Skip to main content
Fixed grammar, notations, clarified problem stated, and added workings.
Source Link
STOI
  • 348
  • 1
  • 15

I was looking at the enthalpy change for water-splitting reaction:

$$ \Delta H^o_R = [\Delta H^0_{H_2(g)} +\frac{1}{2}\Delta H^0_{O_2(g)}]-\Delta H^0_{H_2O(l)} = 285.83 kJ/mol$$

According to the book "Thermal physics"by Schroeder; at constant T and P; if there are no other forms of work on the system besides compression/expansion. Then, then $\Delta H^o_R = Q$ and if we have. However, when there are other forms of work being done we then have $\Delta Gº_R \leq W_{other}$ and $\Delta H^o_R = Q + W_{other}$. Does The value for the Gibbs free energy in this mean itcase is definitely not possible$ \Delta Gº_R = 237 kJ/mol $. We can relate $\Delta G$ and $\Delta H$ by $\Delta G =\Delta H -T\Delta S$ .

My confusion arises first from reading that the gibbs free energy is the work we need to changedrive the enthalpy of a reaction purely by compression/expansion, say electrical work ? Is. However, the enthalpy change inshows that the energy required could be done via heat and/or another form of work is higher than that of the Gibbs free energy? My guess so far is zerothat we can take some energy from the environment for "free", but what happens when enthalpy iswe drive this reaction only changed by heat? Ifvia heat and say electrical work are used, then G is the minimum worksuch that needs to be supplied by the electric work$\Delta H = Q$, would $\Delta G = 0 $ ?

I was looking at the enthalpy change for water-splitting reaction:

$$ \Delta H^o_R = [\Delta H^0_{H_2(g)} +\frac{1}{2}\Delta H^0_{O_2(g)}]-\Delta H^0_{H_2O(l)} = 285.83 kJ/mol$$

According to the book "Thermal physics"by Schroeder; at constant T and P; if there are no other forms of work on the system besides compression/expansion. Then, $\Delta H^o_R = Q$ and if we have other work being done we have $\Delta Gº_R \leq W_{other}$. Does this mean it is definitely not possible to change the enthalpy of a reaction purely by compression/expansion work ? Is the change in Gibbs free energy is zero when enthalpy is only changed by heat? If heat and say electrical work are used, then G is the minimum work that needs to be supplied by the electric work ?

I was looking at the enthalpy change for water-splitting reaction:

$$ \Delta H^o_R = [\Delta H^0_{H_2(g)} +\frac{1}{2}\Delta H^0_{O_2(g)}]-\Delta H^0_{H_2O(l)} = 285.83 kJ/mol$$

According to the book "Thermal physics"by Schroeder; at constant T and P; if there are no other forms of work on the system besides compression/expansion, then $\Delta H^o_R = Q$. However, when there are other forms of work being done we then have $\Delta Gº_R \leq W_{other}$ and $\Delta H^o_R = Q + W_{other}$. The value for the Gibbs free energy in this case is $ \Delta Gº_R = 237 kJ/mol $. We can relate $\Delta G$ and $\Delta H$ by $\Delta G =\Delta H -T\Delta S$ .

My confusion arises first from reading that the gibbs free energy is the work we need to drive the reaction, say electrical work. However, the enthalpy change shows that the energy required could be done via heat and/or another form of work is higher than that of the Gibbs free energy? My guess so far is that we can take some energy from the environment for "free", but what happens when we drive this reaction only via heat, such that $\Delta H = Q$, would $\Delta G = 0 $ ?

edited body
Source Link
STOI
  • 348
  • 1
  • 15

I was looking at the enthalpy change for water-splitting reaction:

$$ \Delta H^o_R = [\Delta H^0_{H_2(g)} +\frac{1}{2}\Delta H^0_{O_2(g)}]-\Delta H^0_{H_2O(l)} = 285.85 kJ/mol$$$$ \Delta H^o_R = [\Delta H^0_{H_2(g)} +\frac{1}{2}\Delta H^0_{O_2(g)}]-\Delta H^0_{H_2O(l)} = 285.83 kJ/mol$$

According to the book "Thermal physics"by Schroeder; at constant T and P; if there are no other forms of work on the system besides compression/expansion. Then, $\Delta H^o_R = Q$ and if we have other work being done we have $\Delta Gº_R \leq W_{other}$. Does this mean it is definitely not possible to change the enthalpy of a reaction purely by compression/expansion work ? Is the change in Gibbs free energy is zero when enthalpy is only changed by heat? If heat and say electrical work are used, then G is the minimum work that needs to be supplied by the electric work ?

I was looking at the enthalpy change for water-splitting reaction:

$$ \Delta H^o_R = [\Delta H^0_{H_2(g)} +\frac{1}{2}\Delta H^0_{O_2(g)}]-\Delta H^0_{H_2O(l)} = 285.85 kJ/mol$$

According to the book "Thermal physics"by Schroeder; at constant T and P; if there are no other forms of work on the system besides compression/expansion. Then, $\Delta H^o_R = Q$ and if we have other work being done we have $\Delta Gº_R \leq W_{other}$. Does this mean it is definitely not possible to change the enthalpy of a reaction purely by compression/expansion work ? Is the change in Gibbs free energy is zero when enthalpy is only changed by heat? If heat and say electrical work are used, then G is the minimum work that needs to be supplied by the electric work ?

I was looking at the enthalpy change for water-splitting reaction:

$$ \Delta H^o_R = [\Delta H^0_{H_2(g)} +\frac{1}{2}\Delta H^0_{O_2(g)}]-\Delta H^0_{H_2O(l)} = 285.83 kJ/mol$$

According to the book "Thermal physics"by Schroeder; at constant T and P; if there are no other forms of work on the system besides compression/expansion. Then, $\Delta H^o_R = Q$ and if we have other work being done we have $\Delta Gº_R \leq W_{other}$. Does this mean it is definitely not possible to change the enthalpy of a reaction purely by compression/expansion work ? Is the change in Gibbs free energy is zero when enthalpy is only changed by heat? If heat and say electrical work are used, then G is the minimum work that needs to be supplied by the electric work ?

Source Link
STOI
  • 348
  • 1
  • 15

Understanding enthalpy and gibbs energy changes in a reaction

I was looking at the enthalpy change for water-splitting reaction:

$$ \Delta H^o_R = [\Delta H^0_{H_2(g)} +\frac{1}{2}\Delta H^0_{O_2(g)}]-\Delta H^0_{H_2O(l)} = 285.85 kJ/mol$$

According to the book "Thermal physics"by Schroeder; at constant T and P; if there are no other forms of work on the system besides compression/expansion. Then, $\Delta H^o_R = Q$ and if we have other work being done we have $\Delta Gº_R \leq W_{other}$. Does this mean it is definitely not possible to change the enthalpy of a reaction purely by compression/expansion work ? Is the change in Gibbs free energy is zero when enthalpy is only changed by heat? If heat and say electrical work are used, then G is the minimum work that needs to be supplied by the electric work ?