Skip to main content
Notice removed Draw attention by Ivan
Bounty Ended with Qmechanic's answer chosen by Ivan
Notice added Draw attention by Ivan
Bounty Started worth 50 reputation by Ivan
edited title
Link
Ivan
  • 990
  • 10
  • 29

Functional derivative of second derivative (Faddeevin Faddeev Popov method and Lorenz(Lorenz Gauge)

deleted 1 character in body; edited title; edited tags
Source Link
Qmechanic
  • 212.7k
  • 48
  • 589
  • 2.3k

Functional derivative of second derivative (Faddeev Popov method and LorentzLorenz Gauge)

When applying Faddeev and Popov method (am using Peskin and Schroeder as reference), we use the identity: $$1=\int \mathcal{D}\alpha(x)\delta(G(A^\alpha)) \det\left(\frac{\delta G(A^\alpha)}{\delta\alpha}\right) \tag{9.53}$$ to write $$ \int \mathcal{D}Ae^{iS[A]}=\det\left(\frac{\delta G(A^\alpha)}{\delta\alpha}\right)\int\mathcal{D}\alpha(x)\int\mathcal{D}Ae^{iS[A]}\delta (G(A^\alpha))\tag{9.54}$$ When we use the LorentzLorenz gauge, we obtain: $$G(A)=\partial^\mu A_\mu+\frac{1}{e}\partial^2\alpha(x)$$

My questions is: how do we obtain the following: $$ \det\left(\frac{\delta G(A^\alpha)}{\delta\alpha}\right) = \det\left(\frac{1}{e}\partial^2\right) $$

I am also confused about how can we obtain an operator by taking a functional derivative, if someone could give an intuitive explanation of this it would be highly appreciated!

Functional derivative of second derivative (Faddeev Popov method and Lorentz Gauge)

When applying Faddeev and Popov method (am using Peskin and Schroeder as reference), we use the identity: $$1=\int \mathcal{D}\alpha(x)\delta(G(A^\alpha)) \det\left(\frac{\delta G(A^\alpha)}{\delta\alpha}\right) \tag{9.53}$$ to write $$ \int \mathcal{D}Ae^{iS[A]}=\det\left(\frac{\delta G(A^\alpha)}{\delta\alpha}\right)\int\mathcal{D}\alpha(x)\int\mathcal{D}Ae^{iS[A]}\delta (G(A^\alpha))\tag{9.54}$$ When we use the Lorentz gauge, we obtain: $$G(A)=\partial^\mu A_\mu+\frac{1}{e}\partial^2\alpha(x)$$

My questions is: how do we obtain the following: $$ \det\left(\frac{\delta G(A^\alpha)}{\delta\alpha}\right) = \det\left(\frac{1}{e}\partial^2\right) $$

I am also confused about how can we obtain an operator by taking a functional derivative, if someone could give an intuitive explanation of this it would be highly appreciated!

Functional derivative of second derivative (Faddeev Popov method and Lorenz Gauge)

When applying Faddeev and Popov method (am using Peskin and Schroeder as reference), we use the identity: $$1=\int \mathcal{D}\alpha(x)\delta(G(A^\alpha)) \det\left(\frac{\delta G(A^\alpha)}{\delta\alpha}\right) \tag{9.53}$$ to write $$ \int \mathcal{D}Ae^{iS[A]}=\det\left(\frac{\delta G(A^\alpha)}{\delta\alpha}\right)\int\mathcal{D}\alpha(x)\int\mathcal{D}Ae^{iS[A]}\delta (G(A^\alpha))\tag{9.54}$$ When we use the Lorenz gauge, we obtain: $$G(A)=\partial^\mu A_\mu+\frac{1}{e}\partial^2\alpha(x)$$

My questions is: how do we obtain the following: $$ \det\left(\frac{\delta G(A^\alpha)}{\delta\alpha}\right) = \det\left(\frac{1}{e}\partial^2\right) $$

I am also confused about how can we obtain an operator by taking a functional derivative, if someone could give an intuitive explanation of this it would be highly appreciated!

