# Tagged Questions

Any of the various explanations of gravity as a quantum theory, including string theory and loop quantum gravity.

1answer
74 views

### Is Hawking radiation valid for a microscopic black hole?

A black hole evaporates by Hawking radiation. The computation of the evaporation time uses some approximations. Question: Is the evaporation time valid for a microscopic black hole? In particular, ...
1answer
249 views

### What causes gravity in M-Theory?

New and updated, because people were misunderstanding what I meant! General relativity describes gravity as the result of....(very roughly) spacetime curvature Newtonian gravity describes gravity as ...
4answers
283 views

### How far apart do two objects have to be for there to be negligible force between them?

Inspired from the commentary on this question. How far apart do two objects have to be for the gravitational force between them to be negligible? By negligible I mean, that it could never be ...
2answers
119 views

### Do quantum wave functions curve spacetime before they are measured

Do wave functions cause spacetime curvature before they are measured, or would curvature only happen upon measurement? I guess the question becomes, do quantum wavefunctions carry energy while they ...
3answers
456 views

### Do gravitational waves exist at the quantum level?

Do gravitational waves exist at quantum level produced by electrons or by atoms or by molecules? If yes, which particle produces them and how are they produced? Spacetime exists at a quantum level ...
2answers
150 views

### What is it exactly that conflicts when trying to unify all 4 fundamental forces?

Everyone knows that there are 4 fundamental forces: Gravity Electromagnetic Weak Strong At school and university you're taught that no one has been able to unify these 4 fources. However, not a ...
0answers
64 views

### Gravity dual of N free scalars in 2D

I have a very basic (and might be very naive) question. What should be the dual gravity description of $N$ (with $N>>1$) free scalars in two dimensions? I was wondering whether it would be ...
2answers
107 views

### Probing beyond the black hole event horizon

Black holes are interpreted to have a "break down" of general relativity at their point of singularity. The region near the singularity is expected to be described by some theory of quantum gravity. ...
0answers
18 views

### Boundary term from isolated horizon?

In Quantum Black Hole Physics one must add a boundary term to the Einstein-Hilbert action because of a geometric restriction on the horizon. Why? Stokes theorem doesn't apply since the horizon isn't ...
0answers
43 views

### Problems of General Relativity on small and large scales [duplicate]

As far as I know, the most important problem of GR on large scales is the cosmological constant problem which in some manner can be thought of as a dark energy problem (please correct me if I am wrong)...
0answers
50 views

### How much do we know about Quantum Gravity at energies larger than Planck energy?

What kind of predictions do current approaches to quantum gravity (superstrings/M-theory, loop quantum gravity,...) make at energies LARGER than Planck scale? Or is that a meaningless question? Does ...
3answers
770 views

### What are the technical obstructions that prevent scale relativity from being a viable theory of quantum-gravity? [closed]

This post has been imported on physicsoverflow, see here. The astrophysicist Laurent Nottale develops since 1984 the scale relativity, which aims to unify quantum physics and relativity theory, ...
4answers
3k views

### Why do physicists trust black hole physics?

Based on popular accounts of modern physics and black holes (articles, video lectures), I have come to understand the following: Black holes are predicted by General Relativity, a classical theory ...
0answers
249 views

### Can we create graviton particle or gravitational wave? [duplicate]

Can we create graviton particle or gravitational wave? I want to know if we able to generate graviton particle out of some energy. Is it theoretically possible? And could we generate gravitational ...
2answers
72 views

### Do the stellar remnant in a black hole have spatial extent? [duplicate]

I am not talking about event horizons. I am talking about the actual remnant of stellar collapse. Is it just a point, hence the problem with the singularity? Or does it have a finite volume that we ...
0answers
47 views

### Palatini type gravities: Where could I find them?

I read the article Quantum gravity with torsion and non-metricity. Although I found interesting the analysis in the paper, I found quite interesting an statement in the abstract, The class of ...
2answers
379 views

