Skip to main content
Post Reopened by Freedom, John Rennie, Jos Bergervoet
added 8 characters in body; edited title
Added to review
Source Link

How do you detectbuild a Coherent Elastic Neutrino-Nucleus Scattering (CEvNS) detector?

*Milkjug-sized neutrino detector (the COHERENT neutrino detector):

This question is similar to: Is a DIY neutrino detector feasible?. The difference between my question, and the old one is that the question is from over 8 years ago. Naturally, some of the answers are outdated and the links to materials they provide are all expired. Additionally, we now have neutrino detectors the size of milk jugs, so now a DIY Neutrino Detector is much more feasible than the answers in the older question indicated. Given this, I ask my questions because I want to know how feasible it is today, and what is required to make it.

*If you see this question and have any level of knowledge on the question for you to be able to edit the questions to make them more specific, by all means please feel free to do so. I also want to mention that I am looking for something more along the lines of general advice rather than specifically engineering questions. Especially since the questions I am asking are mostly only going to be able to be answered by a physicist, rather than an engineer.*If you see this question and have any level of knowledge on the question for you to be able to edit the questions to make them more specific, by all means please feel free to do so. I also want to mention that I am looking for something more along the lines of general advice rather than specifically engineering questions. Especially since the questions I am asking are mostly only going to be able to be answered by a physicist, rather than an engineer.

How does the COHERENT neutrino detector, detect neutrinos and CEvNS? And why does it work despite its incredibly small size?

Considering that we now have neutrino detectors the size of milk jugs (COHERENT), how might one make their own ('DIY') neutrino detector?

*The following questions serve as order of magnitude requests to give me an idea of how feasible this project that I am very passionate about is. It gives me an idea of how much money I am going to need to request, raise, and apply for grants for.*The following questions serve as order of magnitude requests to give me an idea of how feasible this project that I am very passionate about is. It gives me an idea of how much money I am going to need to request, raise, and apply for grants for.

What might you need if you had a large budget to make it? And what would you need if you had a limited budget?

Are any of the supplies you might need to build your own neutrino detector be cheaper if you made them yourself?

How do you detect Coherent Elastic Neutrino-Nucleus Scattering (CEvNS)?

*Milkjug-sized neutrino detector (the COHERENT neutrino detector):

This question is similar to: Is a DIY neutrino detector feasible?. The difference between my question, and the old one is that the question is from over 8 years ago. Naturally, some of the answers are outdated and the links to materials they provide are all expired. Additionally, we now have neutrino detectors the size of milk jugs, so now a DIY Neutrino Detector is much more feasible than the answers in the older question indicated. Given this, I ask my questions because I want to know how feasible it is today, and what is required to make it.

*If you see this question and have any level of knowledge on the question for you to be able to edit the questions to make them more specific, by all means please feel free to do so. I also want to mention that I am looking for something more along the lines of general advice rather than specifically engineering questions. Especially since the questions I am asking are mostly only going to be able to be answered by a physicist, rather than an engineer.

How does the COHERENT neutrino detector, detect neutrinos and CEvNS? And why does it work despite its incredibly small size?

Considering that we now have neutrino detectors the size of milk jugs (COHERENT), how might one make their own ('DIY') neutrino detector?

*The following questions serve as order of magnitude requests to give me an idea of how feasible this project that I am very passionate about is. It gives me an idea of how much money I am going to need to request, raise, and apply for grants for.

What might you need if you had a large budget to make it? And what would you need if you had a limited budget?

Are any of the supplies you might need to build your own neutrino detector be cheaper if you made them yourself?

How do you build a Coherent Elastic Neutrino-Nucleus Scattering (CEvNS) detector?

*Milkjug-sized neutrino detector (the COHERENT neutrino detector):

This question is similar to: Is a DIY neutrino detector feasible?. The difference between my question, and the old one is that the question is from over 8 years ago. Naturally, some of the answers are outdated and the links to materials they provide are all expired. Additionally, we now have neutrino detectors the size of milk jugs, so now a DIY Neutrino Detector is much more feasible than the answers in the older question indicated. Given this, I ask my questions because I want to know how feasible it is today, and what is required to make it.

*If you see this question and have any level of knowledge on the question for you to be able to edit the questions to make them more specific, by all means please feel free to do so. I also want to mention that I am looking for something more along the lines of general advice rather than specifically engineering questions. Especially since the questions I am asking are mostly only going to be able to be answered by a physicist, rather than an engineer.

How does the COHERENT neutrino detector, detect neutrinos and CEvNS? And why does it work despite its incredibly small size?

