Take the 2-minute tour ×
Physics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for active researchers, academics and students of physics. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I have a puzzle I can not even understand. A graviton is generally understood in $D$ dimensions as a field with some independent components or degrees of freedom (DOF), from a traceless symmetric tensor minus constraints, we get:

  1. A massless graviton has $D(D-3)/2$ d.o.f. in $D$-dimensional spacetime.

  2. A massive graviton has $D(D-1)/2-1$ d.o.f. in $D$-dimensional spacetime.

Issue: In classical gravity, given by General Relativity, we have a metric (a symmetric tensor) and the Einstein Field Equations(EFE) provide its dynamics. The metric has 10 independent components, and EFE provide 10 equations. Bianchi identities reduce the number of independent components by 4. Hence, we have 6 independent components. However, for $D=4$, we get

  1. 2 independent components.

  2. 5 independent components.

Is the mismatch between "independent" components of gravitational degrees of freedom (graviton components) one of the reasons why General Relativity can not be understood as a quantum theory for the graviton?

Of course, a massive graviton is a different thing that GR but even a naive counting of graviton d.o.f. is not compatible with GR and it should, should't it? At least from the perturbative approach. Where did I make the mistake?

share|improve this question
Does this help? -- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/… . I don't see any quantum mechanics in the question at all. It seems purely classical. –  Ben Crowell Aug 16 '13 at 0:11
This question (v3) is also addressed in e.g this and this Phys.SE answers. –  Qmechanic Aug 16 '13 at 8:22
@BenCrowell Well, I have certainly some confussion, that is why I asked. GR is a classical field theory for the metric (without torsion). Gravitational field is provided with the aid of a metric. Therefore, I am interested in the number of independent components of the "graviton" due to the Weinberg's formulae I wrote above. However counting independent d.o.f. does not match what I believed to. –  riemannium Aug 16 '13 at 15:37
add comment

1 Answer

As far as counting d.o.f.s for GR, I believe it goes: Start with a symmetric tensor (10 d.o.f in 4-D). Throw out 4 because of the Bianchi identities (6 d.o.f left). Throw out another 4 because of invariance under space-time diffeomorphisms (in other words, GR is invariant under General Coordinate Transformations, so you have 4 unphysical d.o.f.s). Thus there are only two degrees of freedom left.

Regarding massive gravity, see: Theoretical Aspects of Massive Gravity by Kurt Hinterbichler [arxiv 1105.3735] which has a fairly readable introduction.

share|improve this answer
Question: were not the Bianchi identities the 4 relationships due to Diff. invariance itself too? Anyway I think I understand this stuff better know... :). By the way, thanks for the reference. –  riemannium Aug 20 '13 at 10:27
add comment

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.