Skip to main content
added 902 characters in body
Source Link
Voulkos
  • 16.4k
  • 2
  • 43
  • 72

In Special Relativity we couldn't say in general that the axes of two inertial frames $\:\rm S\:$ and $\:\rm S'\:$ in relative translational motion (boost) are parallel, see Figure-02, except of special cases, see Figure-01.

Suppose that a frame $\:\rm S'\:$ is moving uniformly with velocity $\:\boldsymbol\upsilon\:$ with respect to an inertial frame $\:\rm S\:$ and with common $\: x',x-$axes along this velocity as in Figure-01. Planes $\:\mathrm O'x'y'\:$ and $\:\mathrm Oxy\:$ are parallel. We could make the $\: y',y-$axes parallel and the same for the $\:z',z-$axes. This is a special case we could talk about parallel axes between the two inertial frames.

To the contrary, in case of a general boost with velocity $\:\boldsymbol\upsilon$, see Figure-02, we could not talk about parallel axes. For example, the points of the $\:x'_2-$axis in frame $\:\rm S'\:$ at a given moment $\:t'\:$ are simultaneous events in Minkowski space, so the $\:x'_2-$axis is a well-defined straight line in $\:\rm S'$. But these events are not simultaneous in $\:\rm S\:$ so there doesn't exist such a thing or curve or whatever else in $\:\rm S\:$ to be parallel to the $\:x_2-$axis.


enter image description here


enter image description here


ADDENDUM (20-08-2022)

The $\:Ox_1\:$ axis of frame $\:\mathbf S\:$ in Figure-02 is a straight line in frame $\:\mathbf S'\:$ but not parallel to $\:O'x'_1\:$. To derive the details, extract from my answer here Is it a typo in David Tong's derivation of spin-orbit interaction? equations (03) for the Lorentz boost of Figure-02.

Consider that the points of a straight segment (vector) $\:\Delta\mathbf x\:$ are seen simultaneously by observer $\:\mathbf S\:$, that is $\:\Delta t=0\:$, to derive that in $\:\mathbf S'$. \begin{align} \Delta\mathbf{x'} & = \Delta\mathbf{x}+ \dfrac{\gamma^2}{c^2 \left(\gamma+1\right)}\left(\boldsymbol{\upsilon}\boldsymbol{\cdot} \Delta\mathbf{x}\right)\boldsymbol{\upsilon} \tag{03a}\label{03a}\\ \Delta t' & = -\gamma\dfrac{\boldsymbol{\upsilon}\boldsymbol{\cdot} \Delta\mathbf{x}}{c^2} \tag{03b}\label{03b} \end{align}\begin{align} \Delta\mathbf{x'} & = \Delta\mathbf{x}\boldsymbol + \dfrac{\gamma^2}{c^2 \left(\gamma\boldsymbol +1\right)}\left(\boldsymbol{\upsilon}\boldsymbol{\cdot} \Delta\mathbf{x}\right)\boldsymbol{\upsilon} \tag{03a}\label{03a}\\ \Delta t' & = \boldsymbol-\,\gamma\dfrac{\boldsymbol{\upsilon}\boldsymbol{\cdot} \Delta\mathbf{x}}{c^2} \tag{03b}\label{03b} \end{align}

Depending on the sign of $\:\Delta t'\:$ return backward or forward in time $\:t'\:$ the points of $\:\Delta\mathbf{x'}\:$ in order to be seen simultaneously by observer $\:\mathbf S'$. The result will be a straight segment (vector) but not parallel to $\:\Delta\mathbf x$.

In Special Relativity we couldn't say in general that the axes of two inertial frames $\:\rm S\:$ and $\:\rm S'\:$ in relative translational motion (boost) are parallel, see Figure-02, except of special cases, see Figure-01.

