Skip to main content
replaced http://physics.stackexchange.com/ with https://physics.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

Why does excess positive charge stay on the surface of a conductor?

This is what I understood from: How does positive charge spread out in conductors?How does positive charge spread out in conductors?

and other resources on the web:

  • If there is a electric field inside the conductor they will pull on the electrons
  • Therefore there can be no field inside the conductor
  • It follows from Gauss's Law that there are no charges inside

My questions:

  • If there are positive charges inside the conductor, they will attract the electrons. But the electrons are already being attracted by the nucleus they belong to so why would they move? All electrons have electric fields already acting on them (the electric field of the nucleus) so why would adding new ones make a difference?

  • If the positive charges are distributed on the surface, the field would only be zero right at the centre.The fields would cancel out in the centre because of symmetry but the field anywhere other than the centre would be non-zero. So how would the electrons be an equilibrium?

Please see the details on the bounty

Why does excess positive charge stay on the surface of a conductor?

This is what I understood from: How does positive charge spread out in conductors?

and other resources on the web:

  • If there is a electric field inside the conductor they will pull on the electrons
  • Therefore there can be no field inside the conductor
  • It follows from Gauss's Law that there are no charges inside

My questions:

  • If there are positive charges inside the conductor, they will attract the electrons. But the electrons are already being attracted by the nucleus they belong to so why would they move? All electrons have electric fields already acting on them (the electric field of the nucleus) so why would adding new ones make a difference?

  • If the positive charges are distributed on the surface, the field would only be zero right at the centre.The fields would cancel out in the centre because of symmetry but the field anywhere other than the centre would be non-zero. So how would the electrons be an equilibrium?

Please see the details on the bounty

Why does excess positive charge stay on the surface of a conductor?

This is what I understood from: How does positive charge spread out in conductors?

and other resources on the web:

  • If there is a electric field inside the conductor they will pull on the electrons
  • Therefore there can be no field inside the conductor
  • It follows from Gauss's Law that there are no charges inside

My questions:

  • If there are positive charges inside the conductor, they will attract the electrons. But the electrons are already being attracted by the nucleus they belong to so why would they move? All electrons have electric fields already acting on them (the electric field of the nucleus) so why would adding new ones make a difference?

  • If the positive charges are distributed on the surface, the field would only be zero right at the centre.The fields would cancel out in the centre because of symmetry but the field anywhere other than the centre would be non-zero. So how would the electrons be an equilibrium?

Please see the details on the bounty

Notice removed Improve details by CommunityBot
Bounty Ended with no winning answer by CommunityBot
edited title
Link
dfg
  • 2k
  • 7
  • 38
  • 55

Excess Conductors and their charge on conductors?

Tweeted twitter.com/#!/StackPhysics/status/426160176681730048
added 46 characters in body
Source Link
dfg
  • 2k
  • 7
  • 38
  • 55

Why does excess positive charge stay on the surface of a conductor?

This is what I understood from: How does positive charge spread out in conductors?

and other resources on the web:

  • If there is a electric field inside the conductor they will pull on the electrons
  • Therefore there can be no field inside the conductor
  • It follows from Gauss's Law that there are no charges inside

My questions:

  • If there are positive charges inside the conductor, they will attract the electrons. But the electrons are already being attracted by the nucleus they belong to so why would they move? All electrons have electric fields already acting on them (the electric field of the nucleus) so why would adding new ones make a difference?

  • If the positive charges are distributed on the surface, the field would only be zero right at the centre.The fields would cancel out in the centre because of symmetry but the field anywhere other than the centre would be non-zero. So how would the electrons be an equilibrium?

Please see the details on the bounty

Why does excess positive charge stay on the surface of a conductor?

This is what I understood from: How does positive charge spread out in conductors?

and other resources on the web:

  • If there is a electric field inside the conductor they will pull on the electrons
  • Therefore there can be no field inside the conductor
  • It follows from Gauss's Law that there are no charges inside

My questions:

  • If there are positive charges inside the conductor, they will attract the electrons. But the electrons are already being attracted by the nucleus they belong to so why would they move? All electrons have electric fields already acting on them (the electric field of the nucleus) so why would adding new ones make a difference?

  • If the positive charges are distributed on the surface, the field would only be zero right at the centre.The fields would cancel out in the centre because of symmetry but the field anywhere other than the centre would be non-zero. So how would the electrons be an equilibrium?

Why does excess positive charge stay on the surface of a conductor?

This is what I understood from: How does positive charge spread out in conductors?

and other resources on the web:

  • If there is a electric field inside the conductor they will pull on the electrons
  • Therefore there can be no field inside the conductor
  • It follows from Gauss's Law that there are no charges inside

My questions:

  • If there are positive charges inside the conductor, they will attract the electrons. But the electrons are already being attracted by the nucleus they belong to so why would they move? All electrons have electric fields already acting on them (the electric field of the nucleus) so why would adding new ones make a difference?

  • If the positive charges are distributed on the surface, the field would only be zero right at the centre.The fields would cancel out in the centre because of symmetry but the field anywhere other than the centre would be non-zero. So how would the electrons be an equilibrium?

Please see the details on the bounty

Notice added Improve details by dfg
Bounty Started worth 50 reputation by dfg
edited tags
Link
Qmechanic
  • 212.8k
  • 48
  • 589
  • 2.3k
Loading
Source Link
dfg
  • 2k
  • 7
  • 38
  • 55
Loading