Take the 2-minute tour ×
Physics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for active researchers, academics and students of physics. It's 100% free, no registration required.

If water is introduced in a container maintained at 20 °C in vacuum conditions, a gaseous phase will appear and the pressure will stabilize at the vapour pressure for the given temperature inside the container. So far so good.

Now imagine the experiment is repeated but instead of vacuum conditions, the water is presurized with nitrogen at 1 atm. According to the phase diagram of water, liquid is the stable form of water in these conditions. Yet it is commonly observed that the water molecules with the highest kinetic energy will escape and form a gaseous phase. The partial pressure of gaseous water will be equal to the saturation pressure at this temperature.

Why do we say that this is a liquid/vapour equilibrium in this case, since the liquid phase is not at pressure required for this equilibrium to appear?

Edit: I just realized that my question seems to be answered by Raoult's law.

share|improve this question
    
I don't think Raoult's law is applicable except when the liquid is composed of multiple things. I think you just want Dalton's law. –  Rick Jan 21 at 19:46

2 Answers 2

up vote 1 down vote accepted

Single species

At the surface of a liquid, molecules are constantly being ejected from the liquid surface and gas molecules rejoining it. When those two rates are equal there's no net change and the system is in equilibrium.

The rate at which liquid water will eject a molecule is roughly independent of pressure and is based solely on temperature. The temperature determines how much kinetic energy the molecules have while the pressure just determines how tightly packed they are and they're already very tightly packed so the density doesn't change much. There are always water molecules right on the surface because of this high density.

The rate at which gaseous water molecules rejoin the water depends on how often one hits the surface which depends on the density. By the ideal gas law, the density is related to pressure and temperature, so if we've already set the temperature, it only depends on pressure. Thus the higher the pressure, the higher the density, the more gaseous water molecules there are to hit the surface and join it.

Locally, the density and pressure of the gaseous water molecules will increase until the rate of rejoining is equal to the rate of evaporation.

Multi gas species

Other gasses can feel free to bombard the surface of the water, compressing it a little bit, and increasing the pressure significantly. However, this doesn't increase the rate at which water molecules escape, so the vapor will still equilibrate at the same partial pressure.

Multi liquid species

This is where Raoult's law comes in. On the liquid surface there are now two species of molecules but the rate at which molecules are ejected is still the same. Now those ejections must be split between species, and according to Raoult's law, it's based on the concentration. If 30% of the liquid's molecules are water then 30% of the ejections will be water, so the rate of ejection is reduced to 30%. So in equilibrium the rate of rejoining must also be 30% so there must be 30% as many collisions thus 30% the density and thus 30% the vapor pressure.

Non Equilibrium

Examining the gas directly above the surface would show a partial pressure of water that approaches the vapor pressure of water for that temperature very quickly. These water molecules would then diffuse through the nitrogen which would slowly lower the local partial pressure if it was not being replenished by additional evaporation from the surface. This evaporation requires energy to overcome the latent heat and as such it will lower the local temperature of the water. Water is a much better heat conductor than air so this heat is drawn from the water.

In some evaporation processes the slow diffusion of the gas dominates, in others, the temperature drops until the diffusion process dominates. This is why liquid nitrogen gets and stays so cold, and why wet bulb temperatures are lower than dry bulb temperatures.

If you'd like to learn more about the steady state solution I would recommend reading about relative/absolute humidity, condensation etc.

If you'd like to learn more about the rate limiting effect look into gas diffusion.

If you'd like to learn more about the evaporation condensation process learning about statistical thermodynamics would help.

share|improve this answer

When you say “not at the pressure required for this equilibrium to appear”, you make this statement by comparison with water’s phase diagram. However, water’s phase diagram tells you of the behaviour of bulk water, and your system including nitrogen is not bulk water, it’s bulk water plus nitrogen. Thus, comparison of the total pressure of this composite system to the water’s bulk phase diagram is not valid.

share|improve this answer
    
The vapor pressure of water does not depend on the pressure of other gases in the container. –  pentane Jan 21 at 21:09

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.