Skip to main content
edited title
Link
Urb
  • 2.7k
  • 4
  • 14
  • 26

Does Newtonian Mechanicsmechanics work in polar coordinates?

Became Hot Network Question
Tweeted twitter.com/StackPhysics/status/1474167950492028929
edited tags; edited tags
Source Link
Qmechanic
  • 212.7k
  • 48
  • 589
  • 2.3k

Our teacher suggested that Newtonian Mechanics only applies in cartesian coordinates. Is this true?

He gave this example.

Suppose there a train moving with constant velocity $\vec{v}=v_0\hat{x}$, with initial position vector $\vec{r}=(0, y_0)$, where $v_0,y_0$ are constants. He argued that Newton's second law would not hold in polar coordinates. Any ideas  ?

(We can assume 2D or 3D cases as well, so spherical or polar, it doesn't really matter)

Our teacher suggested that Newtonian Mechanics only applies in cartesian coordinates. Is this true?

He gave this example.

Suppose there a train moving with constant velocity $\vec{v}=v_0\hat{x}$, with initial position vector $\vec{r}=(0, y_0)$, where $v_0,y_0$ are constants. He argued that Newton's second law would not hold in polar coordinates. Any ideas  ?

(We can assume 2D or 3D cases as well, so spherical or polar, it doesn't really matter)

Our teacher suggested that Newtonian Mechanics only applies in cartesian coordinates. Is this true?

He gave this example.

Suppose there a train moving with constant velocity $\vec{v}=v_0\hat{x}$, with initial position vector $\vec{r}=(0, y_0)$, where $v_0,y_0$ are constants. He argued that Newton's second law would not hold in polar coordinates. Any ideas?

(We can assume 2D or 3D cases as well, so spherical or polar, it doesn't really matter)

Source Link
seVenVo1d
  • 3.2k
  • 14
  • 32

Does Newtonian Mechanics work in polar coordinates?

Our teacher suggested that Newtonian Mechanics only applies in cartesian coordinates. Is this true?

He gave this example.

Suppose there a train moving with constant velocity $\vec{v}=v_0\hat{x}$, with initial position vector $\vec{r}=(0, y_0)$, where $v_0,y_0$ are constants. He argued that Newton's second law would not hold in polar coordinates. Any ideas ?

(We can assume 2D or 3D cases as well, so spherical or polar, it doesn't really matter)