2
$\begingroup$

This is very hypothetical question. Consider all chemistry (even bio-chemistry) is just physics of valence electrons. Because solutions of Schroedinger equation for system of electrons and nuclei are highly anisotropic and directional ( like sp$^3$-hydridization ) you can at the end form structures like proteins and DNA.

The only stable structures bound by nuclear forces we currently know are around 250 nuclei of stable isotopes ( Am I right ?). All of them are basically just spherical clusters of nucleons (only few halo nuclei deviate from liquid drop model but just a little).

But is there any (even very speculative) possibility to form something more complex (perhaps like nuclear polymer), or is it completely exclude by laws of nature?

Possibly it is just matter of kinetics? Almost all nucleosynthetic processes (both natural and human made ) create new nuclei in excited state by harsh collisions. It is natural that such nuclei has a lot of excess energy to overcome activation barriers and create most stable but boring spherical clusters. It's a bit like doing chemistry in hot gas - you never create more complex molecules. Maybe if there would be an hypothetical method how to prepare such nuclear structures in gentle way ( cool, not excited ) it would be quite stable?

And even if it is not possible in normal conditions on earth, maybe such complex nuclear structures may exist on the surface of neutron stars, in phase transition from normal matter to nuclear matter. Is that what is called nuclear pasta?. ( I would like to read something )


By the way - is there any good book which discuss nuclear structure form the perspective close to chemist ( quantum chemist, chemical physicist ) - i.e. discussing everything in terms of "nuclear orbitals" (and it's shape) in analogy to atomic orbitals and molecular orbitals.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Is it not clear to me how do you imagine the form of those nuclear polymers, but take into account that nuclear forces are short ranged. Therefore, a hadron (neutron, proton) cannot gather around itself a whole additional cluster of hadrons. $\endgroup$ – Sofia Feb 12 '15 at 16:59
  • $\begingroup$ in chemical molecules the interactions are also rather short-ranged ( e.g. just nearest neighbour interaction in LCAO Hamiltonian are enought to describe 90% of binding energy ). This does not limit the long range order. $\endgroup$ – Prokop Hapala Feb 12 '15 at 22:40
1
$\begingroup$

Yes, there are phases of matter that correspond to your question that exist inside neutron stars and are known collectively as nuclear pasta.

The inner crust of a neutron star has densities $>4 \times 10^{14}$ kg m$^{-3}$ and consists of a lattice of extremely neutron-rich nuclei, surrounded by degenerate gases of neutrons and ultrarelativistic electrons that behave like fluids. The equilibrium composition and structure is found by forming the sum of the energy densities of these components and then minimising it with respect to the number densities of the nuclei, neutrons and protons, and the numbers of neutrons and protons in the nuclei, subject to baryon and charge conservation.

The energy density sum must include the rest mass energy of the nuclei, which is a function of the number of protons and neutrons, their binding energy plus modifications that account for the presence of the neutron fluid surrounding the nuclei that reduces the surface energy term and a negative term due the binding energy of the nuclear lattice.

Above densities of $\simeq 3\times10^{16}$ kg m$^{-3}$, nuclei probably start to lose their separate identities and spherical nature, forming elongated rods or planes of nuclear material -- nuclear pasta. Initially the nuclei are thought to group into "spaghetti" and then into "lasagna", where the sauce is provided by the gaseous free neutrons. As densities exceed $10^{17}$ kg m$^{-3}$, it is thought these roles reverse; the gaseous neutrons form into spaghetti like structures sourrounded by nuclear material and then finally, shortly before dissolution, the crust consists of nuclear material enclosing spherical bubbles of neutron gas.

Here is a schematic picture, due to Newton et al. (2011) that shows how the pasta phases develop with increasing density. As I show in some more detail below, the departure from an ordered lattice of spherical nuclei is expected to occur on the nuclei fill more than abut 1/10 of the volume.

Schematic of nuclear pasta

A few details

An approximate understanding of the process arises by considering the Bohr-Wheeler condition for the fission of nuclei. $$ E_{C}^{(0)} > 2 E_S\, , $$ where $E_{C}^{(0)}$ is the self-Coulomb energy of the nucleus and $E_S$ its surface energy term. When the Coulomb energy of the nucleus satisfies this inequality then it becomes energetically feasible for the nucleus to split.

$$ E^{(0)}_{C} = \frac{1}{4\pi \epsilon_0} \int_{0}^{r_N} \frac{q(r)}{r} \, dq \, , $$ where $r_N$ is the nuclear radius. If we assume the total charge $q=Ze$ and the charge (due to $Z$ protons) is spread uniformly in the nuclear volume, such that $q(r) = Ze(r/r_N)^3$ and hence $dq = 3Ze (r^2/r_{N}^{3})$, then this integral shows that $E^{(0)}_{C} = (3/5)(Z^2e^2/r_N)$.

However, in terms of the energtics of the gas as a whole, the nuclei are not isolated, but sit in a neutral Wigner-Seitz sphere, accompanied by $Z$ electrons distributed pseudo-uniformly, where $q_e(r) = -Ze(r/r_0)^3$, is the charge distribution of the electrons, and $r_0$ is the radius of the neutral Wigner-Seitz sphere. From this, it can be shown that the total Coulomb energy is $$ E_C = \frac{Z^2 E^2}{4\pi \epsilon_0}\left( \frac{3}{5r_N} + \frac{3}{5r_0} - \frac{3}{2r_0}\right)\, . $$ If we write the fraction of the volume occupied by the nuclei as $f = (r_N/r_0)^3$, we can rearrange this to give $$ E_C = E_{C}^{(0)}\left( 1 - \frac{3}{2} f^{1/3} \right)\, . \tag{1} $$

Now since $E_{C}^{(0)} \propto Z^2/r_N$ and $r_N \propto A^{1/3}$, where $A$ is the number of nucleons in each nucleus, then for a certain value of $Z/A$, the Coulomb energy per nucleon $E_C/A \propto A^{2/3}$. The surface energy term is proportional to the area of the nucleus, so $E_S/A \propto A^{-1/3}$. If we minimise the sum of these two terms with respect to $A$ as follows $$ \frac{\partial (E_{\rm tot}/A)}{\partial A} = \frac{\partial }{\partial A} \left( \alpha A^{2/3} + \beta A^{-1/3} \right) = 0\, \, $$ where $\alpha$ and $\beta$ are just arbitrary constants of proportionality. Solving this gives $2\alpha A^{2/3} = \beta A^{-1/3}$ and hence $2E_C = E_S$ at equilibrium.

If we put this into the Bohr-Wheeler condition and use equation (1) for $E_C$, then we find that $f > 1/8$. In other words the nuclei become unstable to fission and deformation once they fill about one tenth of the total volume, which corresponds to densities of $\sim 3 \times 10^{16}$ kg m$^{-3}$.

$\endgroup$
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ I was also reffering to nuclear pasta, but not knowing the derivation. Thank you for that. Still, the main point of my question was if this nuclear pasta or other exotic state of nuclear matter could have such complex structures as organic chemistry and biochemistry. And If I imagine it correctly ( as complex molecules of localized nucleons similar to atoms in organic molecules fixed at specific site / configuration ) or if the nature of nucleons in nuclear pasta is more abstract / elusive (delocalized, superfiluid ... ). Can it store some permanent structural information like DNA? $\endgroup$ – Prokop Hapala Dec 28 '15 at 9:14
  • $\begingroup$ @ProkopHapala I've told you (in some detail) what I know. Nuclear pasta is a theoretical construction at present. $\endgroup$ – Rob Jeffries Dec 28 '15 at 9:44

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.