Physics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for active researchers, academics and students of physics. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

My understanding is that QCD has three color charges that are conserved as a result of global SU(3) invariance. What about SU(2) weak? Does it have two types of charges? What I'm getting at is:

U(1) --> 1 type of charge

SU(2) --> ?

SU(3) --> 3 types of charge

Does SU(2) have two types? If not, what is the relation between SU(N) invariance and the number of charge types?

Idea: Maybe both I and I_3 (weak isospin and its third component) are conserved before electroweak symmetry breaking? Is that true? If so, then that would answer my question.

share|cite|improve this question
1  
Actually each of the symmetry generators commutes with the Hamiltonian and gives a conserved charge. For an SU(N) group the number of generators is $N^2 - 1$. The total number of generators in the SM is $ 1 + (2^2 - 1) + (3^2 -1) = 12$. – Michael Brown Mar 14 '13 at 13:41
    
@Michael Brown, I am aware that local invariance of SU(N) leads to N^2-1 gauge fields, however I think this is a different question from what I am asking. SU(3) has 8 gauge fields (quantized becomes 8 gluons), but 3 colors. 3 conserved charges, due to global invariance of SU(3), not local. – user1247 Mar 14 '13 at 13:54
    
Look up Noether's theorem again. There is a conserved current $j_\mu^A$ for every generator $T^A$ of the group, i.e. the currents live in the adjoint rep. Therefore there are $N^2 - 1$ conserved charges. The number of components in the fundamental rep is a different matter. For SU(N) that is $N$. – Michael Brown Mar 14 '13 at 14:45
    
@Michael Brown, I thought that color charge was conserved, and that SU(3) implied three such colors. Am I mistaken that the "3" colors are related to the "3" in SU(3), and that their conservation is related to Noether's theorem? Any help would be appreciated. – user1247 Mar 14 '13 at 15:24
2  
The "3" is the same 3 as in the SU(3). There are indeed three colours. I didn't say gluons are conserved. But there are 8 conserved quantities in an SU(3) theory, which are the generators of the symmetry group. If it helps you can think of these formally as colour-anticolour pairs (look up 't Hooft double line formalism) since the charges live in the adjoint rep which is isomorphic to fundamental $\otimes$ antifundamental. There is always a conserved quantity associated to any continuous symmetry via Noether's theorem. # of symmetries = # of conserved quantities. – Michael Brown Mar 14 '13 at 16:39

@Michael Brown is right. The SM has 12 exactly conserved charges.

  • All local invariances, a fortiori also imply global invariances, if you ignore (for the sake of argument) the spacetime variability of transformation parameters/angles. So SU(3) has 8, not 3 conserved charges, RG, BG, .... The group has 8 generators. Likewise, SU(2) has 3, not 2 conserved charges: you know this from spin, where each of the 3 projections of a rotationally invariant system is conserved. U(1) has one conserved charge.
  • SSB does not affect the number of conserved charges, in sharp contrast to explicit symmetry breaking: The currents are still conserved, except they have a special nonlinear form (their leading term is linear, not bilinear in the fields, so the corresponding charges shift the fields "nonlinearly"). The symmetry is hidden, and much less apparent, but it is still there, which is why these symmetries are so powerful: they control systematically the divergences of the corresponding QFT.
  • There are further approximate symmetries in the SM, meaning that their charges are violated by a "small" amount (a technical characterization), or even quantum anomalies (collective quantum action of the Dirac sea of fermions coupling chirally to them).

[Tom Kibble, in memoriam]

share|cite|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.