# Tagged Questions

For questions involving the Lagrangian formulation of a dynamical system. Namely, the application of an action principle to a suitably chosen Lagrangian or Lagrangian Density in order to obtain the equations of motion of the system.

I have heard the following two definitions for a symmetry of the Lagrangian: If under a coordinate transformation the form of the Lagrangian remains unchanged then there is a symmetry. If $\delta \... 4answers 3k views ### Why can't any term which is added to the Lagrangian be written as a total derivative (or divergence)? All right, I know there must be an elementary proof of this, but I am not sure why I never came across it before. Adding a total time derivative to the Lagrangian (or a 4D divergence of some 4 ... 1answer 453 views ### Invariance of action$\Rightarrow$covariance of field equations? Invariance of action$\Rightarrow$covariance of field equations? Is this statement true? I have only seen examples of this, like the invariance of Electromagnetic action under Lorentz ... 1answer 142 views ### How to use Euler-Lagrange when Lagrangian is$L=\sqrt{t}\sqrt{1+(dy/dt)^2}$In this Lagrangian problem, action is $$S = \int_{t_1}^{t_2} \sqrt{t}\sqrt{1+\dot{y}^2} \,\,dt$$ where$\dot{y} = dy/dt$and$t_1$and$t_2$are some fixed points. I tried to solve this problem using ... 2answers 836 views ### Semiclassical limit of Quantum Mechanics I find myself often puzzled with the different definitions one gives to "semiclassical limits" in the context of quantum mechanics, in other words limits that eventually turn quantum mechanics into ... 1answer 142 views ### When is numerical value of Lagrangian evaluated on-shell a full differential? I noticed recently that for many field equations, Lagrangian evaluated on-shell (i.e. using equations of motions) is a full derivative- a divergence or something, or in other words a boundary term. ... 1answer 506 views ### Is this field redefinition for free scalar field theory non-local? The action of free scalar field theory is as follows: $$S=\int d^4 x \frac{\dot{\phi}^2}{2}-\frac{\phi(m^2-\nabla^2)\phi}{2}.$$ I have been thinking to redefine field as $$\phi'(x)=\sqrt{m^2-\nabla^... 4answers 159 views ### How can I tell that a Lagrangian has an SU(2)\times SU(2) symmetry? this is a very basic question and it probably has a very simple answer. I was reading through some handouts when I came over something that I did not understand. One considered the simple Lagrangian ... 2answers 191 views ### Quantum Anomalies and Quantum Symmetries In Quantum Field Theories (QFT) there is a well known phenomenon of anomalies, where a classical symmetry is broken in the quantum theory due to a so called anomaly. This symmetry breaking can be ... 2answers 293 views ### Does the lagrangian contain all the information about the representations of the fields in QFT? Given the Lagrangian density of a theory, are the representations on which the various fields transform uniquely determined? For example, given the Lagrangian for a real scalar field$$ \mathscr{L} = ... 1answer 121 views ### Action of a massive free point-particle in relativistic mechanics I was reading about the formulation of mechanics in special relativity and found that the action for a massive free point-particle as $$S = -mc\int_a^b ds$$ So, I did a few observations, ie. $$S =... 1answer 111 views ### Why is a theory Lorentz invariant if the Lagrangian is Lorentz invariant? For if I started by trying to make the Hamiltonian Lorentz invariant, I would have failed. Indeed, the Hamiltonian is part of a covariant tensor. But how do I know that the Lagrangian is not a part of ... 2answers 230 views ### How do derivative couplings affect canonical quantization? Consider a Lagrangian for a scalar field \phi with an interaction term$$\mathcal{L}_{int} = (\partial^2 \phi)^2 \phi.$$Here I'm suppressing all indices for brevity. Now, this is just a three-... 1answer 173 views ### How do you build a Lagrangian in particle/nuclear physics? (A specific example) I know that the terms in the Lagrangian needs to be scalars (with respect to Lorentz symmetry etc.). Also I know that [see C. G. Tully (EPP) p. 85] in general, for \psi in the fundamental ... 1answer 165 views ### Is it possible to derive the brane action in pure supergravity? The branes that source the RR fields of supergravity are described by the DBI action plus a CS term. I know this only from superstring considerations. Is there a way to find this result without ... 1answer 154 views ### Lagrangian formalism and Contact Bundles In his Applied Differential Geometry book, William Burke says the following after telling that the action should be the integral of a function L: A line integral makes geometric sense only if it'... 