0
$\begingroup$

Lets say that I am on a spaceship moving with the speed of 0,90c and I am looking on my friend who stayed back on earth. My friend is looking on me.

From my perspective, my friend is moving 7 times slower then "normal" and from his perspective I am moving 7 times slower then "normal".

Lets say that seven years passes on earth which means that I am one year older and my friend is seven years older.

But if I was moving for one year and I was seeing him moving 7 times slower shouldn't he be 1/7 year older not 7?

Can someone explain that to me?

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Neither of you will appear only 1/7 year older: each of you will measure 7 years on your own clock and see 1 apparent year pas for the other. 1/7 of a year would be 49 times slower, not seven as you originally stated. $\endgroup$ – Asher Aug 26 '15 at 16:32
2
$\begingroup$

If you are abit more careful about making the statements, then "both perspectives" are actually correct. Let me be more concrete and explain.

Let $E$ be the one who stays on Earth and $S$ be the one who is on the spaceship. The first issue you have is you said "let's say seven years passes on Earth" - this is an ambiguous statement: from whose perspective?

Let's say seven years passes on Earth from $E$'s perspective. $E$ will indeed see $S$ to age only a year. Note that during this interval, $S$ will only see 1/7 years to have passed on Earth.

But wait a second, did I just say that $E$ sees $S$ to age slower and $S$ sees $E$ to age slower? Yes! And both are correct from their own perspective.

Hmm, but maybe you are still not very convinced. You might ask: how can $E$ be both 7 years older and 1/7 years older at the same time? The answer: $E$ is 7 years older from $E$'s frame, but 1/7 years older from $S$'s frame. These are two different frames, and one cannot just compare like this.

More concretely, from the viewpoint of $S$, all the clocks in $E$'s frame are at all moving slower BUT they start at different times (clocks at the 'rear' have a headstart). See bottom left of diagram. The $E$-clock that is staring right in front of the face of $S$ reads to $S$: 7 years elapsed. But the $E$-clock that is located on Earth reads to $S$: 1/7 years elapsed.

(You might have to download and zoom in to see the clock timings, especially the negative signs) enter image description here

Extension (to comment): What happens if $S$ turns back to Earth; when both $S$ and $E$ are on Earth, how can $E$ and $S$ both see each other to have aged less? This is known as the twin paradox. The correct "answer" is $E$ has aged 14 years and $S$ has aged 2 years. This was $E$'s perspective all along, so why is $S$'s perspective now "wrong"? The caveat is that when $S$ turns around to return to Earth, $S$ has changed inertia frame/has experienced acceleration. If you know how to deal with accelerating frames, you can compute that $S$ will perceive $E$ to suddenly age $13 \frac{5}{7}$ years during the short interval when $S$ turns around. So $S$'s perspective, when rightfully accounted for, will see $E$ to also age $1/7 + 13 \frac{5}{7} + 1/7 = 14$ years as well.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ The last paragraph is a bit hard to understand. But I have another question. If S will travel on his ship for two years and then come back on Earth he should see E 14 years older, right? How is that posiible if time on Earth will be 7 times slower then S time? $\endgroup$ – Krzysztof Majewski Aug 26 '15 at 9:09
  • $\begingroup$ Aha! I was going to talk about that. And I was going to draw a diagram to explain the last paragraph. I'll update in about an hour. $\endgroup$ – suncup224 Aug 26 '15 at 9:15
  • $\begingroup$ @KrzysztofMajewski hopefully this helps $\endgroup$ – suncup224 Aug 26 '15 at 9:41

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.