Skip to main content
Bounty Ended with 50 reputation awarded by SRS
added 209 characters in body
Source Link
G. Smith
  • 52.2k
  • 4
  • 85
  • 154

Spatial curvature actually shifts all of the peaks right or left. It does so because it bends the light rays traveling across the universe to us from the surface of last scattering.

If the universe has positive curvature, light rays from opposite sides of a “hot spot” bend toward each other, making the spot appear larger to us than would appear in a universe with zero curvature. If the universe has negative curvature, light rays from opposite sides of a hot spot bend away from each other, making the spot appear smaller.

This curvature-induced magnification or demagnification applies to hot spots of all sizes and therefore shifts all of the peaks.

The fact that the first peak is expected near $l=200$ if the curvature is zero requirescomes from a detailed calculation of the size of the horizon at recombination. One finds that the horizon at that time has an angular size of about 0.9 degrees of arc in the sky today, corresponding to $l=180/0.9=200$.

See http://background.uchicago.edu/~whu/intermediate/clcurvature.html and https://briankoberlein.com/2014/09/03/three-peaks/http://folk.uio.no/hke/AST5220/v11/AST5220_2_2011.pdf, both of which are credible sources.

Spatial curvature actually shifts all of the peaks right or left. It does so because it bends the light rays traveling across the universe to us from the surface of last scattering.

If the universe has positive curvature, light rays from opposite sides of a “hot spot” bend toward each other, making the spot appear larger to us than would appear in a universe with zero curvature. If the universe has negative curvature, light rays from opposite sides of a hot spot bend away from each other, making the spot appear smaller.

This curvature-induced magnification or demagnification applies to hot spots of all sizes and therefore shifts all of the peaks.

The fact that the first peak is expected near $l=200$ if the curvature is zero requires a detailed calculation.

See http://background.uchicago.edu/~whu/intermediate/clcurvature.html and https://briankoberlein.com/2014/09/03/three-peaks/.

Spatial curvature actually shifts all of the peaks right or left. It does so because it bends the light rays traveling across the universe to us from the surface of last scattering.

If the universe has positive curvature, light rays from opposite sides of a “hot spot” bend toward each other, making the spot appear larger to us than would appear in a universe with zero curvature. If the universe has negative curvature, light rays from opposite sides of a hot spot bend away from each other, making the spot appear smaller.

This curvature-induced magnification or demagnification applies to hot spots of all sizes and therefore shifts all of the peaks.

The fact that the first peak is expected near $l=200$ if the curvature is zero comes from a calculation of the size of the horizon at recombination. One finds that the horizon at that time has an angular size of about 0.9 degrees of arc in the sky today, corresponding to $l=180/0.9=200$.

See http://background.uchicago.edu/~whu/intermediate/clcurvature.html and http://folk.uio.no/hke/AST5220/v11/AST5220_2_2011.pdf, both of which are credible sources.

added 115 characters in body
Source Link
G. Smith
  • 52.2k
  • 4
  • 85
  • 154

Spatial curvature actually shifts all of the peaks right or left. It does so because it bends the light rays traveling across the universe to us from the surface of last scattering.

If the universe has positive curvature, light rays from opposite sides of a “hot spot” bend toward each other, making the spot appear larger to us than would appear in a universe with zero curvature. If the universe has negative curvature, light rays from opposite sides of a hot spot bend away from each other, making the spot appear smaller.

This curvature-induced magnification or demagnification applies to hot spots of all sizes and therefore shifts all of the peaks.

The fact that the first peak is expected near $l=200$ if the curvature is zero requires a detailed calculation.

See http://background.uchicago.edu/~whu/intermediate/clcurvature.html and https://briankoberlein.com/2014/09/03/three-peaks/.

Spatial curvature actually shifts all of the peaks right or left. It does so because it bends the light rays traveling across the universe to us from the surface of last scattering.

If the universe has positive curvature, light rays from opposite sides of a “hot spot” bend toward each other, making the spot appear larger to us than would appear in a universe with zero curvature. If the universe has negative curvature, light rays from opposite sides of a hot spot bend away from each other, making the spot appear smaller.

This curvature-induced magnification or demagnification applies to hot spots of all sizes and therefore shifts all of the peaks.

See http://background.uchicago.edu/~whu/intermediate/clcurvature.html and https://briankoberlein.com/2014/09/03/three-peaks/.

Spatial curvature actually shifts all of the peaks right or left. It does so because it bends the light rays traveling across the universe to us from the surface of last scattering.

If the universe has positive curvature, light rays from opposite sides of a “hot spot” bend toward each other, making the spot appear larger to us than would appear in a universe with zero curvature. If the universe has negative curvature, light rays from opposite sides of a hot spot bend away from each other, making the spot appear smaller.

This curvature-induced magnification or demagnification applies to hot spots of all sizes and therefore shifts all of the peaks.

The fact that the first peak is expected near $l=200$ if the curvature is zero requires a detailed calculation.

See http://background.uchicago.edu/~whu/intermediate/clcurvature.html and https://briankoberlein.com/2014/09/03/three-peaks/.

Source Link
G. Smith
  • 52.2k
  • 4
  • 85
  • 154

Spatial curvature actually shifts all of the peaks right or left. It does so because it bends the light rays traveling across the universe to us from the surface of last scattering.

If the universe has positive curvature, light rays from opposite sides of a “hot spot” bend toward each other, making the spot appear larger to us than would appear in a universe with zero curvature. If the universe has negative curvature, light rays from opposite sides of a hot spot bend away from each other, making the spot appear smaller.

This curvature-induced magnification or demagnification applies to hot spots of all sizes and therefore shifts all of the peaks.

See http://background.uchicago.edu/~whu/intermediate/clcurvature.html and https://briankoberlein.com/2014/09/03/three-peaks/.