Physics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for active researchers, academics and students of physics. It's 100% free.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

A simple question I hope...

Initially, have two separate containers of 2 different ideal gases, 1.) N1, P, T, V1 and 2.) N2, P, T, V2.

After mixing, the pressure and temperature are still P and T, but the volume is additive. Assuming isolated system.

So I calculated the change in entropy with $\Delta\,S_i = n\,R\,\ln((V1+V2)/Vi)$. I found the change to be positive, which is to be expected.

Then when I look at the first law, $d\,U = \delta\,Q - \delta\,W$, I think that as the temperatures did not change then the internal energy of the gases did not change and $d\,U = 0$. Also, I think that there was no work done and so there is no heat transfer, $\delta\,Q$. *Is this right? * *Is the total energy change zero too? *

share|cite|improve this question

Let's assume that in your setup:

  1. The combined system of gas 1 + gas 2 is thermally insulated from the environment (so that there is no heat exchange between the environment and the gases as they mix.

  2. The original gas samples are separated by a partition, and to allow them to mix we simply remove the partition and allow them to freely expand into one another to fill the entire container.

In this case, one should be careful not to use the first law in differential form (which only holds for quasi-static processes). The first law is still true, however in the form $\Delta U = Q-W$ where $Q$ is the total heat transferred to the combined system, and $W$ is the total work done by the system. You are right that $Q=0$ and $W=0$ in such a situation and therefore $\Delta U = 0$ as you indicate.


share|cite|improve this answer

On a simpler note consider it this way:

1) Firstly the assumption of system being 'isolated' implies that there is no exchange of heat/energy (or mass/enthalpy) with its surrounding. Hence ΔQ = 0. Here the system is two gas volumes, and the surrounding is everything else.

2) Secondly since both the gases are at same pressure to begin with, they do not expend or gain any p-V work during mixing. Hence, ΔW = 0. An intricacy may arise from the process of removing the partition between the gases which will add a finite amount of 'work' to the system, but this can be neglected in the present case. This is similar to what is referred to as the 'stirrer work' in many thermodynamics textbooks.

And so from the first law of thermodynamics, the system should not undergo any change in its internal energy.

share|cite|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.