1
$\begingroup$

I am trying to understand some facts on electrical potential and potential energy. It is quite confusing in the text to say that the zero potential could be freely chosen for convenience. In that case, how do you interpret the associated energy and the sign.

Let me start with the gravitational energy as analogy. Let's said I am standing on a high platform H h meter above the ground. If I am free to chose where the zero potential is, I consider the following two cases:

1) Assuming the ground has zero potential energy, the potential energy that I have is $mg(H-0)=mgH$. This makes sense to me since I have positive energy since I am standing in high place and I have potential to fall if I jump so my positive energy will convert into kinetic energy.

2) But what happens if I choose the zero potential at where I stand so the ground is at $-H$, so my energy is $mg(-H-0) = -mgH$, so is that negative really mean? I can only have one specific energy because I am standing at one place. So how does this negative potential energy related or equal to the positive one at 1)?

Now come to my question on electrical potential and energy, it is even more confusing because we have two different kind of charge (positive and negative). Let's consider the following case

enter image description here

Two metal terminals are connected to a battery (voltage is $V$). If I have an electron between the terminals, what is the potential energy the electron experience? As I learn from the text, the electrical potential energy should be $qV$, where $q$ is the charge of the particle, $V$ is the potential difference. Again, if we are free to choose the zero potential point, it may end up with two potential energy

1) By choosing the negative terminal as zero potential point so the potential energy for the electron should be $-e(V-0)=-eV$, which is negative. This makes sense to me because a negative charge will move away from the the negative terminal instead of the positive one, so it has negative potential energy (it won't move by itself towards the negative gate).

2) By choosing the positive terminal as zero potential point so the potential energy for the electron should be $-e(0-V)= eV$. It is hard to understand what is this positive potential really mean.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Its the potential difference that matters. $\endgroup$ – soumyadeep Oct 8 '14 at 16:01
2
$\begingroup$

I think you confused yourself with your example.

  1. The zero of potential energy is at ground level. So you have mgH at initial position and zero at ground level. So your initial energy is +mgH above ground energy.

  2. The zero of the potential is at height H. So your initial energy is zero and the energy at ground level is -mgH. So your initial energy is +mgH above ground energy.

See? Compare the last sentences of the two cases. There is no difference. In both cases the PE(initial) - PE(final) is the same. In your calculation you switched the terms for case 2 so of course you got negative sign.

| cite | improve this answer | |
$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

But your height on the hill is Rearth + H, where Rearth is the radius of the Earth and, so would U = mg(Rearth + H) (never mind the integral needed for now)? But wait, the Earth is in the potential well of the Sun so shouldn't U = mg(sun)(Rorbit - H)? Luckily, you don't need to know an absolute potential which would require knowing the distances, masses, and charges to everything in the universe. You can pick any point as a reference point and work with differences from that point. Forces depend on the gradients (instantaneous change with distance) in the potential and work depends on changes in U from one point to another. Electrons move up the local potential gradient.

| cite | improve this answer | |
$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Thanks. I understood that only the potential difference matters. But my question is asking if I choose the different zero potential, the absolute potential energy will be same but the sign might flipped, so what does it mean by the sign in that case? $\endgroup$ – user1285419 Oct 8 '14 at 17:01
  • $\begingroup$ If only differences matter, then the sign does not tell you anything. The sign of the difference from some reference point does matter. $\endgroup$ – eshaya Oct 8 '14 at 17:36
1
$\begingroup$

I would like to give a general answer for both gravitational and electric systems considered here.Please read the definition below:-

The change in potential energy of the system is defined as the negative of work done by the internal conservative forces of the system.$$\Delta U_{system}=-\int \vec{F_{cons}}.d\vec{s}$$

For example:- Take a ball and earth as your system then gravitational force will be an internal conservative force for the system.Now release the ball from a certain height $h$ then the work done by the gravitational force is $mgh$ so,corresponding change in gravitational potential energy will be given as $-mgh$.

Now consider the following points:-

  • Change in potential energy of the system is only defined for multi particle system.

  • Absolute potential energy is undefined.

As absolute potential energy is undefined and we can just calculate change in potential energy of a system then if we say that change in gravitational potential energy is $-mgh$ when we release a ball from certain height $h$ then the change will remain the same whether you choose your reference point as $\infty$ or $0$ or $2h$ etc.

| cite | improve this answer | |
$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.