Take the 2-minute tour ×
Physics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for active researchers, academics and students of physics. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I need to calculate the initial velocity required to launch a projectile at a given angle from point A to point B. The only force acting on the projectile after launch will be gravity – zero air resistance. The projectile is launched within a simulated, virtual environment; however, I am asking for help with the physics rather than the simulation itself.

I have had success (with a different equation) when point A and point B are at the same height; however, once point B is at a different height, my calculations become less precise – well, wrong in fact.

I researched the following formula for finding the range of a projectile on uneven ground. The parameters are all available to me, except the initial velocity that I need to solve for.

$d$ : range or distance
$v_i$ : initial velocity
$g$ : gravity
$\theta$ : launch angle
$y_0$ : launch height

$$d = \frac{v_i \cos\theta}{g}(v{_i} \sin \theta + \sqrt{(v_i \sin\theta)^2 + 2gy_0})$$

I attempted to solve for initial velocity (eq: A):

$$v_i = \sqrt{\frac{d^2g}{2\cos\theta^2(y_0+d \tan\theta)}}$$

Using this equation in my simulation I apply the velocity to a normalised displacement vector and launch the projectile. It gets close to its target but:

  • $x_{final}$ is always correct
  • $z_{final}$ is always incorrect - it is close to the desired $z$ but always offset by a seemingly proportional amount.

I have spent many hours trying to review the equation but I have been unsuccessful. Any advice would be most appreciated:

  • is this the correct equation?
  • have I solved for $v_i$ correctly? I have looked for an example equation online but I have not found one structured how I need it, i.e. solving for $v_i$
  • I have spent hours researching online - perhaps I have missed some good (but entry-level) resources. Do you know of any reference material that may help me?

Update - I have now named the equation above for referencing below

Following on from the answer by @Pygmalion, which I am still gratefully working to understand:

I agree that your derived equation is equivalent to mine (A). Using yours (@Pygmalion's) in my simulation, I therefore observe the same failures: the projectile always lands short of the target.

I have simplified the simulation keeping the launch height and target height the same. I still encounter the same problem with equation A; however, when passing the same parameters to the following equation the projectile always hits the target precisely (eq: B):

$$v_i = \sqrt{\frac{dg}{\sin2\theta}}$$

Given the success of equation B when the launch and target heights are the same and the failure of equation A given the same conditions, I question whether equation A is the correct one to solve the problem since I would expect it to work for any combination of launch|target height.

I think the help I need is around why equation B works. Does it cater for conditions that equation A overlooks? If equation A is unsuitable, are you able to recommend an alternative?

In short, the $v_i$ calculated by equation A (in my simulations) is always less than $v_i$ from equation B given the same inputs - the projectile therefore always falls short of its target.

share|improve this question
    
Hi James, and welcome to Physics Stack Exchange! This is a borderline case, in part because it is a very elementary question, but I think you're correct that the homework tag doesn't apply because what you actually need is the answer, not the method by which you would derive an answer. –  David Z May 8 '12 at 12:19
    
Are you solving the problem in 2D or 3D? You say "$z_{final}$ is always incorrect - it is close to the desired $z$ but always offset by a seemingly proportional amount". And then you also have $y_0$ in your answer for the initial velocity. Perhaps the geometry of the situation is not clearly stated. –  Vijay Murthy May 8 '12 at 16:55
    
I'm solving in 3D; however, I have hopefully simplified my test scenario sufficiently to avoid the extra complication: Xinitial and Xfinal are both 0; Yi and Yf are both equal; Zi and Zf are different. In this scenario, Z is treated as X in the 2D domain. Once the problem is solved then I will move the target in X also, but until then X is redundant. As mentioned earlier, in this setup, equation A fails yet equation B succeeds. –  James May 8 '12 at 17:01
add comment

1 Answer

up vote 4 down vote accepted

This types of problems are solved by observing projectile movements in $x$ and $y$ direction separately. In $x$ direction you have constant velocity movement

$$v_x = v_{x0} = v_0 \cos(\theta), \; (1)$$

$$x = v_{x0} t +x_0 = v_0 \cos(\theta) \; t +x_0, \; (2)$$

and in $y$ direction you have constant acceleration movement with negative acceleration $-g$

$$v_y = - g t + v_{y0} = - g t + v_0 \sin(\theta), \; (3)$$

$$y = - \frac{1}{2} g t^2 + v_{y0} t + y_0 = - \frac{1}{2} g t^2 + v_0 \sin(\theta) \; t + y_0. \; (4)$$

Your initial conditions are

$$x_0 = 0, \; y_0 \ne 0,$$

and final conditions (at moment $t=T$ projectile falls back on the ground) are

$$t = T, \; x = d, \; y = 0.$$

If you put initial and final conditions into equations (2) and (4) you end up with two equations and two unknowns $v_0, T$. By eliminating $T$ you get expression for $v_0$.

My calculations show that

$$v_0 = \frac{1}{\cos(\theta)}\sqrt{\frac{\frac{1}{2} g d^2}{d \tan(\theta)+y_0}}$$

which is I believe equal to your equation. Maybe your problem is that $d$ means displacement in direction $x$, while the total displacement is $\sqrt{d^2+y_0^2}$?

share|improve this answer
    
Thanks Pygmalion, especially for the quick and detailed response. This is taking me well past my comfort zone in physics/maths, so it's going to take me a short while to digest what you've written. I'm interested in your closing question: displacement in direction x vs total displacement. I sourced the formula from the link below where their description does seem to match my problem. I will investigate further and reply back. Equation Source –  James May 8 '12 at 11:51
2  
The answer is correct, but maybe there is confusion with the nomenclature. If the separation between the launch point and target is $(\Delta x,\Delta y)$ in xy components, then the equation relating the separations is $\Delta y = \Delta x \tan\theta - \frac{ \frac{1}{2} g \Delta x^2} {v_0^2 \cos^2 \theta} $. This can be solved for $v_0$. –  ja72 May 8 '12 at 17:31
    
@ja72 Exactly my point! Thanks for pointing this out in even more clear way that I did. –  Pygmalion May 8 '12 at 20:13
    
@Pygmalion and ja72. I am indeed using xy components and so switching the equation to that suggested has solved the problem for me. Thank you for your time. –  James May 11 '12 at 9:00
    
@James I've only seen the change to your answer now. If you got your asnwer, I consider the case closed. –  Pygmalion May 11 '12 at 9:28
show 2 more comments

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.