Quantum-ElectroDynamics (QED) is the quantum field theory believed to describe the electromagnetic interaction (and with some extension the weak nuclear force).
32
votes
2answers
2k views
Why did Feynman's thesis almost work?
A bit of background helps frame this question. The question itself is in the last sentence.
For his PhD thesis, Richard Feynman and his thesis adviser John Archibald Wheeler devised an astonishingly ...
13
votes
2answers
2k views
How are classical optics phenomena explained in QED (Snell's law)?
How is the following classical optics phenomenon explained in quantum electrodynamics?
Reflection and Refraction
Are they simply due to photons being absorbed and re-emitted? How do we get to ...
13
votes
1answer
212 views
Spontaneous breaking of Lorentz invariance in gauge theories
I was browsing through the hep-th arXiv and came across this article:
Spontaneous Lorentz Violation in Gauge Theories. A. P. Balachandran, S. Vaidya. arXiv:1302.3406 [hep-th]. (Submitted on 14 ...
11
votes
1answer
371 views
how is shown that photon speed is constant using QED?
In Feynman's simple QED book he talks about the probability amplitude P(A to B) ,where A and B are events in spacetime, and he says that it depends of the spacetime interval but he didn't put the ...
11
votes
3answers
629 views
Simple (but wrong) argument for the generality of positive beta-functions
In the introduction (page 5) of Supersymmetry and String Theory: Beyond the Standard Model by Michael Dine (Amazon, Google), he says
(Traditionally it was known that)
the interactions of ...
11
votes
2answers
263 views
What tree-level Feynman diagrams are added to QED if magnetic monopoles exist?
Are the added diagrams the same as for the $e-\gamma$ interaction, but with "$e$" replaced by "monopole"? If so, is the force between two magnetic monopoles described by the same virtual ...
10
votes
4answers
726 views
QM and Renormalization (layman)
I was reading Michio Kaku's Beyond Einstein. In it, I think, he explains that when physicsts treat a particle as a geometric point they end up with infinity when calculating the strength of the ...
10
votes
3answers
259 views
Can the path of a charged particle under the influence of a magnetic field be considered piecewise linear?
Ordinarily we consider the path of a charged particle under the influence of a magnetic field to be curved. However, in order for the trajectory of the particle to change, it must emit a photon. ...
10
votes
1answer
374 views
how does dynamic casimir effect generate correlated photons
There is a recent paper on arxiv receiving lot of acclaim http://arxiv.org/abs/1105.4714
The authors experimentally show that moving a mirror of a cavity at high speeds produces light from high ...
10
votes
2answers
316 views
Using photons to explain electrostatic force
I am trying to understand the idea of a force carrier with the following example.
Let's say there are two charges $A$ and $B$ that are a fixed distance from each other. What is causing the force on ...
9
votes
4answers
320 views
The Schwinger model
The Schwinger model is the 2d QED with massless fermions. An important result about it (which I would like to understand) is that this is a gauge invariant theory which contains a free massive vector ...
9
votes
2answers
1k views
Virtual photon description of B and E fields
I continue to find it amazing that something as “bulky” and macroscopic as a static magnetic or electric field is actually a manifestation of virtual photons.
So putting on your QFT spectacles, look ...
8
votes
3answers
392 views
Why muonium is unstable?
This question is closely related to my previous question Bound states in QED.
Muonium is a system of electron and anti-muon. This article in wikipedia claims that muonium is unstable.
QUESTION: Why ...
8
votes
2answers
319 views
Quantizing EM field
Why when we quantize EM field, whe quantize the vector potential $A^\mu$ obtaining vectorial particles (photons) like the elastic field (phonons) and we can't quantize directly the EM-field tensor ...
8
votes
3answers
425 views
Why isn't light scattered through transparency?
I'm asking a question that has bothered me for years and years. First of all, let me give some context. I'm a layman in physics (college educated, math major). I've read Feynman's QED cover to cover, ...
8
votes
1answer
53 views
Relativistic corrections to quantum mechanics of Coloumb potential
Systems of charged particles (such as atomic nuclei and electrons) can be described by nonrelativistic quantum mechanics with the Coloumb interaction potential. A fully relativistic description is ...
8
votes
2answers
728 views
Bound states in QED
I am a beginner in QED and QFT.
