section 4, pages 6..9 is a proof of the spherical harmonics addition theorem.

Page 8 has eq.(25), an application of Laplace series:

$$Y_{lm}^*(\theta,\phi) = \sum_{m'=-l}^{l} B_{mm'} Y_{lm'}(\gamma,\beta).$$

This is just very confusing. I sort of get the idea of what $Y_{lm}^*(\theta,\phi)$ is. It is simply the usual spherical harmonic but just relating it to the vector $\vec{r}$ i.e. if we play around with $\vec{r}$ and let it point all different ways, and create a function that outputs the usual spherical harmonic tortoise shell values as $\vec{r}$ moves around..

But what is $Y_{lm'}(\gamma,\beta)$ on the right hand side? When you offset $\vec{r}$ from $\vec{r}'$ which is how you get $\gamma$ ($\gamma$ being defined as the angle between $\vec{r}$ and $\vec{r}'$ on page 7) then I guess we can define a spherical harmonic type function over the coordinates $(\gamma,\beta)$ analogously, but $\beta$ is arbitrary! When we line up $\vec{r}'$ with the $+z$ axis (creating a new coordinate system) we pick some $x$ and $y$ axes to go with the new coordinate system, but that choice is arbitrary and determines $\beta$.

Can anyone explain more sensibly what's going on here?

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Yes $\beta$ is ``arbitrary'', but if you continue to follow his proof you see that he integrates over the solid angle, so $\beta$ integrates out in the end. $\endgroup$ – Bill N Sep 8 '15 at 17:58

What he's really trying to say in eq.(25),

$$Y_{lm}^*(\theta,\phi) = \sum_{m'=-l}^{l} B_{mm'} Y_{lm'}(\gamma,\beta)$$,

is "Given the complex conjugate of an e.g. $l=l_0=10,m=m_0=+7$ tortoise shell (spherical harmonic), there exists a set of 21 coefficients (the $B$s) that constitute a linear combination of the 21 tortoise shells of $l_0=10$ but TILTED, such that this linear combination of TILTED tortoise shells sums to the original 'right side up' spherical harmonic $Y_{lm}^*(\theta,\phi)$."

This is a result of Laplace series.

Fine, but then he says "Now set $\gamma \rightarrow 0$ and we can solve for $B_{m_0=+7,m'=0}$" (because all the $B$s with $m' \neq 0$ go away).

But by his definition (see page 7), to say $\gamma=0$ means the right hand side $Y$s are not tilted at all with respect to the left hand side $Y$!

So the statement

${Y^*}_{l_0=10}^{m_0=+7} = B_{m_0=+7,m'=0} \sqrt{\dfrac{2l+1}{4\pi}}$

(see his work after eq.(27) on page 8) does not make sense to me. How could a $m_0=+7$ spherical harmonic = a constant?


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.