece of the string in between those two sections of string where the tensions acting to the left and right are imbalanced. The piece of string would be a contradiction to the argument you've given above that all pieces of string must have balanced forces on them to satisfy Newton's second law.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.