# Tagged Questions

Space expansion is a cosmological phenomenon wherein the proper distance between two spatial points for a given inertial reference frame increases from one moment of time to another. That is, space itself expands; the added distance is not due to relative motion of points or objects.

318 views

### How do we know for certain that space is expanding?

How do we know for certain that space is expanding? Let's say that in the year 1950, we observe that galaxy 1 is 5 billion light years away from us and galaxy 2 is 10 billion light years away from us,...
73 views

### What proof do we have that space is expanding? [duplicate]

how can we really say that space is expanding when we cannot see the distant galaxies forming nor are the planets nearby newly formed, nor is anything expanding in size nor are we going far away? (...
65 views

### Momentum conservation in FRW spacetime

The spatially flat FRW metric in Cartesian co-ordinates is given by: $$ds^2 = -dt^2 + a^2(t)(dx^2 + dy^2 + dz^2)$$ As I understand it, since the metric does not depend on the spatial co-moving co-...
110 views

### Do we really need inflation for horizon problem?

This is a very fundamental doubt. I think i am missing something in inflation. The inflation theory solves the horizon problem by stating all of the universe started from a very small region in ...
88 views

### The Doppler shift and the apparent speed of galactic rotation with distance

A Doppler redshift would also give the illusion that galaxies were rotating more slowly then they are with the degree of illusory slowing in proportion to the degree of redshift. Do more distant ...
200 views

### Traveling faster than the universe is expanding?

I was thinking, if the universe is space and time expanding, lets say in 3D (like a sphere). And it is doing that in a constant or not constant speed, there is a debate about that, never mind that but ...
353 views

### What does the accelerating expansion of the universe mean about its end?

So we know that the expansion of the universe is accelerating.When we thought that the expansion of the universe was slowing down,we predicted that it would reach a plateaux and maybe reverse the ...
153 views

### Age of the universe [closed]

Does the fact that the edge of our observable Universe contains information from the beginning of the Universe give us an ability to determine its age? The edge of our observable universe surely has ...
66 views

### We stretch as the universe does [duplicate]

Here's an idea I thought about; more of a thought experiment than anything: The universe is essentially the same as the universe 14 billion years ago, just stretched. However, all matter stretches ...
68 views

### Why is a negatively curved universe older than a flat one?

And a positively curved universe younger than a flat one? I get that negatively curved means an open universe, and positively curved is a closed one. But how can this affect their age? Is it ...
35 views

### Why do we say the universe is expanding faster and faster [duplicate]

The further we look away, the more redshift and expansion. But isn't looking further away looking back in time? Why do we not say that the younger universe (further away) was expanding faster and ...
216 views

### Where did energy come from?

So it is my understanding that before the big bang there was a very small point that held all of the matter in the universe. My question is what form did energy of the universe take on when it was in ...
74 views

### Does conservation of moment hold in space expansion?

I recently watched a video describing that the expansion of space is a "stretch". Everywhere in the universe expanding together. My question is, does conservation of momentum hold true in this ...
102 views

### Are we really sure that the whole universe is expanding?

Haven't we thought about the possibility of only a region of the universe is expanding? What about space is expanding in this region and space is compressed in another region, that satisfies the ...
275 views

### Does the universe have a different age to different observers?

Although I understand that the universe is approximately 12 billion light years wide, and that may mean that it took the light photons 12 billion years at 186,000 miles per second to reach the ...
158 views

### When they say the universe was the size of a baseball about a billion billion billion billionth of a second

after the big bang. Does that means the observable universe was the size of a baseball, or does it mean the entire universe? I'm guessing it means the observable universe - as we really don't ...
99 views

### Why should I believe that matter does not expand along with the space between it [duplicate]

This question has been asked before under other guises. I am not a scientific profesional however i have some schooling in pyhsics and mathematics and have a keen interest in these subjects. It seems ...
384 views

### Where is all the Dark Matter? Theoretical Question

In my Physics Class we had to look into possible areas where Dark Matter could be "hiding." Such as Black Holes and so on. Dark matter really can be "seen" through its gravitational effects, and we ...
124 views

### Expanding universe - does the Hubble red shift come from gravity? [duplicate]

Measurement of the expansion of the universe is based, in part, on the red shift of light. The speed of light is a constant, although some people argue that it may be changing over time, I am going to ...
117 views

### Light clocks measure conformal time - detailed argument

Let us assume that an observer is stationary at the origin in expanding space. We assume the FRW metric near the origin is given by: $$ds^2=-dt^2+a(t)^2dr^2$$ Let us assume that the observer ...
81 views

### Is our locally measured time actually conformal time?

The FRW metric at the origin $r=0$, with $c=1$, is given by: $$ds^2=-dt^2+a(t)^2dr^2$$ Now one can change variables so that near the origin the FRW metric is approximated by the Minkowski metric ...
104 views

### Flat universe and accelerating expansion

As current data suggests that the universe is flat, a flat universe would imply a slowing expansion rather than an accelerating one which we observe. Neither in an open nor a closed universe there is ...
75 views

### Does time expand along with space? [duplicate]

The flat FRW metric is given by: $$ds^2=-c^2dt^2+a(t)^2dr^2$$ If we take $dt=0$ then we get: $$ds=a(t)\ dr$$ Thus we find that space expands. If we take $ds=0$ to find the null geodesic followed ...
22 views

