Take the 2-minute tour ×
Physics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for active researchers, academics and students of physics. It's 100% free, no registration required.

A friend asked me if it would be possible to make soap bubbles out of a gas like hydrogen and if you did, would they float higher, faster. Due to the lower mass of light gases (compared to the air) I know they will float up faster (buoyancy). I wonder how stable they would be though.

My question is, will bubbles filled with a light gas like helium or hydrogen be stable for similar time periods to bubbles filled with air? I suspect there are complicated effects between the gas and the surface tension of the soap. Will the smaller molecules of the light gases be able to breach the soap bubble faster?

I found a video that shows bubbles filled with air having helium added to them. They seem stable but I wonder if they'd be stable if they didn't have the air mixed in (pure helium).

share|improve this question

1 Answer 1

up vote 2 down vote accepted

I have seen bubbles made with hydrogen. This is a popular trick with the various lecturers who do fireworks related lectures because the bubbles make a satisfying pop if you ignite them.

A bubble is mainly stabilised by layers of surfactant adsorbed at the gas/water interface. As the bubble wall thins, the adsorbed surfactant layers at the opposite gas/water surfaces come into contact and prevent further thinning. This is a purely kinetic barrier as the gas/water surface tension is still greater than zero (i.e. you'd reduce the overall energy by reducing the surface area) but the rate of desorption of surfactant from the surface is slow.

In principle the gas will affect the adsoption of the surfactant at the gas/water interface and possibly affect the stability, but in practice all common gases are so different from water that the relatively minor differences between gases makes little difference. Bubbles can even be blown with steam as long as you keep the gas phase temperature above 100C.

However, over medium timespans the gas inside the bubble will diffuse out through the water film and cause the bubble to shrink. The rate at which this happens will depend on the solubility of the gas and its diffusion rate in water. I'm sure there will be differences between hydrogen and air, though I don't know of anyone who has actually measured it. I found papers reporting diffusion rates here and here, though both are behind paywalls. I had better luck with solubility figures. Both hydrogen and helium are about a factor of ten less soluble in water than nitrogen, which would make their bubbles more stable than air bubbles though their greater diffusion rates will counteract this to some extent.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.