Considering that we now have neutrino detectors the size of milk jugs (COHERENT), how might one make their own ('DIY') neutrino detector?

*The following questions serve as order of magnitude requests to give me an idea of how feasible this project that I am very passionate about is. It gives me an idea of how much money I am going to need to request, raise, and apply for grants for.

What might you need if you had a large budget to make it? And what would you need if you had a limited budget?

Are any of the supplies you might need to build your own neutrino detector be cheaper if you made them yourself?

Left closed in review as "Original close reason(s) were not resolved" by Michael Seifert, BioPhysicist, ZeroTheHero
deleted 1545 characters in body
Source Link

*The moderator @rob completely hit the nail on the head and read my mind with their interpretation of this post. I assume this is because they have been in my shoes before, so they understand my perspective, and because of the sheer amount of clear and extensive experience they have in physics. You can see their interpretation here.*Milkjug-sized neutrino detector (the COHERENT neutrino detector):

*ThisThis question is similar to: Is a DIY neutrino detector feasible?. The difference between my question, and the old one is that the question is from over 8 years ago. Naturally, some of the answers are outdated and the links to materials they provide are all expired. Additionally, we now have neutrino detectors the size of milk jugs, so now a DIY Neutrino Detector is much more feasible than the answers in the older question indicated. Given this, I ask my questions because I want to know how feasible it is today, and what is required to make it.

*This question is quite broad and I do apologize for that (I am working on making separate questions, don’t worry), but I don’t know much about the subject to ask very specific, and for lack of a better word, better questions. So if*If you see this question and have any level of knowledge on the question for you to be able to edit the questions to make them more specific, by all means please feel free to do so. I also want to mention that I am looking for something more along the lines of general advice rather than specifically engineering questions. Especially since the questions I am asking are mostly only going to be able to be answered by a physicist, rather than an engineer.

*Now forHow does the pricing questionsCOHERENT neutrino detector, theydetect neutrinos and CEvNS? And why does it work despite its incredibly small size?

Considering that we now have neutrino detectors the size of milk jugs (COHERENT), how might one make their own ('DIY') neutrino detector?

*The following questions serve as order of magnitude requests to give me an idea of how feasible this project that I am very passionate about is. It gives me an idea of how much money I am going to need to request, raise, and apply for grants for (I am a New York City high school student in a research program at my prestigious public high school, they put a lot of funding and money into us research students, but there are not many resources for those of us with a love for physics; which is why I have turned to the internet for answers to my questions; I hope this does not get taken as me asking for ‘illegal’ help for my research, I am genuinely curious about this stuff, and have been before I was accepted into the program, and I can’t find answers to any of my questions, and I am not even close to beginning my research).

*Milkjug-sized neutrino detector (the COHERENT neutrino detector):

*miniTimeCube detector:

#1 Priority:

How does the COHERENT neutrino detector, neutrinos and CEvNS?

Why does (or maybe how does) the smallest neutrino detector (the COHERENT detector) work despite its incredibly small size?

What is used to detect CEvNS?

Considering that we now have neutrino detectors the size of milk jugs, how might one make their own neutrino detector?

#2 Priority:

Why might the smallest neutrino detector work despite its incredibly small size?

Are any of the supplies you might need to build your own neutrino detector be cheaper if you made them yourself?

What might a 'shopping list' for building your own neutrino detector look like?

*The moderator @rob completely hit the nail on the head and read my mind with their interpretation of this post. I assume this is because they have been in my shoes before, so they understand my perspective, and because of the sheer amount of clear and extensive experience they have in physics. You can see their interpretation here.

*This question is similar to: Is a DIY neutrino detector feasible?. The difference between my question, and the old one is that the question is from over 8 years ago. Naturally, some of the answers are outdated and the links to materials they provide are all expired. Additionally, we now have neutrino detectors the size of milk jugs, so now a DIY Neutrino Detector is much more feasible than the answers in the older question indicated. Given this, I ask my questions because I want to know how feasible it is today, and what is required to make it.

*This question is quite broad and I do apologize for that (I am working on making separate questions, don’t worry), but I don’t know much about the subject to ask very specific, and for lack of a better word, better questions. So if you see this question and have any level of knowledge on the question for you to be able to edit the questions to make them more specific, by all means please feel free to do so. I also want to mention that I am looking for something more along the lines of general advice rather than specifically engineering questions. Especially since the questions I am asking are mostly only going to be able to be answered by a physicist, rather than an engineer.