Suppose that a frame $\:\rm S'\:$ is moving uniformly with velocity $\:\boldsymbol\upsilon\:$ with respect to an inertial frame $\:\rm S\:$ and with common $\: x',x-$axes along this velocity as in Figure-01. Planes $\:\mathrm O'x'y'\:$ and $\:\mathrm Oxy\:$ are parallel. We could make the $\: y',y-$axes parallel and the same for the $\:z',z-$axes. This is a special case we could talk about parallel axes between the two inertial frames.

To the contrary, in case of a general boost with velocity $\:\boldsymbol\upsilon$, see Figure-02, we could not talk about parallel axes. For example, the points of the $\:x'_2-$axis in frame $\:\rm S'\:$ at a given moment $\:t'\:$ are simultaneous events in Minkowski space, so the $\:x'_2-$axis is a well-defined straight line in $\:\rm S'$. But these events are not simultaneous in $\:\rm S\:$ so there doesn't exist such a thing or curve or whatever else in $\:\rm S\:$ to be parallel to the $\:x_2-$axis.


enter image description here


enter image description here


ADDENDUM (20-08-2022)

The $\:Ox_1\:$ axis of frame $\:\mathbf S\:$ in Figure-02 is a straight line in frame $\:\mathbf S'\:$ but not parallel to $\:O'x'_1\:$. To derive the details, extract from my answer here Is it a typo in David Tong's derivation of spin-orbit interaction? equations (03) for the Lorentz boost of Figure-02.

Consider that the points of a straight segment (vector) $\:\Delta\mathbf x\:$ are seen simultaneously by observer $\:\mathbf S\:$, that is $\:\Delta t=0\:$, to derive that in $\:\mathbf S'$. \begin{align} \Delta\mathbf{x'} & = \Delta\mathbf{x}+ \dfrac{\gamma^2}{c^2 \left(\gamma+1\right)}\left(\boldsymbol{\upsilon}\boldsymbol{\cdot} \Delta\mathbf{x}\right)\boldsymbol{\upsilon} \tag{03a}\label{03a}\\ \Delta t' & = -\gamma\dfrac{\boldsymbol{\upsilon}\boldsymbol{\cdot} \Delta\mathbf{x}}{c^2} \tag{03b}\label{03b} \end{align}

Depending on the sign of $\:\Delta t'\:$ return backward or forward in time $\:t'\:$ the points of $\:\Delta\mathbf{x'}\:$ in order to be seen simultaneously by observer $\:\mathbf S'$. The result will be a straight segment (vector) but not parallel to $\:\Delta\mathbf x$.

In Special Relativity we couldn't say in general that the axes of two inertial frames $\:\rm S\:$ and $\:\rm S'\:$ in relative translational motion (boost) are parallel, see Figure-02, except of special cases, see Figure-01.

Suppose that a frame $\:\rm S'\:$ is moving uniformly with velocity $\:\boldsymbol\upsilon\:$ with respect to an inertial frame $\:\rm S\:$ and with common $\: x',x-$axes along this velocity as in Figure-01. Planes $\:\mathrm O'x'y'\:$ and $\:\mathrm Oxy\:$ are parallel. We could make the $\: y',y-$axes parallel and the same for the $\:z',z-$axes. This is a special case we could talk about parallel axes between the two inertial frames.

To the contrary, in case of a general boost with velocity $\:\boldsymbol\upsilon$, see Figure-02, we could not talk about parallel axes. For example, the points of the $\:x'_2-$axis in frame $\:\rm S'\:$ at a given moment $\:t'\:$ are simultaneous events in Minkowski space, so the $\:x'_2-$axis is a well-defined straight line in $\:\rm S'$. But these events are not simultaneous in $\:\rm S\:$ so there doesn't exist such a thing or curve or whatever else in $\:\rm S\:$ to be parallel to the $\:x_2-$axis.


enter image description here


enter image description here


ADDENDUM (20-08-2022)

The $\:Ox_1\:$ axis of frame $\:\mathbf S\:$ in Figure-02 is a straight line in frame $\:\mathbf S'\:$ but not parallel to $\:O'x'_1\:$. To derive the details, extract from my answer here Is it a typo in David Tong's derivation of spin-orbit interaction? equations (03) for the Lorentz boost of Figure-02.

