And a positively curved universe younger than a flat one?

I get that negatively curved means an open universe, and positively curved is a closed one. But how can this affect their age?

Is it because the geometry affects the +/- signs on the right hand side of the Friedmann equation? If so how?


Your question isn't quite right - not all closed universes are younger than all flat universes, and all open universes are not older than all flat universes.

As a reference Universe, pick your favourite flat Universe - the density may be in several components (matter, radiation, $\Lambda$), but it must be exactly critical.

Suppose we want an open universe - this means we need sub-critical energy density. Suppose we steal a little bit of energy density from $\Lambda$. This component drives expansion, so the universe had a slightly harder time expanding, and took a little longer to reach its present size: it is older than the reference flat universe. Conversely, if we steal a little bit of energy density from the matter component (which inhibits expansion), the universe had a slightly easier time expanding and reached its present size faster: it is younger than the reference flat universe. Likewise for the closed universe - we need super-critical energy density, and get the opposite effect of removing a bit of energy density from different components.

More generally, yes, you just need to look to the Friedmann equation. The age is:

$$t = \int_0^1\frac{{\rm d}a}{\dot{a}}$$

And you get $\dot{a}$ from:

$$\left(\frac{\dot{a}}{a}\right)^2 = \frac{8\pi G}{3}\left[\rho_{m,0}\left(\frac{a_0}{a}\right)^3+\rho_{r,0}\left(\frac{a_0}{a}\right)^4+\rho_{\Lambda,0}\right]-\frac{Kc^2}{a^2}$$

But you can't just look at the curvature term ($K=0$ is flat, $K=+1$ is closed, $K=-1$ is open) and draw a conclusion about the relative ages of various universes, because $K$ is not independent of the density parameters.

  • $\begingroup$ awesome that's really helpful $\endgroup$ – Tom Apr 29 '15 at 19:20

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.