1answer 265 views ### Caldeira-Leggett Dissipation: frequency shift due to bath coupling I am trying to understand the Caldeira-Leggett model. It considers the Lagrangian$$L = \frac{1}{2} \left(\dot{Q}^2 - \left(\Omega^2-\Delta \Omega^2\right)Q^2\right) - Q \sum_{i} f_iq_i + \sum_{i}\... 1answer 260 views ### Orbit through L4 and L5 I was reading the Wikipedia article on Lagrangian points and doing the requisite wiki walk through the various quasi-satellites of Earth when a question occurred to me: Could there be a stable or ... 0answers 248 views ### Equation of motion for cyclic model of the universe I recently started to study about cyclic universe. I came across this article [1]. My question is about the action that used for describing the cyclic model: $$S = \int d^{4}x\sqrt{-g}(\frac{1}{16\pi ... 2answers 275 views ### Why so many arguments for the transformation equations of generalized coordinates? For a system of N particles with k holonomic constraints, their Cartesian coordinates are expressed in terms of generalized coordinates as$$\mathbf{r}_1 = \mathbf{r}_1(q_1, q_2,..., q_{3N-k}, t)$$... 2answers 956 views ### Question about the apparent loophole in principle of least action In Lagrangian formalism, given two points (x_1,t_1) and (x_2,t_2), we ask the question which paths x(t) make the action S=\displaystyle \int_{t_1}^{t_2}L\ \mathrm dt stationary and satisfy the ... 4answers 1k views ### Why can't we ascribe a (possibly velocity dependent) potential to a dissipative force? Sorry if this is a silly question but I cant get my head around it. 1answer 149 views ### Free Field theory to Interacting Field theory Free field theory: Why is it said that different Fourier modes in case of a free field (say, real Klein-Gordon field) are independent of each other? Interacting field theory: How exactly does the ... 2answers 793 views ### How do I show that there exists variational/action principle for a given classical system? We see variational principles coming into play in different places such as Classical Mechanics (Hamilton's principle which gives rise to the Euler-Lagrange equations), Optics (in the form of Fermat's ... 2answers 257 views ### Damped oscillator: time-reversal, time-translation and dissipation The equation of motion of a damped oscillator$$\frac{d^2x}{dt^2}+\gamma\frac{dx}{dt}+\omega_0^2x=0$$which is invariant under time-translation t\rightarrow t+a, but not under time reversal t\... 1answer 413 views ### Why should it be allowed to set the einbein to unity? The Polyakov action for a massive free point particle with worldline \gamma is given by$$ S[\gamma] = \frac{1}{2}\int_\gamma e \biggl(\frac{1}{e^2}\dot{x}^2 - m^2\biggr)\mathrm{d}\tau $$where e... 3answers 692 views ### Noether theorem with semigroup of symmetry instead of group Suppose You have semigroup instead of typical group construction in Noether theorem. Is this interesting? In fact there is no time-reversal symmetry in the nature, right? At least not in the same ... 2answers 236 views ### What canonical momenta are the “right” ones? I'm doing some classical field theory exercises with the Lagrangian$$\mathscr{L} = -\frac{1}{4}F_{\mu \nu}F^{\mu \nu}$$where F_{\mu \nu} = \partial_\mu A_\nu - \partial_\nu A_\mu. To find the ... 1answer 195 views ### Does anybody know of any good sources that explain (generically) how we form Lagrangians/Actions/Superpotentials for different field content? I regularly find that I'll understand where the field content in a particular physics paper comes from, but then a Lagrangian or action or superpotential is stated and I don't know how it's derived. ... 5answers 345 views ### In the Principle of Least Action, how does a particle know where it will be in the future? In his book on Classical Mechanics, Prof. Feynman asserts that it just does. But if this is really what happens (& if the Principle of Least Action is more fundamental than Newton's Laws), then ... 2answers 363 views ### How do we know if a formulation of classical mechanics is correct? For example, the Lagrangian formulation. I may be missing something, i.e. not having done it in enough detail, but here is my issue: from the definition of the lagrangian (\mathcal{L}) and from ... 2answers 139 views ### Group of symmetries of Lagrange's equations Consider the following statements, for a classical system whose configuration space has dimension d: Lagrange equations admit a smaller group of "symmetries" (coordinate change under which ... 