What is known (or expected to be) about bound states in QED? As far as I understand,
in non-relativistic QM electron and positron can form a bound state. Should it be ...
8
votes
1answer
193 views
Effect of introducing magnetic charge on use of vector potential
It is well known that Maxwell equations can be made symmetric w.r.t. $E$ and $B$ by introducing non-zero magnetic charge density/flux.
In this case we have $div B = \rho_m$, where $\rho_m$ is a ...
8
votes
1answer
224 views
Did the Feynman heuristic of “simple effects have simple causes” fail for spin statistics?
Someone here recently noted that "The spin-statistics thing isn't a problem, it is a theorem (a demonstrably valid proposition), and it shouldn't be addressed, it should be understood and celebrated."
...
7
votes
2answers
116 views
Simulation of QED
Can anyone point me to a paper dealing with simulation of QED or the Standard Model in general? I will particularly appreciate a review paper.
7
votes
1answer
402 views
How are classical optics phenomena explained in QED (color)?
How is the following classical optics phenomenon explained in quantum electrodynamics?
Color
According to Schroedinger's model of the atom, only particular colors are emitted depending on the type ...
7
votes
0answers
132 views
Magnetic monopole and electromagnetic field quantization procedure
From the Maxwell's equations point of view, existence of magnetic monopole leads to unsuitability of the introduction of vector potential as $\vec B = \operatorname{rot}\vec A$. As a result, it was ...
6
votes
3answers
260 views
What is the massless limit of massive electromagnetism?
Consider electromagnetism, an abelian gauge theory, with a massive photon. Is the massless limit equal to electromagnetism? What does it happen at the quantum level with the extra degree of freedom? ...
6
votes
2answers
349 views
critical electric field that spontaneously generates real pairs
With the current QED framework, If an electric field is strong enough (say, near a nucleus with $Z > 140$) , pair production will occur spontaneously? Is this a real effect or an artifact before ...
6
votes
2answers
468 views
Deriving Planck's radiation law from microscopic considerations?
In the usual derivation of Planck's radiation law, the energies or frequencies $\omega$ of the oscillators depend on the measurements $L$ of the black body. The model is such that the only ...
6
votes
2answers
398 views
Why is the spinor field anti-commutator not made gauge invariant?
When we introduce minimal coupling for the Dirac spinor field, we introduce terms into the Lagrangian, by the substitution $i\frac{\partial}{\partial x^\mu}\mapsto i\frac{\partial}{\partial ...
6
votes
1answer
181 views
Can a photon exhibit multiple frequencies?
Can a photon be a superposition of multiple frequency states? Kind of similar to how an electron can be a superposition of multiple spin states.
6
votes
3answers
195 views
Is there a simple way to compute some physical constant from Feynman diagram statistics?
I've been playing around writing some software to generate Feynman diagrams for QED, respecting the vertex "rules" described here, and avoiding creating isomorphic duplicates.
So from a starter ...
6
votes
2answers
498 views
How do electrons interact if one of them had just exited the two slits of the double-slit experiment?
Consider the following experiment: a double-slit set-up for firing electrons one at a time. Let's now add a second electron (orange), which is fired parallel to the first one, but in the opposite ...
6
votes
1answer
254 views
Is there a strong force analog to magnetic fields?
In special relativity, magnetism can be re-interpreted as an aspect of how electric charges interact when viewed from different inertial frames.
Color charge is more complex than electric charge, but ...
6
votes
1answer
214 views
Where is the velocity term in Dirac current hiding?
The dirac current is
$$J^\mu = \bar{\psi}\gamma^\mu \psi $$
It looks weird at first because there is no derivative in the expression. So the velocity must be hidden somewhere in either $\gamma$ or ...
6
votes
4answers
795 views
How does charge work if photons are neutral?
How can an electron distinguish between another electron and a positron? They use photons as exchange particles and photons are neutral, so how does it know to repel or attract?
6
votes
3answers
2k views
Properties of the photon: Electric and Magnetic field components
Consider an electromagnetic wave of frequency $\nu$ interacting with a stationary charge placed at point $x$. My question concerns the consistency of two equally valid quantum-mechanical descriptions ...
6
votes
1answer
187 views
How to quantize the free electro-magnetic field in 2d?