When applying Faddeev and Popov method (am using PeskingPeskin and ShcroederSchroeder as reference), we use the identity: $$1=\int \mathcal{D}\alpha(x)\delta(G(A^\alpha)) \det\left(\frac{\delta G(A^\alpha)}{\delta\alpha}\right)$$$$1=\int \mathcal{D}\alpha(x)\delta(G(A^\alpha)) \det\left(\frac{\delta G(A^\alpha)}{\delta\alpha}\right) \tag{9.53}$$ to write $$ \int \mathcal{D}Ae^{iS[A]}=\det\left(\frac{\delta G(A^\alpha)}{\delta\alpha}\right)\int\mathcal{D}\alpha(x)\int\mathcal{D}Ae^{iS[A]}\delta (G(A^\alpha))$$$$ \int \mathcal{D}Ae^{iS[A]}=\det\left(\frac{\delta G(A^\alpha)}{\delta\alpha}\right)\int\mathcal{D}\alpha(x)\int\mathcal{D}Ae^{iS[A]}\delta (G(A^\alpha))\tag{9.54}$$ When we use the Lorentz gauge, we obtain: $$G(A)=\partial^\mu A_\mu+\frac{1}{e}\partial^2\alpha(x)$$

My questions is: how do we obtain the following: $$ \det\left(\frac{\delta G(A^\alpha)}{\delta\alpha}\right) = \det\left(\frac{1}{e}\partial^2\right) $$

I am also confused about how can we obtain an operator by taking a functional derivative, if someone could give an intuitive explanation of this it would be highly appreciated!

When applying Faddeev and Popov method (am using Pesking and Shcroeder as reference), we use the identity: $$1=\int \mathcal{D}\alpha(x)\delta(G(A^\alpha)) \det\left(\frac{\delta G(A^\alpha)}{\delta\alpha}\right)$$ to write $$ \int \mathcal{D}Ae^{iS[A]}=\det\left(\frac{\delta G(A^\alpha)}{\delta\alpha}\right)\int\mathcal{D}\alpha(x)\int\mathcal{D}Ae^{iS[A]}\delta (G(A^\alpha))$$ When we use the Lorentz gauge, we obtain: $$G(A)=\partial^\mu A_\mu+\frac{1}{e}\partial^2\alpha(x)$$

My questions is: how do we obtain the following: $$ \det\left(\frac{\delta G(A^\alpha)}{\delta\alpha}\right) = \det\left(\frac{1}{e}\partial^2\right) $$

I am also confused about how can we obtain an operator by taking a functional derivative, if someone could give an intuitive explanation of this it would be highly appreciated!

When applying Faddeev and Popov method (am using Peskin and Schroeder as reference), we use the identity: $$1=\int \mathcal{D}\alpha(x)\delta(G(A^\alpha)) \det\left(\frac{\delta G(A^\alpha)}{\delta\alpha}\right) \tag{9.53}$$ to write $$ \int \mathcal{D}Ae^{iS[A]}=\det\left(\frac{\delta G(A^\alpha)}{\delta\alpha}\right)\int\mathcal{D}\alpha(x)\int\mathcal{D}Ae^{iS[A]}\delta (G(A^\alpha))\tag{9.54}$$ When we use the Lorentz gauge, we obtain: $$G(A)=\partial^\mu A_\mu+\frac{1}{e}\partial^2\alpha(x)$$

My questions is: how do we obtain the following: $$ \det\left(\frac{\delta G(A^\alpha)}{\delta\alpha}\right) = \det\left(\frac{1}{e}\partial^2\right) $$

I am also confused about how can we obtain an operator by taking a functional derivative, if someone could give an intuitive explanation of this it would be highly appreciated!

Source Link
Ivan
  • 990
  • 10
  • 29
Loading