Take the 2-minute tour ×
Physics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for active researchers, academics and students of physics. It's 100% free, no registration required.

According to the reports, the shutdown procedures at all the Fukushima reactors were successful, and all the control rods were fully inserted.

So - if there was a meltdown, would the control rods also melt and blend into the resulting material (corium)? If so, would that have the effect of "diluting" the corium in radioactive terms and stabilising it to some extent? (I guess it would depend on the relative melting points of the fuel and the control rods: if the rods are of boron, the melting point is a lot higher than that of uranium.)

share|improve this question

2 Answers 2

A nuclear reactor system is a very delicately balanced system for sustained chain reaction controlled by the control rods.

As in fukushima reactors, which are light water reactor where you have enriched uranium, the criticality depends heavily on the core configuration and the position of control rods.

In a core meltdown, what it meant is the uranium core get melted and settles down and the core configuration gets damaged; for control rod mechanism to work the control rods should be surrounded by active core

Actually, that's how reactor power is reduced by inserting the control rods into the core, Now, when core meltdown occurs the core becomes inaccessible for control rods, since it settles down.

enter image description here

So, the question whether control rods melts is heavily dependent on the mature of accident. Control rods are generally made of stainless steel with boron or cadmium or hafnium, while core is Uranium which is somewhat like soft metals sodium having melting point near 1100 degree Celsius, while SS has melting point near 1500 degree Celsius. Again some reactor used $UO_2$ as fuel which has higher melting point than metallic uranium. I don't know fukushima used which one!!

So, due to the temperature difference, is seems unlikely that control rods melted in fukushima, rather it seems to me that control rod melting is a good thing for controlling the reactor in case of a core meltdown.

share|improve this answer

A typical control rod will be stainless steel plus boron carbide, boron steel, a silver/cadmium containing metal rod or halfmium. If these were heated up then they would be likely to melt along with the fuel. It is likely that the molten pool of fuel would have mixed with it the control rod material if a "melt down" occurs.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.