Take the 2-minute tour ×
Physics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for active researchers, academics and students of physics. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I have always fancied building my own reflector telescope. I am wondering - For a certain budget, can you get better results with a home made rig? Or is this a folly, and really it would be better to buy a ready made unit?

share|improve this question
3  
Clyde Tombaugh (the discoverer of Pluto) told me it was worth it for him. Of course, he did that quite a few years ago when it was harder to buy good instruments. –  dmckee Feb 29 '12 at 20:49

4 Answers 4

(Assuming you're in the US)

It's hard to compete with the Chinese "econo-dobs" on price. A 150 ... 200 mm (6" ... 8") GSO-made dob (sold rebranded by the various companies here) is $300 ... 350. Could you build a dob for less than that? Umm... mmmmaybe?... But you'll have to be pretty persistent in hunting down the best deals for materials and stuff. Even so, quality-wise, it might be better in some regards, but worse in other ways.

You'll also need some tools for wood-working and such - if you don't have those to begin with, you'll probably blow the budget.

Also keep in mind that the cheap Corning-made Pyrex is all but gone (I should know, I bought one of the last 12.5" Pyrex blanks at the old price a few months ago), so you'll probably pay a little bit more for the mirror kit than last year - you'll probably be using Schott Supremax (borosilicate), which is the same thing, but being imported from EU, what with the exchange parity and overseas shipping, it's more expensive.

Maybe the chinese will pick up the slack and start making cheap borosilicate. Or maybe you find an old Pyrex blank real cheap, with some minor defect, that just requires muscle power and patience to fix. Maybe.

Or just use plate glass instead of borosilicate. It will take more time to cool down when in use, and there's a higher risk it will crack when you're pressing the hot pitch lap for polishing. But it's dirt cheap. Try and use annealed glass, though, not just any chunk of green transparent stuff you found laying on a pile of trash outside.

Why don't you do what I did? Forget about beating GSO on price. This is a long-term project anyway (unless you're unemployed and can work on it full time). You're not going to spend the money all at once. Then just be frugal, but try and do a good job at each step. In the end it will be more expensive, but chances are it's going to be better than the econo-dob from China.

Especially if you go slow on the mirror. "In the optics lab, nothing good happens quickly". So go slow, overdo each step a little bit, polish until all pits are gone, be patient and do lots of attempts when parabolizing, and you'll end up with an awesome primary mirror. Most econodobs are λ/4 at best; you could do a λ/10 or better, which will make a difference visually.

Plus, you can custom-design it - use a slightly larger secondary mirror so you could do some astrophoto with a DSLR on bright non-tracking targets like the Moon. Etc, etc.

Finally, you'll take pride in the result of your work. Anyone with money can buy a scope, but it takes patience and skill to make one from scratch. You'll also learn a lot in the process.

Good luck.

EDIT: I've heard of a guy who, while broke and unemployed, built a 16" truss dob. You can be sure he built it real cheap. So, yes, it's possible to beat the chinese on price. Depends on what motivates you.

share|improve this answer
1  
Great info - thanks –  UpTheCreek Sep 10 '11 at 6:11
    
The links that Geoff provided are great. Stellafane has an awesome tutorial on mirror making. Their plans for the small dob are excellent. This site alone might be enough. If you want to go beyond that, then: Get the famous book by Texereau on mirror making, it's the Bible of this field. Richard Berry has a book on telescope making (intro level), and then he co-wrote an advanced level book with David Kriege (of Obsession Telescopes fame). Armed with all this docu, and lots of patience, you can build a great scope. –  Florin Andrei Sep 12 '11 at 20:01

Fifty years ago, it used to be very common for people to make their own telescopes. Nowadays it has become very rare, because commercial telescopes have become relatively inexpensive. One result of this is that it is very hard to find the parts needed to build your own scope. Unless you have a very strong motivation to learn how to do this, and to track down the parts needed, I wouldn't recommend building your own scope. Because the parts are hard to find, they are very expensive, and a home made telescope will cost many times more than a commercially built telescope. Labour is so much cheaper in China where almost all telescopes are made nowadays.

http://www.atmsite.org/

http://stellafane.org/tm/atm/index.html

http://www.atmpage.com/

share|improve this answer
    
The links are great, but I respectfully disagree on the difficulty to find ATM parts and materials. If anything, I think today we're having it much better than ever before - better glass, better grit and polishing agents, better everything. There only seems to be a minor hiccup with borosilicate glass right now, since Pyrex stocks have all but vanished and the available low-expansion glass is the relatively expensive one made by Schott. Other than that, things are pretty awesome. When I was a kid, I read about cerium oxide, and it was pretty much Unobtainium to me. Not so nowadays. –  Florin Andrei Sep 12 '11 at 18:15

Building your own scope is a challenge, a labour of love and, when completed, a source of great pride. As has already been mentioned, you can design your own telescope . The making of the parts is challenging. I bought my own lathe in 1975. It has since been replaced by a Chinese model with an integrated milling machine. This machine is wonderful for the manufacture your own focusers and drive units. Electronics comes into the design and building of stepper motor drives. By the time you have built a few scopes you will have increased your knowledge in optics, engineering and electronics. The best thing about telescope making today is that the internet has an almost limitless supply of information in all aspects of telescope making. Go for it!

share|improve this answer

I started building reflectors in the 1950s and apart from being a labour of love it provides great satisfaction. In these days I polished my mirrors with jewlers rouge, that red stuff ! After making half a dozen scopes or so finished up making a 6"schmit-cassegrain which took me all of 8 years off and on..Still got that one.I'm sure its not 1/4 wave but it produces awesome images!! So I wonder how you got on with your project...Writing from Scotland where viewing is limited by weather..Anyway good luck !!

share|improve this answer
    
The question is also addressing costs etc. Can you elaborate a bit on that? –  Bernhard Mar 16 '13 at 11:22

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.