# Tag Info

33

Here is a free body diagram of the balls: … and one of the water volume: The four balance equations are \begin{align} B_1 - T_1 - m_1 g & =0 \\ B_2 + T_2 - m_2 g & = 0 \\ F_1 + T_1 - B_1 - M g & = 0 \\ F_2 - B_2 - M g & = 0 \end{align} where $\color{magenta}{B_1}$,$\color{magenta}{B_2}$ are the buoyancy forces, ...

18

The weight on the left bowl would be the weight of the water plus vase plus ping-pong ball (plus thread, ignored). The weight on the right bowl would be the weight of the water plus vase plus the buoyancy of the steel ball (plus the buoyancy of the submerged thread, ignored). That buoyancy is the weight of an equivalent volume of water. Since the ping-pong ...

17

A Thought Experiment We can arrive at an intuitive explanation without any special knowledge of physics. The strategy is to re-create the setup as closely as possible while keeping the two sides in balance. Imagine that you start with two identical beakers, filled with the same amount of water, no balls. Placed on the scale, they balance. On the left, ...

3

I'm amazed that this is so confounding to some. This is too long to be a comment, so I'm making it an answer. The TL;DR version: The answers that say the scale will tilt down to the right are correct. The beaker full of water with the steel ball suspended from above is heavier than is the beaker that contains the ping pong ball anchored from below. ...

2

The elasticity does not influence the measurement as long as the scale stands perfectly level and you stand perfectly still. The angle of the floor however can greatly influence the result. Your gravitational force won't compress the spring in full strength, it will rather split into normal force and downhill force. The spring will only "see" the normal ...

1

Well I got this badly wrong, and grovellingly apologise to those I traduced. It seemed easy: the water in both is the same weight, so I thought that removing it would make no difference to the balance. This was wrong: removing the water from the right hand beaker does have an effect, the presence of the suspended ball does add extra weight to it, so the ...

Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible