2
$\begingroup$

This question is about the equation describing the net dipole moment for an arbitrary number of point charges.

Here's what I understand:

For two point charges $q$ and $-q$ with positions $\mathbf{r_1}$ and $\mathbf{r_2}$, the dipole moment is $$\mathbf{p} = q\mathbf{r_1} +- q\mathbf{r_2} = q\mathbf{d}$$ where we define $\mathbf{d}$ to point from the negative charge to the positive charge.

It would seem to me, incorrectly, that to find the net dipole moment of a set of $N$ point charges you just add up the individual dipole moments between every pair of them. I'll call this $\mathbf{p_{wrong}}$ for obvious reasons.

$$\mathbf{p_{wrong}} = \sum_{j=1}^{N-1}\left(\sum_{k=j+1}^{N} q_j\mathbf{r_j} + q_k\mathbf{r_k} \right) $$

which,for 3 charges would be

$(q_1\mathbf{r_1} + q_2\mathbf{r_2}) + (q_1\mathbf{r_1} + q_3\mathbf{r_3}) + (q_2\mathbf{r_2} + q_3\mathbf{r_3})$

My textbook and all sources I have consulted list the below as the correct answer with very little explanation.

$$\mathbf{p_{right}} = \sum_i^N q_i\mathbf{d_i} $$

I can't for the life of me see how this is right. In this context, I don't even understand what $\mathbf{d_i}$ means. Is my expression somewhow equivalent, is $\mathbf{d_i}$ just the absolute position vector of each point charge, or am I completely out in the weeds here?

$\endgroup$
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Look back at center of mass to get an idea. $\endgroup$ – AHusain Jun 23 '16 at 2:06
  • $\begingroup$ center of mass, if my memory serves is $$\mathbf{r_{cm}} = \frac{1}{M_{tot}} \sum(m_i\mathbf{r_i})$$. So then it seems you're saying it would be $$\mathbf{p} = \sum(q_i\mathbf{r_i}$$ $\endgroup$ – MmmQuarks Jun 23 '16 at 20:26
1
$\begingroup$

Yes, ${\bf d}_i$ simply means the absolute position vector for the $i$th point charge. It turns out that if the total charge is zero (i.e. $\sum_i q_i = 0$), then the value of this vector quantity does not depend on your choice of origin. However, this fact is not necessarily immediately obvious to a beginning student, so your textbooks should have explained why it is true.

It's better to memorize and think about that the general formula ${\bf p} := \sum_i^N q_i {\bf d}_i$, and to consider the case of two opposite point charges as a special case, than to start from the special case and try to generalize to an arbitrary number of charges.

$\endgroup$
0
$\begingroup$

In the expression $$\mathbf{p_{right}} = \sum_i^N q_i\mathbf{d_i} $$ you are summing dipoles and assuming that the net charge is zero so the sum is independent of the choice of reference point.
So $q_i$ is the charge on the dipole and $\mathbf{d_i} $ is the position vector of the positive charge relative to the negative charge.

If you have two charges $+q$ and $-q$ at positions $\mathbf{r_+}$ and $\mathbf{r_-}$ relative to a reference point then the dipole moment is $+q\mathbf{r_+} - q \mathbf{r_-} = +q(\mathbf{r_+} - \mathbf{r_-}) = q\mathbf{d} $, thus independent of the reference point.

The Wikipedia article Electric Dipole Moment is possibly worth consulting as is the answer to this question and the link therein provided by @EmilioPisanty where monopoles and multipoles are mentioned.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Here's my confusion. This is supposed to hold for an arbitrary number of point charges so when you say: "$q_I$ is the charge on the dipole and $\mathbf{d_i}$ is the position vector of the positive charge relative to the negative charge" how do I know which pair to use to calculate $\mathbf{d_i}$? Also what if there are no two charges $q$ and $q\prime$ for which $q = -q\prime$ ? What do I use as $q_i$ then? Does $\mathbf{p_{right}}$ only apply to systems of even number of point charges where every point charge has an equal and opposite point charge? $\endgroup$ – MmmQuarks Jun 23 '16 at 20:22

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.