4
$\begingroup$

We're currently deriving the Maxwell-Boltzmann speed distribution, but I'm struggling to squeeze out the right answer.

For the first exercise we have to derive the fraction of molecules travelling between speed $v$ and $v+\mathrm{d}v$.

Using the following equation: \begin{equation} q(v_x)\propto \mathrm{e}^{-m v_x^2/2kT}, \end{equation} (with $q$ the fraction of molecules travelling between $v_x$ and $v_x+\mathrm{d}v_x$) and \begin{equation} q(v_x,v_y,v_z)=q(v_x)\cdot q(v_y)\cdot q(v_z), \end{equation} I get $q(v)\mathrm{d}v\propto\mathrm{e}^{-mv^2/2kT}\mathrm{d}v$.

For the second part, we have to derive the expression for the region in velocity space comprised between $v$ and $v+\mathrm{d}v$. Because we're going from vector space to scalars: $v=|\vec{v}|$, I can represent all speed scalars in the plane, to justify $A=4\pi r^2$. Evaluating this last expression, I find $A=4\pi\left[(v+\mathrm{d}v)^2-v^2\right]$ for the desired region enclosed between limits $v$ and $v+\mathrm{d}v$.

Ideally both of these answers would now multiply to the Maxwell-Boltzmann speed distribution (minus normalization factor), but this doesn't seem to be the case: \begin{equation} p(v)\mathrm{d}v\propto\mathrm{e}^{-mv^2/2kT}\mathrm{d}v\cdot 4\pi\left(2v\mathrm{d}v +\mathrm{d}v^2\right). \end{equation} (Where $p$ should be the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution without normalization.) Contrary to most derivations, the way the question is asked very much disincentivizes using the expression $A=4\pi v^2$. How can I justify using this anyway ? It's clearly not the region enclosed by the limits given in the exercise. Secondly, the wording in the exercise explicitly mentions to multiply these two results, resulting in another factor $\mathrm{d}v$ that I can't explain.

I'd very much appreciate some guidance on what I'm missing.

$\endgroup$
5
$\begingroup$

To pass from the 1st part of your exercise to the 2nd part should not be difficult. Imagine a 3-dimentional space in which on the $x$-axis represents the $x$ projection of the velocity vector, the $y$ axis represents the y projection, and the $z$ axis the $z$ projection. You already calculated the probability of having velocities in a small cube of dimensions $dv_x, dv_y, dv_z$, with the cube positioned at the end of the vector $(v_x, v_y, v_z)$. You got

$$q(v_x, v_y, v_z)dv_x dv_y dv_z = C exp[(−mv^2)/2kT]dv_x dv_y dv_z.$$

where $C$ is the normalization constant. Now, you have to distinguish between probability and DENSITY of probability, i.e. probability per UNIT VOLUME of your space. The density of probability is equal to

$$C \exp[(−mv^2)/2kT].$$

Notice that this density of probability is independent of the direction of the velocity.

Now, you are asked to calculate the probability of having the velocity between $|v|$ and $|v| + d|v|$, where $|v|$ is the length of the velocity vector. Consider therefore a sphere of radius $|v|$ in the velocity space, and around it another sphere of radius $|v| + d|v|$. All the velocity vectors, no matter in which direction they are directed, end-up between these two spheres if their length is between $|v|$ and $|v| + d|v|$. So, what is the volume confined between these two spheres? It is $4\pi|v|^2 d|v|$. The density of probability (per unit of volume in the velocity space) you already calculated, and found it independent of the direction of the velocity. Then, to find the probability $dP$ in all the volume between the two spheres you multiply the probability per unit volume, with the volume. You get

$$dP = C \exp[(−mv^2)/2kT]4\pi|v|^2 d|v|.$$

What you are requested is to calculate $dP/d|v|$. Obviously, it is equal to

$$C \exp[(−mv^2)/2kT]4\pi|v|^2.$$

Good luck,

Sofia

$\endgroup$
0
$\begingroup$

We know that $q(v_x)\propto \mathrm{e}^{-m v_x^2/2kT}$. Thus, the probability $q(\vec{v})$ that a particle has velocity $\vec{v}=(v_x,v_y,v_z)$ is: $$q(\vec{v}) \propto \mathrm{e}^{\frac{-m (v_x^2+v_y^2+v_z^2)}{2kT}} dv_xdv_ydv_z$$

Now, You want to know the probability $q(v)$ that a particle has speed between $v$ and $v+dv$. For that, you have to integrate the Boltzmann distribution over all $v_x$,$v_y$,$v_z$ such that $v_x^2+v_y^2+v_z^2=v^2$ is a constant. Thus,

$$q(v) \propto \int_{|\vec{v}|=v}\mathrm{e}^{\frac{-m (v_x^2+v_y^2+v_z^2)}{2kT}} dv_xdv_ydv_z$$ $$= \mathrm{e}^{\frac{-m v^2}{2kT}} \int_{|\vec{v}|=v} dv_xdv_ydv_z$$ Inthe $2^{nd}$ step, I could take out the exponential term since it is a constant, as I am integrating over the condition |$\vec{v}|=v$ is a constant.

Now, all I have to do is to evaluate $ \int_{|\vec{v}|=v} dv_xdv_ydv_z$. To do this, I'll go into a 3D coordinate system, where the $x-$axis represents $v_x$, $y-$axis represents $v_y$ and $z-$axis represents $v_z$. In this system, $dv_xdv_ydv_z$ represents the volume element $d\tau$. Notice that, the set of all points such that $v_x^2+v_y^2+v_z^2=v^2$ is a sphere of radius $v$. Thus, the required integral is just $4\pi v^2dv$. As a result, we now get our final expresion,

$$q(v) \propto 4\pi v^2 \mathrm{e}^{\frac{-m v^2}{2kT}}$$

I hope this clears your doubt. If not, please comment or send me a message, and I'll be happy to explain.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.