Physics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for active researchers, academics and students of physics. It's 100% free.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Connect the positive terminal of a battery to a piece of p-doped semiconductor, say, silicon doped with boron. Will the terminal pull electrons out of the doped silicon, or equivalently, inject holes into it?

The atomic structure of p-doped semiconductors certainly accepts electrons freely, but I feel like it should be stingier than an insulator when it comes to donating electrons. As an example of an insulator, undoped silicon is unwilling to give away electrons, or accept holes, because that would rip gaps in the stable crystalline bonding. P-type silicon should behave similarly here; thus, I would guess that the p-type block remains neutral, unlike a copper block which would take on the same charge as the terminal. However, if it were connected to a negative terminal, it would accept enough electrons to basically saturate it and give it a negative charge. Is this understanding correct? Or could the p-type somehow donate electrons/accept holes because of some kind of instability associated with doping?

EDIT: Admittedly, this is a rather petty question, and I doubt that anyone has ever bothered to check the answer in a published experiment. Still, knowing that the p-type stays neutral would confirm most people's (or at least my) model of why doped semiconductors conduct. Their conductivity possesses a kind of asymmetry, unlike that of copper, which gives and takes electrons equally freely.

share|cite|improve this question
Your question actually breaks up into two sections: 1. what happens when we touch some lightly p-doped semiconductor against metal to either form a "cats-whisker" Schottky diode, or use heavy p-doped material to form a non-rectifying thermocouple-style junction? 2. What happens when touching either a diode or a thermocouple against a supply terminal which is positive with respect to ground? As for donating/accepting, these are basically symmetrical if the metal-P junction doesn't form a rectifier. – wbeaty Jul 5 '13 at 6:05

The P-type material already has a positive charge and thus a lack of free electrons so, no, it will not pull electrons from it making it more positively charged. You have to make a complete circuit in order to move electrons. Like Kirchoff said, if one electron leaves, then one has to take it's place. So if you take the negative terminal and connect it to the other side of the chunk o' P-type silicon then you'll have electrons moving. You will have also created a dead short... but that's ok. Everyone likes a little arcy sparky blowy upy.

share|cite|improve this answer
Actually, it is a common misconception that doped materials have charge. In fact, p-type semiconductor is neutral. The electron holes are only gaps in the bonding structure. Doping silicon with boron, for instance, means sprinkling a few atoms with 5 protons and 5 electrons (3 valence) among atoms with 14 protons and 14 electrons (4 valence). The difference in valence electrons creates unstable gaps in the otherwise diamond-like bonding pattern. Similarly for n-type. – Kent Apr 5 '13 at 20:10

The answer to your main question is NO. Connecting only one side of a battery (positive or negative) does not alter the electrical state of the block (semiconductor, copper, etc.). It is only until the negative side of the battery is also applied, that something can happen. For an undoped block, since the resistance is large, a small current will flow. For a copper block, since the resistance is small, a large current will flow. For the doped block, the resistance is "medium," so a medium current will flow.

An example that might make this clear is the case of two plates separated by some distance (a capacitor), but even here, nothing happens when you connect only one side of the battery to one plate. It's only until the negative terminal is connected to the other plate that a potential difference exists between the plates causing some of the electrons on the plate attached to the positive terminal to be removed, causing the plate to be positively charged, (the opposite happens on the other plate). The plates continue to "charge" until the voltage across the plates equals the battery voltage and then the current flow stops.

Note: The battery terminal does not have a charge, what the battery has, is a voltage difference/potential between its terminals! This is why nothing happens, unless you use both terminals.

share|cite|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.