Skip to main content
added 93 characters in body
Source Link
Dale
  • 109.1k
  • 11
  • 160
  • 319

If $apple$ is a valid unit then $apple^2$ is also a valid unit. Simply because it is valid does not imply that it is meaningful.

Whether or not a unit is meaningful has to do with whether it is used in any physical formulas. I don’t know of any formulas that involve the unit $apple$, nor any that take products of quantities measured in $apples$. So to my knowledge it is not meaningful.

If there were such a formula then the meaning of the unit $apple^2$ would be as a reference standard for the quantity described by the corresponding variable in the formula.

You cannot talk about the meaning of a unit in the absence of a physical formula using that unit. For example the unit $\text{kg m}^2 \text{ s}^{-2}$ means different things in different contexts.

If $apple$ is a valid unit then $apple^2$ is also a valid unit. Simply because it is valid does not imply that it is meaningful.

Whether or not a unit is meaningful has to do with whether it is used in any physical formulas. I don’t know of any formulas that involve the unit $apple$, nor any that take products of quantities measured in $apples$. So to my knowledge it is not meaningful.

If there were such a formula then the meaning of the unit $apple^2$ would be as a reference standard for the quantity described by the corresponding variable in the formula.

You cannot talk about the meaning of a unit in the absence of a physical formula using that unit.

If $apple$ is a valid unit then $apple^2$ is also a valid unit. Simply because it is valid does not imply that it is meaningful.

Whether or not a unit is meaningful has to do with whether it is used in any physical formulas. I don’t know of any formulas that involve the unit $apple$, nor any that take products of quantities measured in $apples$. So to my knowledge it is not meaningful.

If there were such a formula then the meaning of the unit $apple^2$ would be as a reference standard for the quantity described by the corresponding variable in the formula.

You cannot talk about the meaning of a unit in the absence of a physical formula using that unit. For example the unit $\text{kg m}^2 \text{ s}^{-2}$ means different things in different contexts.

Source Link
Dale
  • 109.1k
  • 11
  • 160
  • 319

If $apple$ is a valid unit then $apple^2$ is also a valid unit. Simply because it is valid does not imply that it is meaningful.

Whether or not a unit is meaningful has to do with whether it is used in any physical formulas. I don’t know of any formulas that involve the unit $apple$, nor any that take products of quantities measured in $apples$. So to my knowledge it is not meaningful.

If there were such a formula then the meaning of the unit $apple^2$ would be as a reference standard for the quantity described by the corresponding variable in the formula.

You cannot talk about the meaning of a unit in the absence of a physical formula using that unit.