Consider that the points of a straight segment (vector) $\:\Delta\mathbf x\:$ are seen simultaneously by observer $\:\mathbf S\:$, that is $\:\Delta t=0\:$, to derive that in $\:\mathbf S'$ \begin{align} \Delta\mathbf{x'} & = \Delta\mathbf{x}\boldsymbol + \dfrac{\gamma^2}{c^2 \left(\gamma\boldsymbol +1\right)}\left(\boldsymbol{\upsilon}\boldsymbol{\cdot} \Delta\mathbf{x}\right)\boldsymbol{\upsilon} \tag{03a}\label{03a}\\ \Delta t' & = \boldsymbol-\,\gamma\dfrac{\boldsymbol{\upsilon}\boldsymbol{\cdot} \Delta\mathbf{x}}{c^2} \tag{03b}\label{03b} \end{align}

Depending on the sign of $\:\Delta t'\:$ return backward or forward in time $\:t'\:$ the points of $\:\Delta\mathbf{x'}\:$ in order to be seen simultaneously by observer $\:\mathbf S'$. The result will be a straight segment (vector) but not parallel to $\:\Delta\mathbf x$.

added 902 characters in body
Source Link
Voulkos
  • 16.4k
  • 2
  • 43
  • 72

In Special Relativity we couldn't say in general that the axes of two inertial frames $\:\rm S\:$ and $\:\rm S'\:$ in relative translational motion (boost) are parallel, see Figure-02, except of special cases, see Figure-01.

Suppose that a frame $\:\rm S'\:$ is moving uniformly with velocity $\:\boldsymbol\upsilon\:$ with respect to an inertial frame $\:\rm S\:$ and with common $\: x',x-$axes along this velocity as in Figure-01. Planes $\:\mathrm O'x'y'\:$ and $\:\mathrm Oxy\:$ are parallel. We could make the $\: y',y-$axes parallel and the same for the $\:z',z-$axes. This is a special case we could talk about parallel axes between the two inertial frames.

To the contrary, in case of a general boost with velocity $\:\boldsymbol\upsilon$, see Figure-02, we could not talk about parallel axes. For example, the points of the $\:x'_2-$axis in frame $\:\rm S'\:$ at a given moment $\:t'\:$ are simultaneous events in Minkowski space, so the $\:x'_2-$axis is a well-defined straight line in $\:\rm S'$. But these events are not simultaneous in $\:\rm S\:$ so there doesn't exist such a thing or curve or whatever else in $\:\rm S\:$ to be parallel to the $\:x_2-$axis.


enter image description here



 

enter image description here


ADDENDUM (20-08-2022)

The $\:Ox_1\:$ axis of frame $\:\mathbf S\:$ in Figure-02 is a straight line in frame $\:\mathbf S'\:$ but not parallel to $\:O'x'_1\:$. To derive the details, extract from my answer here Is it a typo in David Tong's derivation of spin-orbit interaction? equations (03) for the Lorentz boost of Figure-02.

Consider that the points of a straight segment (vector) $\:\Delta\mathbf x\:$ are seen simultaneously by observer $\:\mathbf S\:$, that is $\:\Delta t=0\:$, to derive that in $\:\mathbf S'$. \begin{align} \Delta\mathbf{x'} & = \Delta\mathbf{x}+ \dfrac{\gamma^2}{c^2 \left(\gamma+1\right)}\left(\boldsymbol{\upsilon}\boldsymbol{\cdot} \Delta\mathbf{x}\right)\boldsymbol{\upsilon} \tag{03a}\label{03a}\\ \Delta t' & = -\gamma\dfrac{\boldsymbol{\upsilon}\boldsymbol{\cdot} \Delta\mathbf{x}}{c^2} \tag{03b}\label{03b} \end{align}

Depending on the sign of $\:\Delta t'\:$ return backward or forward in time $\:t'\:$ the points of $\:\Delta\mathbf{x'}\:$ in order to be seen simultaneously by observer $\:\mathbf S'$. The result will be a straight segment (vector) but not parallel to $\:\Delta\mathbf x$.