### What experiment would disprove loop quantum gravity?

Loop Quantum Gravity (LQG) is a theory of quantum space-time that attempts to describe the interconnection between general relativity and quantum mechanics. It's main postulate is the granularity of ...
1answer
271 views

### Absolute time as a common basis of quantum gravity? [closed]

Quantum mechanics has an absolute time concept, and general relativity has the dynamic time concept of spacetime. The incompatibility of both concepts is called the problem of time in quantum gravity. ...
1answer
104 views

### Can we observe a star collapse into a black hole? [duplicate]

Let's say that I happen by a star that has just burned out and is collasping into a black hole. I seat at infinity to watch it as a Schwarzschild observer. Will I ever see the black hole collapse into ...
0answers
31 views

### How is the first law of black hole thermodynamics formulated for a non-vacuum solution with event horizon?

How is the first law of black hole thermodynamics formulated for a non-vacuum solution with event horizon?
1answer
630 views

### Graviton and principle of equivalence

Is it possible that in a theory of gravitons, i.e., a quantum field theory of gravitation, general relativity's principle of the equivalence of gravitational mass and inertial mass, no longer holds?
2answers
352 views

### Why should the modes of the linearized metric perturbation be “wavefunctions” of gravitons (in the Randall-Sundrum model)?

In "An Alternative to Compactification" by Randall and Sundrum, they discuss the localization of "graviton modes" around the Planck brane in the Randall-Sundrum model where we have a compact fifth ...
1answer
143 views

### Can I teach myself physics (LQG specifically)? [closed]

OK I'm a second year undergrad student...have taken the introductory Math, Phys and Computer Science classes. I LOVE physics, and always have since I was a kid and wanted to major in that initially, ...
0answers
88 views

### Does the uncertainty principle affect event horizons? [duplicate]

I was thinking about black holes. For a simple black hole the event horizon is given by a distance of 2 times mass (energy) of the black hole. (2m). But according to quantum mechanics, if you try to ...
0answers
43 views

### Need some intuition behind spontaneous dimensional reduction

In quantum gravity there is the notion of spontaneous dimensional reduction. Namely, at small scales, the dimension of spacetime is less than the ostensible four. In the causal dynamical ...
0answers
54 views

### In discrete models of spacetime, what are some implications of the Einstein equation

We have several models of discrete spacetime. Sorkin has a causal growth dynamics, there's spin foams, Panangaden showed a correspondence between interval domains and spacetimes. I am looking for ...
2answers
505 views

### Why can't gravitons be created in traditional particle accelerators?

I've heard that it is incredibly difficult to detect a graviton, but I don't quite understand why. With all of the knowledge I have at the present time it seems like it should be possible to create a ...
1answer
79 views

### General relativity and quantum fields evolution in curved space [closed]

There are many cases when we have to discuss the problem of evolution of quantum fields on GR background (inflaton evolution during inflation, axion field evolution etc). But GR isn't quantized as ...
1answer
148 views

### Quantum mechanical explanation of the expansion of the universe?

All the explanations for the expansion of the universe that I have heard about are usually based off Einstein's General Relativity, and many quote the proposed all permeating Dark Energy as the cause ...
0answers
85 views

### About spin 2, graviton, in the context of attractive force.

excerpt from Introduction to Black hole physics, Valeri P. Frolov and Andrei Zelnikov In this textbook, there is comment about spin of gravitons as follows For gravitating bodies the gravitational ...
0answers
76 views

### Where are the gravitons in the Wheeler-de-Witt formalism?

As I understand it, in the Wheeler-de-Witt formalism you sum over the spaces bounded by a start space and and end space. What I want to know is where do gravitons fit into this picture? I ...
1answer
556 views

### Is John Nash's “Interesting Equation” really interesting?

As recently mentioned in the news, before his passing, John Nash worked on general relativity. According to the linked article John Nash's work is available online from his webpage. His work is ...
1answer
259 views