*Now for the pricing questions, they serve as order of magnitude requests to give me an idea of how feasible this project that I am very passionate about is. It gives me an idea of how much money I am going to need to request, raise, and apply for grants for (I am a New York City high school student in a research program at my prestigious public high school, they put a lot of funding and money into us research students, but there are not many resources for those of us with a love for physics; which is why I have turned to the internet for answers to my questions; I hope this does not get taken as me asking for ‘illegal’ help for my research, I am genuinely curious about this stuff, and have been before I was accepted into the program, and I can’t find answers to any of my questions, and I am not even close to beginning my research).

*Milkjug-sized neutrino detector (the COHERENT neutrino detector):

*miniTimeCube detector:

#1 Priority:

How does the COHERENT neutrino detector, neutrinos and CEvNS?

Why does (or maybe how does) the smallest neutrino detector (the COHERENT detector) work despite its incredibly small size?

What is used to detect CEvNS?

Considering that we now have neutrino detectors the size of milk jugs, how might one make their own neutrino detector?

#2 Priority:

Why might the smallest neutrino detector work despite its incredibly small size?

Are any of the supplies you might need to build your own neutrino detector be cheaper if you made them yourself?

What might a 'shopping list' for building your own neutrino detector look like?

*Milkjug-sized neutrino detector (the COHERENT neutrino detector):

This question is similar to: Is a DIY neutrino detector feasible?. The difference between my question, and the old one is that the question is from over 8 years ago. Naturally, some of the answers are outdated and the links to materials they provide are all expired. Additionally, we now have neutrino detectors the size of milk jugs, so now a DIY Neutrino Detector is much more feasible than the answers in the older question indicated. Given this, I ask my questions because I want to know how feasible it is today, and what is required to make it.

*If you see this question and have any level of knowledge on the question for you to be able to edit the questions to make them more specific, by all means please feel free to do so. I also want to mention that I am looking for something more along the lines of general advice rather than specifically engineering questions. Especially since the questions I am asking are mostly only going to be able to be answered by a physicist, rather than an engineer.

How does the COHERENT neutrino detector, detect neutrinos and CEvNS? And why does it work despite its incredibly small size?

Considering that we now have neutrino detectors the size of milk jugs (COHERENT), how might one make their own ('DIY') neutrino detector?

*The following questions serve as order of magnitude requests to give me an idea of how feasible this project that I am very passionate about is. It gives me an idea of how much money I am going to need to request, raise, and apply for grants for.

Are any of the supplies you might need to build your own neutrino detector be cheaper if you made them yourself?

Linkify title of related question.
Source Link
rob
  • 94.2k
  • 20
  • 177
  • 353

*This question is similar to: Is a DIY neutrino detector feasible?Is a DIY neutrino detector feasible?. The difference between my question, and the old one is that the question is from over 8 years ago. Naturally, some of the answers are outdated and the links to materials they provide are all expired. Additionally, we now have neutrino detectors the size of milk jugs, so now a DIY Neutrino Detector is much more feasible than the answers in the older question indicated. Given this, I ask my questions because I want to know how feasible it is today, and what is required to make it.

*This question is similar to: Is a DIY neutrino detector feasible?. The difference between my question, and the old one is that the question is from over 8 years ago. Naturally, some of the answers are outdated and the links to materials they provide are all expired. Additionally, we now have neutrino detectors the size of milk jugs, so now a DIY Neutrino Detector is much more feasible than the answers in the older question indicated. Given this, I ask my questions because I want to know how feasible it is today, and what is required to make it.

*This question is similar to: Is a DIY neutrino detector feasible?. The difference between my question, and the old one is that the question is from over 8 years ago. Naturally, some of the answers are outdated and the links to materials they provide are all expired. Additionally, we now have neutrino detectors the size of milk jugs, so now a DIY Neutrino Detector is much more feasible than the answers in the older question indicated. Given this, I ask my questions because I want to know how feasible it is today, and what is required to make it.

added 50 characters in body
Source Link
Loading
I really hope I provided enough clarity, and I am working on making separate questions to relieve some of the broadness.
Added to review
Source Link
Loading
Post Closed as "Needs more focus" by Kyle Kanos, Matt Hanson, Vincent Thacker
Post Reopened by rob
I just want to know how to detect neutrinos in a more affortable and feasible way. This is not an engineering question, this is an experimental physics question and in some parts conceptually a theoretical physics question. I hope this does not get flagged as an opinion-based question, please don't.
Added to review
Source Link
Loading
Post Closed as "Not suitable for this site" by BioPhysicist, A Nejati, hft
added 271 characters in body
Source Link
Loading
Source Link
Loading