# Why frequency doesn't change during refraction?

When light goes through one medium to another it's velocity and wavelength changes. Why frequency doesn't change in this phenomenon?

-
Closely related to many other questions. May have an answer from Chris here or here and also here –  Waffle's Crazy Peanut Mar 30 '13 at 13:19

The electric and magnetic fields have to remain continuous at the refractive index boundary. If the frequency changed, the light at each side of the boundary would be continuously changing it's relative phase and there would be no way to match the fields.

-
I think it's the simplest explanation... –  Arafat Mar 30 '13 at 17:56
@Kazi Then you should probably accept this answer. –  Douglas B. Staple Apr 10 '13 at 17:24
I'm not sure I quite buy this answer. The things that have to be continuous at the boundary are $D_\perp$, $E_\parallel$, $B_\perp$, and $H_\parallel$. On the other hand, there can be discontinuities in $D_\parallel$, $E_\perp$, $B_\parallel$, and $H_\perp$. So I think there is really more that needs to be filled in to make this a valid argument. –  Ben Crowell Sep 15 '13 at 20:24

When we think of light, we can describe it as an electromagnetic wave or as a flux of particles - photons. The latter description is more fundamental: If you could have a light source with sensitive enough intensity knob, then after just turning it on (minimum intensity), you'd be sending out photons one by one. I believe that answers to your deep questions lie therein. Behold:

Energy of one light quantum (one photon) can be written $E = hf$, where $h$ is a universal (Planck's) constant, $E$ is energy and $f$ is frequency. We cannot divide photon in pieces, so its energy must stay constant and frequency goes the same way. Devices that appear to divide photons (or change photons' frequency) actually first swallow-destroy the incoming photons and then emit other photons at a different frequency. Frequency of light does not ever change, as long as you can be sure that the photons are the same as the photons at the beginning.

Wavelength $L$ is, on the other hand, tied with energy through its speed, $E = hf = hv/L$ . Atoms of materials, even gases like air, impede the flow of photons - photons bounce off of the atoms (elastic collisions) or are swallowed and re-emitted by the atoms (inelastic collisions). Like I wrote above, a photon swallowed and re-emitted is a different photon. So, it is not part of the original light stream. The Snell's laws speak only about the part of light (photons) that experienced only elastic collisions in a material.

So, in passing from one material to another, light changes wavelength proportionally to the change of speed, so that the ratio $v/L = f$ remains constant. But does that mean that it changes color? That depends, how you define color! As color is usually defined via wavelength (i.e. visible light wavelengths in the range 300-700 nm), then indeed, color changes on the interface of two optical materials with different indexes of refraction (like air-glass, air-water, etc).

-
Is there any example where photon and atoms have inelastic collision? –  Arafat Mar 30 '13 at 18:03

Think of it like this: At the boundary/interface of the medium, the number of waves you send is the number of waves you receive, at the other side, almost instantly. Frequency doesn't change because it depends on travelling of waves across the interface.

But speed and wavelength change as the material on the other side may be different, so now it might have a longer/shorter size of wave and so the number of waves per unit time changes.

-