1answer 54 views ### Are there Trojan family or Hilda family satellites locked in Earth's orbit? Jupiter has many Trojan asteroids located at Lagrangian points L4 and L5 and Hilda asteroids dispersed between points L3, L4, and L5. Does the Earth have similar satellites? If so, how many? 1answer 1k views ### When is the principle of virtual work valid? The principle of virtual work says that forces of constraint don't do net work under virtual displacements that are consistent with constraints. Goldstein says something I don't understand. He says ... 1answer 449 views ### What corresponds to this Lagrangian density? Is there a physical example of a field that would have the following Lagrangian density$$ L= \sqrt{1+\phi_x^2 +\phi_y^2+\phi_z^2} $$where the subscripts denote partial derivatives and \phi is a ... 2answers 134 views ### When is stress-energy tensor defined as variation of action with respect to metric conserved? In General Relativity Einstein's equation implies that stress-energy tensor on its RHS is conserved (has vanishing divergence), due to the Bianchi identity. Considering variational principles leading ... 2answers 301 views ### Naive questions on the concept of effective Lagrangian and equations of motion? Let us consider a LC circuit containing an electric dipole moment, the quantum system (electric field E coupled with a dipole moment) can be described by the path integral$$Z=\int DEDxe^{i\int dtL},... 2answers 738 views ### Constraints of massive relativistic point particle in Hamiltonian mechanics I try to understand constructing of Hamiltonian mechanics with constraints. I decided to start with the simple case: free relativistic particle. I've constructed hamiltonian with constraint: $$S=-m\... 3answers 451 views ### Why not formulate Quantum Mechanics using Lagrangians? [duplicate] As the title implies, why is it that the most common formalisms we use in quantum mechanics prefer to describe systems in the terms of a Hamiltionian instead of a Lagrangian? Is there some ... 1answer 624 views ### Peskin & Schroeder Chapter 3.1 EoM Lorentz Invariant under Lorentz Invariant Lagrangian From Peskin & Schroeder QFT page 35: The Lagrangian formulation of field theory makes it especially easy to discuss Lorentz invariance. And equation of motion is automatically Lorentz ... 1answer 792 views ### Lagrangian of 2D square lattice of point masses connected by springs Zee's QFT book mentions the Lagrangian of a square 2D horizontal lattice of point masses, connected by springs, and considering only vertical displacements q_{i}, as L = \frac{1}{2} \sum\limits_{... 3answers 536 views ### Physical meaning of the Lagrangian function [duplicate] In Lagrangian mechanics, the function L=T-V, called Lagrangian, is introduced, where T is the kinetic energy and V the potential one. I was wondering: is there any reason for this quantity to be ... 4answers 838 views ### Least-action classical electrodynamics without potentials Is it possible to formulate classical electrodynamics (in the sense of deriving Maxwell's equations) from a least-action principle, without the use of potentials? That is, is there a lagrangian which ... 2answers 337 views ### Deriving Newton's first law from the principle of least action Newton's first law states that if the net force on an object is zero, then this object moves with constant velocity. I'm interested in the derivation of this law from the principle of least action. ... 2answers 387 views ### Defining quantum effective action (Legendre transformation), existence of inverse (field - source)? Given a Quantum field theory, for a scalar field \phi with generic Action S[\phi], we have the generating functional$$Z[J] = e^{iW[J]} = \frac{\int \mathcal{D}\phi e^{i(S[\phi]+\int d^4x J(x)\... 1answer 356 views ### Sign in front of QFT kinetic terms I'd like to know if the sign in front of a kinetic term in QFT important. For the scalar field we conventionally write (in the$ + --- $metric), {\cal L} _{ kin} = \frac{1}{2} \... 1answer 256 views ### Heuristic Motivation for Lagrangian Formalism Does anyone know a good heuristic motivation for the Lagrangian Formalism? I think most physicist just accept at one point that it works and thats that. I think I understand the historic origin. ... 2answers 2k views ### Can a force in an explicitly time dependent classical system be conservative? If I consider equations of motion derived from the principle of least action for an explicitly time dependent Lagrangian $$\delta S[L[q(\text{t}),q'(\text{t}),{\bf t}]]=0,$$ under what ... 1answer 134 views ### Lie algebra of axial charges Starting from the lagrangian (linear sigma model without symmetry breaking, here$N$is the nucleon doublet and$\tau_a$are pauli matrices)$L=\bar Ni\gamma^\mu \partial_\mu N+ \frac{1}{2} \partial_\...
My question is in reference to Landau's Vol. 1 Classical Mechanics. On Page 6, the starting paragraph of Article no. 4, these lines are given: If an inertial frame $К$ is moving with an ...