Skip to main content
added 132 characters in body
Source Link
J. Murray
  • 71.4k
  • 5
  • 99
  • 203

We know that the post measurement states after a projective measurement has the form $\frac{\hat{\Pi}|\Psi(t)>}{\sqrt{<\psi(t)|\hat{\Pi}|\psi(t)>}}$ -(1)

.$$\frac{\hat{\Pi}|\Psi(t)\rangle}{\sqrt{\langle\psi(t)|\hat{\Pi}|\psi(t)\rangle}} \qquad (1) $$

When a position measurement is made, with finite accuracy $\delta$, we can define $\hat{\Pi}= \int_{x_i }^{x_i+\delta}{|x><x|dx}$$\hat{\Pi}_{x_i}= \int_{x_i }^{x_i+\delta}{|x\rangle\langle x|dx}$ as the projectors.

Why can't we define $\hat{\Pi}=|x><x|$$\hat{\Pi}_x=|x\rangle\langle x|$ as the projectors instead,assuming that there is no theoretical limit to the precision? That is, I have come across statements saying that $\frac{|x><x|\Psi(t)>}{\sqrt{<\psi(t)|\hat{\Pi}|\psi(t)>}}$ -(2)
is

$$\frac{|x\rangle \langle x|\Psi(t)\rangle}{\sqrt{\langle\psi(t)|\hat{\Pi}|\psi(t)\rangle}} \qquad (2)$$

is not a valid post measurement state for position measurements. Why is that so? I have heard that it is related to the fact that for position states $|x>$$|x\rangle$, we have $\int_{-\infty }^{\infty}{<x'|x><x|x'>dx'=\infty}$$\int_{-\infty }^{\infty}\langle x'|x\rangle\langle x|x'\rangle dx'=\infty$, i.e unnormalizable. Although I might be missing something basic, I am not able to see why this fact prohibits equation (2) as a post measurement state?

We know that the post measurement states after a projective measurement has the form $\frac{\hat{\Pi}|\Psi(t)>}{\sqrt{<\psi(t)|\hat{\Pi}|\psi(t)>}}$ -(1)

. When a position measurement is made, with finite accuracy $\delta$, we can define $\hat{\Pi}= \int_{x_i }^{x_i+\delta}{|x><x|dx}$ as the projectors.

Why can't we define $\hat{\Pi}=|x><x|$ as the projectors instead,assuming that there is no theoretical limit to the precision? That is, I have come across statements saying that $\frac{|x><x|\Psi(t)>}{\sqrt{<\psi(t)|\hat{\Pi}|\psi(t)>}}$ -(2)
is not a valid post measurement state for position measurements. Why is that so? I have heard that it is related to the fact that for position states $|x>$, we have $\int_{-\infty }^{\infty}{<x'|x><x|x'>dx'=\infty}$, i.e unnormalizable. Although I might be missing something basic, I am not able to see why this fact prohibits equation (2) as a post measurement state?

We know that the post measurement states after a projective measurement has the form

$$\frac{\hat{\Pi}|\Psi(t)\rangle}{\sqrt{\langle\psi(t)|\hat{\Pi}|\psi(t)\rangle}} \qquad (1) $$

When a position measurement is made, with finite accuracy $\delta$, we can define $\hat{\Pi}_{x_i}= \int_{x_i }^{x_i+\delta}{|x\rangle\langle x|dx}$ as the projectors.

Why can't we define $\hat{\Pi}_x=|x\rangle\langle x|$ as the projectors instead,assuming that there is no theoretical limit to the precision? That is, I have come across statements saying that

$$\frac{|x\rangle \langle x|\Psi(t)\rangle}{\sqrt{\langle\psi(t)|\hat{\Pi}|\psi(t)\rangle}} \qquad (2)$$

is not a valid post measurement state for position measurements. Why is that so? I have heard that it is related to the fact that for position states $|x\rangle$, we have $\int_{-\infty }^{\infty}\langle x'|x\rangle\langle x|x'\rangle dx'=\infty$, i.e unnormalizable. Although I might be missing something basic, I am not able to see why this fact prohibits equation (2) as a post measurement state?

edited title
Link

Why can't this be an aposteriora post measurement state for position measurement?

Source Link

Why can't this be an aposterior state for position measurement?

We know that the post measurement states after a projective measurement has the form $\frac{\hat{\Pi}|\Psi(t)>}{\sqrt{<\psi(t)|\hat{\Pi}|\psi(t)>}}$ -(1)

. When a position measurement is made, with finite accuracy $\delta$, we can define $\hat{\Pi}= \int_{x_i }^{x_i+\delta}{|x><x|dx}$ as the projectors.

Why can't we define $\hat{\Pi}=|x><x|$ as the projectors instead,assuming that there is no theoretical limit to the precision? That is, I have come across statements saying that $\frac{|x><x|\Psi(t)>}{\sqrt{<\psi(t)|\hat{\Pi}|\psi(t)>}}$ -(2)
is not a valid post measurement state for position measurements. Why is that so? I have heard that it is related to the fact that for position states $|x>$, we have $\int_{-\infty }^{\infty}{<x'|x><x|x'>dx'=\infty}$, i.e unnormalizable. Although I might be missing something basic, I am not able to see why this fact prohibits equation (2) as a post measurement state?