In Special Relativity we couldn't say in general that the axes of two inertial frames $\:\rm S\:$ and $\:\rm S'\:$ in relative translational motion (boost) are parallel, see Figure-02, except of special cases, see Figure-01.

Suppose that a frame $\:\rm S'\:$ is moving uniformly with velocity $\:\boldsymbol\upsilon\:$ with respect to an inertial frame $\:\rm S\:$ and with common $\: x',x-$axes along this velocity as in Figure-01. Planes $\:\mathrm O'x'y'\:$ and $\:\mathrm Oxy\:$ are parallel. We could make the $\: y',y-$axes parallel and the same for the $\:z',z-$axes. This is a special case we could talk about parallel axes between the two inertial frames.

To the contrary, in case of a general boost with velocity $\:\boldsymbol\upsilon$, see Figure-02, we could not talk about parallel axes. For example, the points of the $\:x'_2-$axis in frame $\:\rm S'\:$ at a given moment $\:t'\:$ are simultaneous events in Minkowski space, so the $\:x'_2-$axis is a well-defined straight line in $\:\rm S'$. But these events are not simultaneous in $\:\rm S\:$ so there doesn't exist such a thing or curve or whatever else in $\:\rm S\:$ to be parallel to the $\:x_2-$axis.


enter image description here



 

enter image description here

In Special Relativity we couldn't say in general that the axes of two inertial frames $\:\rm S\:$ and $\:\rm S'\:$ in relative translational motion (boost) are parallel, see Figure-02, except of special cases, see Figure-01.

Suppose that a frame $\:\rm S'\:$ is moving uniformly with velocity $\:\boldsymbol\upsilon\:$ with respect to an inertial frame $\:\rm S\:$ and with common $\: x',x-$axes along this velocity as in Figure-01. Planes $\:\mathrm O'x'y'\:$ and $\:\mathrm Oxy\:$ are parallel. We could make the $\: y',y-$axes parallel and the same for the $\:z',z-$axes. This is a special case we could talk about parallel axes between the two inertial frames.

To the contrary, in case of a general boost with velocity $\:\boldsymbol\upsilon$, see Figure-02, we could not talk about parallel axes. For example, the points of the $\:x'_2-$axis in frame $\:\rm S'\:$ at a given moment $\:t'\:$ are simultaneous events in Minkowski space, so the $\:x'_2-$axis is a well-defined straight line in $\:\rm S'$. But these events are not simultaneous in $\:\rm S\:$ so there doesn't exist such a thing or curve or whatever else in $\:\rm S\:$ to be parallel to the $\:x_2-$axis.


enter image description here


enter image description here


ADDENDUM (20-08-2022)

The $\:Ox_1\:$ axis of frame $\:\mathbf S\:$ in Figure-02 is a straight line in frame $\:\mathbf S'\:$ but not parallel to $\:O'x'_1\:$. To derive the details, extract from my answer here Is it a typo in David Tong's derivation of spin-orbit interaction? equations (03) for the Lorentz boost of Figure-02.

Consider that the points of a straight segment (vector) $\:\Delta\mathbf x\:$ are seen simultaneously by observer $\:\mathbf S\:$, that is $\:\Delta t=0\:$, to derive that in $\:\mathbf S'$. \begin{align} \Delta\mathbf{x'} & = \Delta\mathbf{x}+ \dfrac{\gamma^2}{c^2 \left(\gamma+1\right)}\left(\boldsymbol{\upsilon}\boldsymbol{\cdot} \Delta\mathbf{x}\right)\boldsymbol{\upsilon} \tag{03a}\label{03a}\\ \Delta t' & = -\gamma\dfrac{\boldsymbol{\upsilon}\boldsymbol{\cdot} \Delta\mathbf{x}}{c^2} \tag{03b}\label{03b} \end{align}

Depending on the sign of $\:\Delta t'\:$ return backward or forward in time $\:t'\:$ the points of $\:\Delta\mathbf{x'}\:$ in order to be seen simultaneously by observer $\:\mathbf S'$. The result will be a straight segment (vector) but not parallel to $\:\Delta\mathbf x$.

added 512 characters in body
Source Link
Voulkos
  • 16.4k
  • 2
  • 43
  • 72

In Special Relativity we couldn't say in general that the axes of two inertial frames $\:\rm S\:$ and $\:\rm S'\:$ in relative translational motion (boost) are parallel, see Figure-02, except of special cases, see Figure-01.