### Are atomic energies increasing as the Universe expands? [duplicate]

Starting from the FRW metric (for simplicity flat space, radial direction only): $$ds^2=-c^2dt^2+a(t)^2dr^2$$ If we take $dt=0$ then the proper distance $ds(t)$ between two spatially separated ...
352 views

### Is dark matter moving faster than light? [closed]

My way of thinking is as follows: Consider a balloon. Let this be blown into a nearly elliptical sphere. Now, the temperature inside the balloon is increased by some means; this leads to the ...
63 views

### Is there a friction or retarding force in creating spacetime?

As matter and energy expand with the big bang, they create spacetime (or so I've been told). Is there any evidence that this creation of spacetime has a retarding force on the expansion? If not, ...
72 views

### Expanding universe and speed of light [duplicate]

Galaxies are moving away from us proportional to the distance between us and them , but nothing can travel faster than light, so even the farmost galaxies should be travelling away from us along with ...
44 views

### Super-luminal separation

Suppose there are are 5 bodies separating in space (due to it's expansion), and let us consider that they can emit light. 1st body moves in the -x direction, at the speed of light. 2nd body moves ...
2k views

### How is it possible the universe expanded faster than the speed of light during inflation? [duplicate]

In a documentary written in collaboration with Stephen Hawking, the narrator (supposedly Stephen Hawkings) says that by the time the cosmos was 10 minutes old, it had already expanded thousands of ...
44 views

### Cosmological constant theories

Are there any hypotheses on the expansion of the universe, which have a cosmological constant, or some other parameter, that results in a universe with an ever increasing rate of acceleration for the ...
91 views

### Redshift of supernova light curve

I am trying to understand how the width of a supernova light curve depends on the redshift of its component frequencies. Let us make the simple assumption that the light curve is Gaussian. The ...
1k views

### How does the Hubble parameter change with the age of the universe?

How does the Hubble parameter change with the age of the universe? This question was posted recently, and I had almost finished writing an answer when the question was deleted. Since it's a shame to ...
176 views

### Do we need Dark Energy to explain the acceleration of the expansion of the universe?

As far as I know is the discovery that galaxies that are farther away are moving faster from us than galaxies the are closer by. This led to the theory of Dark Energy. The acceleration was speeding up....
676 views

### Space is expanding so what is time doing? [duplicate]

Space is expanding and as we know space and time are intrinsically linked to be now known as spacetime. What is happening to time during expansion? Is there more time, longer time or is the time part ...
157 views

### Why the CMB has not been dispersed so far?

Imagine you have a box of black body radiation. What happens if you open the box for a long time? It becomes dispersed and no radiation remains in the box. Now, apply this example to the Cosmic ...
53 views

### How much has the universe expanded in total from the onset of inflation until today?

Starting from the onset of inflation, through inflation, reheating, radiation domination, matter domination, the transition toward dark energy domination all the way to today, how many e-folds of ...
2k views

### Is there a center of the Universe if the Universe is finite?

Ok, let me make myself clear. I saw all the other questions related to the question, but none of them actually asks the question the way I would put it and therefore no one answers it the way I want ...
79 views

### If space is expanding, how can I see a galaxy 12 billion light years away where it is today?

Assuming space is expanding (and that seems plausible), photons from a galaxy that have been traveling for 12 billion years must have been traveling on a curve to get to us due to the fact that where ...
118 views

### If we can see a galaxy can that galaxy see us?

This is a question about the properties of the expansion of the universe. I can't say it any better than: If we observe a primordial galaxy that existed soon after the Big Bang, does it follow that ...
365 views

### What is meant by a “sodium line”?

What speed should a galaxy move with respect to us so that the sodium line at $589.0\ \mathrm{nm}$ is observed at $589.6\ \mathrm{nm}$? In the above question what's meant by a sodium line? The ...
3k views

### How is dark energy consistent with conservation of mass and energy?

I initially thought that dark energy must in some way violate conservation of mass and energy since the component of the energy density of space that comes from dark energy is constant, and space is ...
165 views

### On non-local physics in cosmology by prof. B.V. Alekseev

Recently I've encountered work by prof. B.V. Alekseev, in which he claims that some physical problems can be easily solved if we consider non-local interactions in kinetic theory (interactions of ...
175 views

### What evidence is there of a universe older than 13.8 billion years

I've read an analogy that finding iron-rich galaxies just 900 years after the Big Bang is like finding an old man in a crib in a nursery. We just recently found a supermassive black hole 12 billion ...
342 views

### Is the accelerated expansion of the universe consistent with conservation of energy? [duplicate]

If energy can neither be created nor destroyed, how come the universe is expanding at an accelerating rate? Where does this energy come from?
156 views

### Is it valid to apply Einstein's Relativity to scenarios involving expansion of space?

IIs it valid to apply Einstein's Relativity to scenarios involving expansion of space? For a practical example of this: Is it legitimate to speak of distant red-shift galaxies as experiencing time ...
80 views

### Assuming the universe is finite, at some point, CMB should go away, right?

I'm not talking about gradual red-shifting, that happens slowly anyway, but with a universe of finite size, we should actually see Cosmic Background Radiation turn off in a sense, first at a point, ...
114 views

### Is there any paper analyzing the validity of Relativity in expanding space? [duplicate]

Big Bang models result from applying Relativity equations to expanding space; however, as Einstein noted, Relativity was not established in expanding space. A basic question arises: is Relativity ...
65 views

### Long rod in an expanding universe

Suppose you have a metal rod, of vast length, floating in space. From it's center-of-mass reference frame it is assumed to be at rest with respect to the CMB. The rod will have some degree of ...