### Hawking Temperature of the BTZ Black Hole

The metric of the BTZ Black Hole is given by $$ds^2 = - N^2 dt^2 + N^{-2} dr^2 +r^2(d\phi + N^\phi dt)^2$$ with  N^2 = -M+ \frac{r^2}{l^2} + \frac{J^2}{4 r^2}, \ \ \ \ \ \ N^\phi = -\frac{J}{2r}...
1answer
1k views

### Is Gravity a Problem?

I was watching the movie "Interstellar" recently and in that a character "Romly" mentions that if he could peep into the black hole "Gargantua" he could solve gravity. I have a questions, is that a ...
1answer
325 views

### What happens as you approach/cross the Planck temperature?

According to IFLScience, above the Planck Temperature (absolute hot) conventional physics break down. My question is what happens as you approach this temperature, and, if it is possible, what ...
1answer
203 views

### What is the significance of Planck charge?

It seems for me that Planck units are somehow connected to limits where our current knowledge breaks down because of (quantum) gravitational effects. Please correct me if I'm wrong. For example ...
3answers
9k views

### Is the Planck length the smallest length that exists in the universe or is it the smallest length that can be observed?

I have heard both that Planck length is the smallest length that there is in the universe (whatever this means) and that it is the smallest thing that can be observed because if we wanted to observe ...
1answer
114 views

### What areas of research question the existence of the Planck length?

As a follow up to What are the structures that exist at roughly the scale of the Planck length?, what areas of research question the idea of a Planck length (or Planck scale)? Or if there are no areas ...
1answer
110 views

### What are the structures that exist at roughly the scale of the Planck length? [closed]

What are the mathematical/geometric structures that exist at the level of the Planck length?
1answer
741 views

### What does the universe look like at the Planck length (in a drawing)?

What is an informative drawing of the universe at the Planck length, to get a deeper sense of the meaning of it? For example, you see stuff like this: But that confuses you because there is no ...
3answers
251 views

### What do gravitons do?

Yes, I know gravitons are 'just a theory', but I'm wondering how they theoretically act. Are they raining down on everything with mass to "push" other things towards it? Or do the gravitons form a ...
1answer
99 views

### How are gravitons supposed to work?

If gravitons are particles, how is it that they can hold us to the ground, or create gravity between two stars millions of miles away from each other?
1answer
65 views

### Can anyone explain to a novice physicist whether there is a gravitational-electromagnetic symmetry?

I am trying to understand how the four fundamental forces relate to one another and to a theory of everything. As I understand it the unified force that is thought to exist at very high energies gets ...
7answers
20k views

### Does gravity exist in a vacuum?

My understanding has always been that it does from conventional science courses, but really thinking about it, I was wondering if this is really the case. To my limited understanding there is a ...
2answers
117 views

### Speed of gravity within a mass

We all consider that gravity travels at the speed of light. Light travels at the speed of light except when it is in a medium ,say glass, where it travels slower. What happens when gravity passes ...
0answers
41 views

### Planck Temperature

I have heard of two different things occurring at Planck Temperature: 1. A black hole forms 2. The quantum gravity takes over and the wavelength of light emitted from the object is Planck length ...
3answers
333 views

### Physical Significance of the Planck Density

The Planck density is the Planck mass devided by the Planck volume, approximately 1093 g/cm3. Does this quantity have any known physical relevance? The Planck mass is believed to be the smallest ...
0answers
59 views

### Force of gravity at quantum level is indetermined?

Newton's law of Universal Gravitation states that any two bodies in the universe attract each other with a force that is directly proportional to the product of their masses and inversely proportional ...
0answers
41 views

### Why should we want to quantize Gravity? [duplicate]

I understand that it will be "nice" to have a quantum description of Gravity as well, just like the other 3 forces. I would like to find out what problems arise in existing theory (not counting String ...
1answer
501 views

### We Don't NEED Quantum Gravity because Gravity isn't Even A Force! [duplicate]

Now, I understand the motivation for quantum gravity. I honestly want to work on a theory myself. However, gravity, according to General Relativity, is not a fundamental force of nature. To me, it's ...