assuming we can evaluate the eigenvalue staircase $ N(E) $ in both manners with the Bohr-Sommerfeld quantization rule
$ N(E)2\pi \hbar = \oint _{C}p.dq $
and using the Gutzwiller trace $ N(E)= N_{smooth} (E) + \delta N_{osc} (E) $
here the oscillating part is given by a sum over orbits in the phase space
are the two formulations equivalent ??