Suppose we have a point source of photons located somewhere in space.

So when the photons are released their location is well known, $\Delta x \approx 0, \Delta y \approx 0, \Delta z \approx 0$

Heisenberg's uncertainty principle tells us: $\Delta p_x \Delta x \ge \dfrac{\hbar}{2}$, and same with y and z axes.

This tells me that $p_x,p_y,p_z$ can take on any values (since the uncertainties in position is 0).

So the debroglie relation $\lambda = \dfrac{h}{\sqrt{p_x^2+p_y^2+p_z^2}}$ leads to an infinite spectrum of wavelengths.

Is my analysis correct or wrong? Can we have a monochromatic point source of photons?


The point dipole is an approximation from classical physics - note that it also involves an infinite field strength in its center, where the field amplitude is not differentiable. I think such a source is not compatible with the common approach to quantum mechanics.

If you take such a very small, subwavelength source, it is true that the evanescent near field around it consists of many components. Some of with have a very high spatial frequency - but they are not radiated, they just reside around the source.

In the contrary, the radiated wave is restricted by the dispersion relations in the surrounding medium to have only a certain wavelength at a given frequency. If the source operates for long enough, you get a very narrow spectrum of frequencies in the radiated wave - which essentially means that even the wave of a point dipole will have a single well-defined wavelength λ=c/f.

| cite | improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.