Take the 2-minute tour ×
Physics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for active researchers, academics and students of physics. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Why the colors of Secondary rainbow is reverse of that in the color in the Primary rainbow?

What can be the possible reason among the following options

  • Because it is formed by one internal reflection.
  • Because it is formed by two internal reflections.
  • Because it is formed by refraction and one internal reflection.
  • Because it is formed by refraction, dispersion and one internal reflection.
share|improve this question
    
The Wikipedia article on Rainbows offers a number of supporting images, but to my surprise does not offer either an explanation or an image to support one. –  dmckee Dec 8 '12 at 18:50

2 Answers 2

up vote 4 down vote accepted

When a primary rainbow is formed, it is due to one total reflection in water droplets. A secondary rainbow is formed by light that underwent two internal reflections, and that is what changes the ordering of the colours. You can also have a tertiary rainbow formed by three internal reflections that would have the same ordering as primary and so on.

share|improve this answer

Actually, total internal reflection of sunlight is impossible in spherical raindrops. The sunlight enters the drop at less than the critical angle, and symmetry makes it strike the boundary at the same angle it had when it entered. An internal reflection occurs, but it is not total and a fraction of the light exits while the rest reflects. The same fraction exits each time the reflected light hits the boundary, decreasing the internal light each time.

The rainbow is not just an arc, it is a full disk. The disks are sized differently for each color, and are brightest at the very edge, which is what makes the colored arcs appear. The colors are not reversed because of the number of reflections, but because of the size of these disks.

For the primary rainbow, the disks are centered at the anti-solar point, which is the point you'd see looking directly away from the sun. The violet disk is 40 degrees wide (measured from the center), and the red disk is 42 degrees, so the red arc appears outside of the violet.

For the secondary, the disks are centered on the sun - away from the direction you are looking when you see it. The violet disk is 127 degrees wide, and the red disc is 130 degrees wide. Because they are more than 90 degrees - in the second quadrant - these disks wrap around the zenith, so that you see the secondary's colored arcs in the same direction you see the primary's arcs. Technically, the red arc is still outside of the violet arc, but you see them reversed ("outside"="down") because of this wrapping.

For higher orders, the red bow is always on the "outside" of the bow, but that can be "up" or "down." Red is "up" when it is in the first or third quadrant, and "down" in the second or fourth. For example, the tertiary is centered away from the sun, and about 220 degrees wide. Because this is in the third quadrant, it actually wraps around the sun as well as the zenith, and "outside" is again "up." The theoretical (it is so faint that it is obliterated by light that exits without reflection) 12th order bow is the first to break the pattern of odd-order being red-up, and even-order being red-down.

share|improve this answer
    
A diagram would go a long way here. –  Brandon Enright Mar 4 at 16:03
    
"total internal reflection is impossible in spherical raindrops; an internal reflection occurs, but it is not total." I suppose that I understand what you mean by that, but if so it needs some qualification. If you mean it in an absolute sense then I believe that you are wrong. –  dmckee Jun 28 at 17:22
    
When light strikes a spherical raindrop at angle A to the surface normal, it enters the drop at angle B as defined by Snell's Law. Because of symmetry, when it strikes the back of the drop, it makes the same angle B with the surface normal there. Snell's Law applies again, in reverse. Since Total Internal Reflection occurs only when there is no external angle A that corresponds to this angle B, but we know there is one here, TIR is impossible. If you think otherwise, you are mis-applying the word "total" in TIR. –  JeffJo Nov 14 at 15:40

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.