Skip to main content
improve title
Source Link
ACuriousMind
  • 128.8k
  • 31
  • 293
  • 701

Are Electromagnetic Is the electromagnetic field a real physical entity?

Up till now, I always thought that the electric and magnetic fields are mathematical constructs which aid our understanding. What was a one-step process of particle $A$ exerting force on a particle $B$ is replaced by a two-step process of the particle $A$ creating a field and the particle $B$ then entering it and experiencing the force.

But I just read a chapter on electro-magneticelectromagnetic (EM) waves. From what I understood, if a charged particle $A$ moves, the electromagnetic field induced by it also changes, and this change in the field can be modeled by a wave equation. This wave equation would then determine the force experienced by a particle $B$ when it enters the field at a particular position $\vec{r}$ and time $t$.

My confusion starts when I see that these varying EM fields (or EM waves) produce an actual physical quantity called light. So if EM Fields were imaginary, then these EM waves should also be imaginary. But expiriment and expirience shows that they are very real. Hence the only possible reason for my confusion is that EM fields are real-world entities. Can someone confirm this for me?

P.S. In case my question in not clear, let me know in the comment section.

Are Electromagnetic field real physical entity?

Up till now, I always thought that the electric and magnetic fields are mathematical constructs which aid our understanding. What was a one-step process of particle $A$ exerting force on a particle $B$ is replaced by a two-step process of the particle $A$ creating a field and the particle $B$ then entering it and experiencing the force.

But I just read a chapter on electro-magnetic (EM) waves. From what I understood, if a charged particle $A$ moves, the electromagnetic field induced by it also changes, and this change in the field can be modeled by a wave equation. This wave equation would then determine the force experienced by a particle $B$ when it enters the field at a particular position $\vec{r}$ and time $t$.

My confusion starts when I see that these varying EM fields (or EM waves) produce an actual physical quantity called light. So if EM Fields were imaginary, then these EM waves should also be imaginary. But expiriment and expirience shows that they are very real. Hence the only possible reason for my confusion is that EM fields are real-world entities. Can someone confirm this for me?

P.S. In case my question in not clear, let me know in the comment section.

Is the electromagnetic field a real physical entity?

Up till now, I always thought that electric and magnetic fields are mathematical constructs which aid our understanding. What was a one-step process of particle $A$ exerting force on a particle $B$ is replaced by a two-step process of the particle $A$ creating a field and the particle $B$ then entering it and experiencing the force.

But I just read a chapter on electromagnetic (EM) waves. From what I understood, if a charged particle $A$ moves, the electromagnetic field induced by it also changes, and this change in the field can be modeled by a wave equation. This wave equation would then determine the force experienced by a particle $B$ when it enters the field at a particular position $\vec{r}$ and time $t$.

My confusion starts when I see that these varying EM fields (or EM waves) produce an actual physical quantity called light. So if EM Fields were imaginary, then these EM waves should also be imaginary. But expiriment and expirience shows that they are very real. Hence the only possible reason for my confusion is that EM fields are real-world entities. Can someone confirm this for me?

Edited the text to be more readable and added tags.
Source Link

Up till now, I always thought that the electric/magnetic and magnetic fields are mathematical construct toconstructs which aid our understanding. What was a 1 stepone-step process of particle A$A$ exerting force on a particle B$B$ is replaced by a 2 steptwo-step process of the particle A$A$ creating a field and the particle B$B$ then entering it and experiencing the force.

But I just read a chapter on electromagneticelectro-magnetic (EM) waves. From what I understandunderstood, if a charged particle A$A$ moves, the electromagnetic field induced by it also changes which, and this change in the field can be modelledmodeled by a wave equation. This wave equation would then determine the force experienced by a particle B$B$ when it enterenters the field at a particular position (r,t)$\vec{r}$ and time $t$.

My confusion starts when I see that these varying EM fields (or EM waves) producedproduce an actual physical quantity called light. So if EM Fields were imaginary, then these EM waves should also be imaginary, but expirement. But expiriment and expirenceexpirience shows that they are very real. Hence the only possible reason for my confusion is that EM fields are a real thing? Can-world entities. Can someone confirm this for me.?

P.S.P.S. In case my question in not clear,let let me know in the comment section.

Up till now I always thought that electric/magnetic fields are mathematical construct to aid our understanding. What was a 1 step process of particle A exerting force on particle B is replaced by a 2 step process of particle A creating a field and particle B entering it and experiencing the force.

But I just read a chapter on electromagnetic waves. From what I understand if a charged particle A moves, the electromagnetic field induced by it also changes which can be modelled by a wave equation. This wave equation would then determine the force experienced by a particle B when it enter the field at a particular (r,t).

My confusion starts when I see that these varying EM fields (or EM waves) produced an actual physical quantity called light. So if EM Fields were imaginary, then these EM waves should also be imaginary, but expirement and expirence shows that they are very real. Hence the only possible reason is that EM fields are a real thing? Can someone confirm this for me.

P.S. In case my question in not clear,let me know in the comment section.

Up till now, I always thought that the electric and magnetic fields are mathematical constructs which aid our understanding. What was a one-step process of particle $A$ exerting force on a particle $B$ is replaced by a two-step process of the particle $A$ creating a field and the particle $B$ then entering it and experiencing the force.

But I just read a chapter on electro-magnetic (EM) waves. From what I understood, if a charged particle $A$ moves, the electromagnetic field induced by it also changes, and this change in the field can be modeled by a wave equation. This wave equation would then determine the force experienced by a particle $B$ when it enters the field at a particular position $\vec{r}$ and time $t$.

My confusion starts when I see that these varying EM fields (or EM waves) produce an actual physical quantity called light. So if EM Fields were imaginary, then these EM waves should also be imaginary. But expiriment and expirience shows that they are very real. Hence the only possible reason for my confusion is that EM fields are real-world entities. Can someone confirm this for me?

P.S. In case my question in not clear, let me know in the comment section.

Source Link

Are Electromagnetic field real physical entity?

Up till now I always thought that electric/magnetic fields are mathematical construct to aid our understanding. What was a 1 step process of particle A exerting force on particle B is replaced by a 2 step process of particle A creating a field and particle B entering it and experiencing the force.

But I just read a chapter on electromagnetic waves. From what I understand if a charged particle A moves, the electromagnetic field induced by it also changes which can be modelled by a wave equation. This wave equation would then determine the force experienced by a particle B when it enter the field at a particular (r,t).

My confusion starts when I see that these varying EM fields (or EM waves) produced an actual physical quantity called light. So if EM Fields were imaginary, then these EM waves should also be imaginary, but expirement and expirence shows that they are very real. Hence the only possible reason is that EM fields are a real thing? Can someone confirm this for me.

P.S. In case my question in not clear,let me know in the comment section.