Suppose that a frame $\:\rm S'\:$ is moving uniformly with velocity $\:\boldsymbol\upsilon\:$ with respect to an inertial frame $\:\rm S\:$ and with common $\: x',x-$axes along this velocity as in Figure-01. Planes $\:\mathrm O'x'y'\:$ and $\:\mathrm Oxy\:$ are parallel. We could make the $\: y',y-$axes parallel and the same for the $\:z',z-$axes. This is a special case we could talk about parallel axes between the two inertial frames.

To the contrary, in case of a general boost with velocity $\:\boldsymbol\upsilon$, see Figure-02, we could not talk about parallel axes. For example, the points of the $\:x'_2-$axis in frame $\:\rm S'\:$ at a given moment $\:t'\:$ are simultaneous events in Minkowski space, so the $\:x'_2-$axis is a well-defined straight line in $\:\rm S'$. But these events are not simultaneous in $\:\rm S\:$ so there doesn't exist such a thing or curve or whatever else in $\:\rm S\:$ to be parallel to the $\:x_2-$axis.


enter image description here



enter image description here

In Special Relativity we couldn't say in general that the axes of two inertial frames $\:\rm S\:$ and $\:\rm S'\:$ in relative translational motion (boost) are parallel, see Figure-02, except of special cases, see Figure-01.

Suppose that a frame $\:\rm S'\:$ is moving uniformly with velocity $\:\boldsymbol\upsilon\:$ with respect to an inertial frame $\:\rm S\:$ and with common $\: x',x-$axes along this velocity as in Figure-01. Planes $\:\mathrm O'x'y'\:$ and $\:\mathrm Oxy\:$ are parallel. We could make the $\: y',y-$axes parallel and the same for the $\:z',z-$axes. This is a special case we could talk about parallel axes between the two inertial frames.


enter image description here



enter image description here

In Special Relativity we couldn't say in general that the axes of two inertial frames $\:\rm S\:$ and $\:\rm S'\:$ in relative translational motion (boost) are parallel, see Figure-02, except of special cases, see Figure-01.

Suppose that a frame $\:\rm S'\:$ is moving uniformly with velocity $\:\boldsymbol\upsilon\:$ with respect to an inertial frame $\:\rm S\:$ and with common $\: x',x-$axes along this velocity as in Figure-01. Planes $\:\mathrm O'x'y'\:$ and $\:\mathrm Oxy\:$ are parallel. We could make the $\: y',y-$axes parallel and the same for the $\:z',z-$axes. This is a special case we could talk about parallel axes between the two inertial frames.

To the contrary, in case of a general boost with velocity $\:\boldsymbol\upsilon$, see Figure-02, we could not talk about parallel axes. For example, the points of the $\:x'_2-$axis in frame $\:\rm S'\:$ at a given moment $\:t'\:$ are simultaneous events in Minkowski space, so the $\:x'_2-$axis is a well-defined straight line in $\:\rm S'$. But these events are not simultaneous in $\:\rm S\:$ so there doesn't exist such a thing or curve or whatever else in $\:\rm S\:$ to be parallel to the $\:x_2-$axis.


enter image description here



enter image description here

added 7 characters in body
Source Link
Voulkos
  • 16.4k
  • 2
  • 43
  • 72
Loading
added 443 characters in body
Source Link
Voulkos
  • 16.4k
  • 2
  • 43
  • 72
Loading
Source Link
Voulkos
  • 16.4k
  • 2
  • 43
  • 72
Loading