I am wondering how one can quantize the free electro-magnetic field
in the two dimensional space-time. The standard method of fixing the
Coulomb gauge in 4d does not seem to generalize immediately to ...
6
votes
2answers
618 views
EM wave function & photon wavefunction
According to this review
Photon wave function. Iwo Bialynicki-Birula. Progress in Optics 36 V (1996), pp. 245-294. arXiv:quant-ph/0508202,
a classical EM plane wavefunction is a wavefunction (in ...
6
votes
1answer
127 views
Database of scattering amplitudes
I want to check whether my result for the invariant amplitude of the electron-electron scattering (to lowest order in $\alpha$; t+u channels) is correct or not.
I can't find any reference that has ...
5
votes
2answers
229 views
Geometrical significance of gauge invariance of the QED Lagrangian
The QED Lagrangian is invariant under
$\psi(x) \to e^{i\alpha(x)} \psi (x)$, $A_{\mu} \to A_{\mu}- \frac{1}{e}\partial_{\mu}\alpha(x)$. What is the geometric significance of this result? Also why is ...
5
votes
1answer
85 views
Is there Pair production in between charged plates
In classical electromagnetic theory, If parallel plates are charged oppositely and placed close to each other, there will be no charge will not flow from one plate to another.
How does this situation ...
5
votes
4answers
428 views
How is the path integral for light explained, or how does it arise?
In a question titled How are classical optics phenomena explained in QED (Snell's law)? Marek talked about the probability amplitude for photons of a given path. He said that it was $\exp(iKL)$, and ...
5
votes
2answers
285 views
On Electromagnetic Self Energy
In the process of pair annihilation an electron and a positron annihilate each other to produce a pair of photons, conserving momentum and energy. As the oppositely charged particles approach each ...
5
votes
3answers
189 views
Representation of phase in quantum mechanics
[Note: My discussion of the three answers can be found just after the question.]
Imagine three points in space that differ only by a phase angle of "something" (what doesn't really matter).
One way ...
5
votes
1answer
211 views
Can a photon see ghosts?
Does it make sense to introduce Faddeev–Popov ghost fields for abelian gauge field theories?
Wikipedia says the coupling term in the Lagrangian "doesn't have any effect", but I don't really know ...
5
votes
1answer
157 views
Why are geons unstable? Are there other problems with geons?
I read in various places geons are "generally considered unstable." Why? How solid is this reasoning?
Is the reason geons are not studied much anymore because we can't make more progress without ...
5
votes
1answer
407 views
Why is the Gupta-Bleuler gauge unfashionable?
In the early days of quantum electrodynamics, the most popular gauge chosen was the Gupta-Bleuler gauge stating that for physical states,
$$\langle \chi | \partial^\mu A_\mu | \psi \rangle = 0.$$
...
5
votes
1answer
444 views
How to calculate the properties of Photon-Quasiparticles
in recent questions like "How are classical optics phenomena explained in QED (Snell's law)?" and "Do photons gain mass when they travel through glass?" we could learn something about effective ...
5
votes
1answer
86 views
How can an asymptotic expansion give an extremely accurate predication, as in QED?
What is the meaning of "twenty digits accuracy" of certain QED calculations? If I take too little loops, or too many of them, the result won't be as accurate, so do people stop adding loops when the ...
5
votes
1answer
78 views
Is diffraction affected by interaction between photons and electrons?
Suppose we take a sheet of ordinary metal, make a narrow slit in it, and shine a light beam through the slit onto a screen. The light beam will diffract from the edges of the slit and spread out onto ...
5
votes
1answer
193 views
Is it true that the angular momentum of electromagnetic waves in an anisotropic medium is an integral of motion?
Extending my previous question Angular moment and EM wave, does it make sense to talk about the angular momentum of electromagnetic waves in an anisotropic medium? It is not obvious that the angular ...
5
votes
1answer
255 views
Why can't fermions be affected by effective gravity in non-linear quantum electrodynamics?
Quantum electrodynamics based upon Euler-Heisenberg or Born-Infeld Lagrangians predict photons
to move according to an effective metric which is dependent on the background electromagnetic
field. In ...
5
votes
0answers
233 views
Do EM waves transmit spin polarization?
Suppose you have a normal dipole antennae (transmitter and receiver) . Spin polarized current (as opposed to normal current) is sent into the transmitter, it emits an EM wave and the Receiver receives ...
