4
$\begingroup$

I've assumed since the translational speed of the moon along its orbit undergoes the same boosts and reductions over its orbital course, the time between the apogee and the pedigee (and respectively, the time between the pedigee and the apogee) should be constant. However, according to this table, it seems they both range from 12 days to 16 days.

Does proximity of the moon/earth system to the Sun cause the moon to go faster along its orbit as well? The in-between times do not appear to increase during July/August (i.e. near Aphelion), so I guess that's not a contributing factor.

So, what is causing the moon to reach apogee/pedigee faster at one time and slower at other times?

edit: I've just found some info which may explain this phenomenon:

"The tidal effect of the Sun's gravitational field increases the eccentricity when the orbit's major axis is aligned with the Sun-Earth vector or, in other words, the Moon is full or new."

So, I would assume whenever the Moon is full or new, its orbit changes its shape to some extent, which causes the time spent between apogee and perigee to be inconstant. Am I correct? And is this the only reason?

$\endgroup$
4
$\begingroup$

The Moon's orbit would be nearly Keplerian were it not for the perturbing effects of the Sun. The time from perigee to perigee and from apogee to apogee wouldn't change, and the time from perigee to apogee would be exactly half the orbital period. What you are seeing are perturbing effects of the Sun on the Moon's orbit.

If you use push the site you found, http://www.timeanddate.com/astronomy/moon/distance.html, to just beyond 2015, you'll see that only 24.69 days transpire between the last lunar perigee of 2015 and the first lunar perigee of 2016. That's almost three days less than the average value of 27.55455 days. There's something curious going on here!

Below is a plot of the times between successive perigees (red curve) and successive apogees (blue curve). Note that the perigean anomalistic month is subject to significantly greater variations than is the apogean anomalistic month. Also note that the two curves have the same frequency (about 7 months) but are almost 180 degrees out of phase. These variations are the direct cause of the phenomenon you observed. You'll see a marked difference between perigee-to-apogee versus apogee-to-perigee when the time from perigee to successive perigee is changing fastest.

enter image description here

It's the Sun that makes these variations occur. The Sun makes the lunar apse line (the line from Earth to the Moon at perigee) precess. This, in combination with the way tidal forces themselves vary, makes the Moon's orbit more eccentric that normal when the lunar apse line (the line perigee to apogee) aligns with the syzygies (new moon or full moon), less eccentric than normal when the apse line is more or less orthogonal to the line from the Earth to the Sun. The perigean months are longest when perigee more or less coincides with a new or full moon, and shortest when perigee more or less coincides with the moon in its quarter phases.

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

Interesting question.

The earth/moon system around the sun certainly changes speed as the earth gets closer to are farther from the sun, but the Earth/Moon orbit the sun together so the direct effect on the Moons orbit regarding the earth's Apogee and Perigee would probobly be small.

I think a larger effect is the tidal effects on the moon's orbit around the earth from the sun.

To look at the math, as simple as possible - when the earth is at it's closest point to the sun, about 91.4 million miles, it's orbital speed is the square root of the change in distance, so it's 1.7% closer, it's speed is about 0.9% faster, and similarly, about 0.9% slower at the furthest point, so, taking 67,000 MPH as the average speed, the earth's fastest orbital speed is about 67,600 MPH and it's slowest about 66,400 - about 1,200 MPH difference, But that effects the earth and moon mostly equally.

If we ignore the Earth's elliptical orbit and set the earth at precisely 93 million miles from the sun, the moon is closest to the sun during the New moon (93 million minus 240,000) and furthest during the full moon, 93 million plus 240,000 miles - so it's a variation of about 0.26% in each direction, 0.52 total percentage change, which is about 0.26% change in speed. 0.26% of 67,000 MPH is about 170 miles per hour, so that is the potential change in the Moon's speed in relation to the earth based entirely on what is essentially the solar tidal effect. The Moon's average orbital speed is 2,300 MPH around the earth, so plus 85 MPH in each direction from the solar tug. - That's enough to throw off the cycle a bit. Not nearly enough to knock it out of orbit (that would be about 41.4% plus on top of the 2,300 MPH to reach escape velocity), but it's enough to create a wobble in the orbit, and my math is probobly pretty rough on this point.

Something else to consider is that Apogee and Perigree operate (almost) on the Sidereal lunar month, or 27.32 days while the full and new moon operate on the Synodic Lunar Month (29.53 days), so the Apogee essentially catches up to the full moon about once a year. I would think that's where the Solar tidal force has a bigger effect, not based on the Earth's apogee, but on the relation between the Moon's apogee to the Moon's position around the earth (full, half, quarter, new, etc). That seems most logical to me anyway, but I'm not 100% sure.

another way to look at this is the Hill Sphere, which is the area of orbital stability around an object. The Earth's Hill Sphere extends about 900,000 million miles. Beyond that, the sun wins. The moon is well within the Earth's Hill Sphere, but not so close to the earth that it's immune to fairly significant wobbles.

anyway - that's my best shot at this question. Orbital Mechanics get pretty complicated with 3 bodies. With 2 bodies, then yes, I think they should be like clockwork.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.