0
$\begingroup$

Each loop in the solenoid will have its own magnetic field wrapped around it. In that case it won't resemble the magnetic lines formed by a bar magnet...; but we see that it is the same. Why is that?

$\endgroup$
7
$\begingroup$

By applying Fleming's Right Hand in each turn, we get magnetic field lines that look like this :-

.. .. .. enter image description here

But Magnetic field lines never intersect. They interact with the fieds of the surrounding turns of solenoid to form a combined magnetic field which looks like this:-

.. .. .. enter image description here

From www.nde-ed.org :-

The magnetic field circling each loop of wire combines with the fields from the other loops to produce a concentrated field down the centre of the coil. A loosely wound coil is illustrated to show the interaction of the magnetic field. The magnetic field is essentially uniform down the length of the coil when it is wound tighter.

If the loops or turns are extremely close to each other, magnetic field lines between neighbouring turns effectively cancel, resulting in straight magnetic fields inside the solenoid, similar magnetic fields inside a bar magnet :-

.. .. .. enter image description here

The magnetic field lines around (a) a bar magnet and (b) a current carrying solenoid :-

xyz

EDIT

As in the case of bar-magnets, the magnetic field is stronger inside the solenoid than outside it. Magnetic field lines are closely packed inside the solenoid, and magnetic field is concentrated into a nearly uniform magnetic field inside the solenoid. The magnetic fields outside are weak and spread out.

ATTRIBUTION

The first three diagrams are snipped from a video available on YouTube: Concepts in physics - Electromagnetism

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Maybe you could improve this by making clear why the field is much stronger inside the solenoid than on the outside. (The second and third figures in isolation don't make this point clear). Also if this is directly quoted from another source could you provide the appropriate credit/attribution. $\endgroup$ – Rob Jeffries Oct 26 '14 at 8:11
  • $\begingroup$ For inside and outside I think it is easy reason. Inside is near the field line in every direction while outside is far away from other $\endgroup$ – Thaina Oct 26 '14 at 10:32
  • $\begingroup$ i dont understand...we only consider to pairs of concentric circles in this case. But we should not forge that there are a LOT of pairs of concentric circles all around the loop at every point $\endgroup$ – MartianCactus Oct 4 '16 at 12:54
0
$\begingroup$

Opposite. Solenoid is actually like real magnet bar

Imagine one iron atom. It has electrons run in circle around that atom so it generate magnetic force. Every iron atom is like a solenoid loop by itself

Then Imagine a bar magnet is clump of iron which almost all atoms align in the same direction so every atom contribute a magnetic force. That's it much more like many solenoid loops parallel to each other

In detail you should watch this video

http://youtube.com/watch?v=hFAOXdXZ5TM

$\endgroup$
0
$\begingroup$

imakesmalltalk's answer is a good description of how the fields superpose in a solenoid to produce a final field similar to a bar magnet, but I want to discuss one or two subtle differences.

The final picture in imakesmalltalk's answer is clearly showing lines of H-field (which are often referred to as magnetic field), because they appear to begin and end at the surface of the magnet, whereas lines of B-field must be continuous. In actual fact there is a weak H-field inside the magnet running in the opposite direction between the poles. In an air-filled solenoid, the lines of H-field are continuous and in the same direction as the B-field. Thus the H-fields of a solenoid and a bar magnet are quite different, though they can be similar outside the solenoid. Another way of saying this is that the air-filled solenoid does not have magnetic poles (sources and sinks of H-field), whereas the bar magnet does.

It is more correct to say that the lines of B-field for a solenoid resemble the lines of B-field for a bar magnet, if the solenoid is of a similar size to the bar magnet. See this diagram from the hyperphysics site. Though note, the labelling of N and S poles on the solenoid is erroneous, in the sense there are no sinks/sources of H-field here and all we are saying is that this arrangement produces a B-field (or exterior H-field) similar to a bar magnet with poles at these positions.

B-fields of a solenoid compared with a bar magnet

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Why is the labelling erroneous? I think the poles of the solenoid are there, although they are not physical present as in the case of bar magnet. $\endgroup$ – user49111 Oct 26 '14 at 12:12
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Erroneous in the sense that there are no sources or sinks of H-field here. If you gave the solenoid an iron core it might be valid. Otherwise, all you are really saying is that it has a magnetic field like a bar magnet that would have poles here. See physikdidaktik.uni-karlsruhe.de/publication/Historical_burdens/… $\endgroup$ – Rob Jeffries Oct 26 '14 at 12:41

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.