Skip to main content
replaced http://physics.stackexchange.com/ with https://physics.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

There are some great explanations on StackExchange of why we see a blue sky on Earth, eg herehere.

Namely, that it's a combination of :

And, that when the Sun is low and thus light going through ~2000km of atmosphere rather than ~10km (do the trig), Rayleigh scattering means there's very little blue light left, so the end effect is a reddish sky. (A little counterintuitive, but thisthis is a good explanation of how that works.)

My question is why is sky red on Mars.

I've seen two explanations, both dependent on the fact that the much thinner Martian atmospheremuch thinner Martian atmosphere means the effect of Rayleigh scattering of light by gas is dominated by the effect of airborne dust.

Explanation one: the airborne dust scatters out all the blue light, so that the sky we'd see is reddish for same reason our sunrise/sunset sky is reddish. (Because there's so much dust?)

Or, simply that because the dust is red (because the surface of Mars is red - ie, lots of iron oxide), we would see a reddish sky.

Can anyone help with this?

There are some great explanations on StackExchange of why we see a blue sky on Earth, eg here.

Namely, that it's a combination of :

And, that when the Sun is low and thus light going through ~2000km of atmosphere rather than ~10km (do the trig), Rayleigh scattering means there's very little blue light left, so the end effect is a reddish sky. (A little counterintuitive, but this is a good explanation of how that works.)

My question is why is sky red on Mars.

I've seen two explanations, both dependent on the fact that the much thinner Martian atmosphere means the effect of Rayleigh scattering of light by gas is dominated by the effect of airborne dust.

Explanation one: the airborne dust scatters out all the blue light, so that the sky we'd see is reddish for same reason our sunrise/sunset sky is reddish. (Because there's so much dust?)

Or, simply that because the dust is red (because the surface of Mars is red - ie, lots of iron oxide), we would see a reddish sky.

Can anyone help with this?

There are some great explanations on StackExchange of why we see a blue sky on Earth, eg here.

Namely, that it's a combination of :

And, that when the Sun is low and thus light going through ~2000km of atmosphere rather than ~10km (do the trig), Rayleigh scattering means there's very little blue light left, so the end effect is a reddish sky. (A little counterintuitive, but this is a good explanation of how that works.)

My question is why is sky red on Mars.

I've seen two explanations, both dependent on the fact that the much thinner Martian atmosphere means the effect of Rayleigh scattering of light by gas is dominated by the effect of airborne dust.

Explanation one: the airborne dust scatters out all the blue light, so that the sky we'd see is reddish for same reason our sunrise/sunset sky is reddish. (Because there's so much dust?)

Or, simply that because the dust is red (because the surface of Mars is red - ie, lots of iron oxide), we would see a reddish sky.

Can anyone help with this?

Notice removed Draw attention by CommunityBot
Bounty Ended with no winning answer by CommunityBot
added 360 characters in body
Source Link
Errol Hunt
  • 1.1k
  • 11
  • 21

There are some great explanations hereon StackExchange of why we see a blue sky on Earth, eg here.

Namely:, that it's a combination of (a) the mix of colours from the Sun (eg, more green than indigo), plus (b) Rayleigh scattering from gas molecules (preferentially scattering shorter wavelengths, ie indigo/blue) plus (c) the sensitivity of our eyes (we see green better than indigo).:

And, that when the Sun is low and thus light going through ~2000km of atmosphere rather than ~10km (do the trig), Rayleigh scattering means there's very little blue light left, so the end effect is a reddish sky. (I'll admit that one has always confused me: a bit of scattering = blueA little counterintuitive, but a lot of scattering = NOT blue...this looksis a good explanation thoof how that works.)

My question is why is sky red on Mars.

I've seen two explanations, both dependent on the fact that the much thinner Martian atmosphere means the effect of Rayleigh scattering of light by gasgas is dominated by the effect of airborne dustairborne dust.

Explanation one: the airborne dust scatters out all the blue light, so that the sky we'd see is reddish for same reason our sunrise/sunset sky is reddish. (Because there's so much dust?)

Or, simply that because the dust is red (because the surface of Mars is red - ie, lots of iron oxide), we would see a reddish sky.

Can anyone help with this?

There are some great explanations here of why we see a blue sky on Earth, eg here.

Namely: a combination of (a) the mix of colours from the Sun (eg, more green than indigo), plus (b) Rayleigh scattering from gas molecules (preferentially scattering shorter wavelengths, ie indigo/blue) plus (c) the sensitivity of our eyes (we see green better than indigo).

And, that when Sun is low and light going through ~2000km of atmosphere rather than ~10km, Rayleigh scattering means very little blue light left, so the end effect is a reddish sky. (I'll admit that one has always confused me: a bit of scattering = blue, but a lot of scattering = NOT blue...this looks a good explanation tho)

My question is why is sky red on Mars.

I've seen two explanations, both dependent on the fact that the much thinner atmosphere means the effect of Rayleigh scattering of light by gas is dominated by the effect of airborne dust.

Explanation one: the airborne dust scatters out all the blue light, so that the sky we'd see is reddish for same reason our sunrise/sunset sky is reddish. (Because there's so much dust?)

Or, simply that because the dust is red (because the surface of Mars is red - lots of iron oxide), we would see a reddish sky.

Can anyone help with this?

There are some great explanations on StackExchange of why we see a blue sky on Earth, eg here.

Namely, that it's a combination of :

And, that when the Sun is low and thus light going through ~2000km of atmosphere rather than ~10km (do the trig), Rayleigh scattering means there's very little blue light left, so the end effect is a reddish sky. (A little counterintuitive, but this is a good explanation of how that works.)

My question is why is sky red on Mars.

I've seen two explanations, both dependent on the fact that the much thinner Martian atmosphere means the effect of Rayleigh scattering of light by gas is dominated by the effect of airborne dust.

Explanation one: the airborne dust scatters out all the blue light, so that the sky we'd see is reddish for same reason our sunrise/sunset sky is reddish. (Because there's so much dust?)

Or, simply that because the dust is red (because the surface of Mars is red - ie, lots of iron oxide), we would see a reddish sky.

Can anyone help with this?

Notice added Draw attention by Errol Hunt
Bounty Started worth 50 reputation by Errol Hunt
Tweeted twitter.com/StackPhysics/status/829619819288920066
Source Link
Errol Hunt
  • 1.1k
  • 11
  • 21

Why is sky on Mars red?

There are some great explanations here of why we see a blue sky on Earth, eg here.

Namely: a combination of (a) the mix of colours from the Sun (eg, more green than indigo), plus (b) Rayleigh scattering from gas molecules (preferentially scattering shorter wavelengths, ie indigo/blue) plus (c) the sensitivity of our eyes (we see green better than indigo).

And, that when Sun is low and light going through ~2000km of atmosphere rather than ~10km, Rayleigh scattering means very little blue light left, so the end effect is a reddish sky. (I'll admit that one has always confused me: a bit of scattering = blue, but a lot of scattering = NOT blue...this looks a good explanation tho)

My question is why is sky red on Mars.

I've seen two explanations, both dependent on the fact that the much thinner atmosphere means the effect of Rayleigh scattering of light by gas is dominated by the effect of airborne dust.

Explanation one: the airborne dust scatters out all the blue light, so that the sky we'd see is reddish for same reason our sunrise/sunset sky is reddish. (Because there's so much dust?)

Or, simply that because the dust is red (because the surface of Mars is red - lots of iron oxide), we would see a reddish sky.

Can anyone help with this?