Prag1
Reputation
Next privilege 125 Rep.
Vote down
 Jun 20 awarded Benefactor Jun 16 comment Is there a natural (suitable) definition for functional derivative in Curved space time Thanks for your answer. The extra terms 'derivative over g' , in the case of functional derivative by g_{\mu \nu} will give -1/2 \sqrt{g} g^{\mu \nu} \delta g_{\mu \nu} so you see I can again extract out the \sqrt{g}. Do you think this prescription have the chance of commutativity? Jun 15 comment Is there a natural (suitable) definition for functional derivative in Curved space time Thanks for your answer. May I ask you why you expect your points 9) , 10) to hold? That was the main point in my question. Jun 13 awarded Promoter Jun 13 awarded Critic Jun 13 revised Is there a natural (suitable) definition for functional derivative in Curved space time added 644 characters in body Jun 11 revised Is there a natural (suitable) definition for functional derivative in Curved space time added 306 characters in body Jun 8 asked Is there a natural (suitable) definition for functional derivative in Curved space time May 20 awarded Notable Question Jan 8 awarded Nice Question Jan 4 awarded Popular Question Oct 17 awarded Popular Question Jul 22 awarded Nice Question Nov 28 asked Can any rank tensor be decomposed into symmetric and anti-symmetric parts? Sep 27 awarded Editor Sep 27 revised What is the variation of Gauss-Bonnet term a total derivative of? added 13 characters in body; edited title Sep 25 comment Conformal transformation/ Weyl scaling are they two different things? Confused! Thanks I am clear about this point and I understand "undoing" by multiplying by the inverse of the function still gives a different space time. Where as conformal transformation does not change space-time just different coordinate label. I would try and attach a link to that paper then you might be able to tell where I am going wrong but not on this point. Thanks Sep 25 awarded Supporter Sep 25 asked What is the variation of Gauss-Bonnet term a total derivative of? Sep 24 comment Conformal transformation/ Weyl scaling are they two different things? Confused! Thanks a lot! it is clear when they are different. My confusion has to do with a paper I read. " Rev. Mod. Phys. 34, 442–457 (1962) Conformal Invariance in Physics" by L.Witten et al.. They talk about active point transformation and define a corresponding coordinate transformation to define a conformal transformation, which amounts to I think, rescaling the metric thus weyl transformation in our lingo. they call this $C_{g}$ however they say that special conformal transformation is a subgroup of these transformations with the usual lie-algebra in our lingo "conformal is a subgroup of weyl" ??