# Effects of high frequency lighting on human vision?

I have a couple of different LED flashlights. One of them has three different "modes" of brightness, and the way it controls it is via pulse width modulation (PWM). Here is a picture that illustrates how it works:

I know that this particular flashlight's PWM circuit operates at about 120Hz. What this means is that when you move something very quickly under it, when running a low duty cycle, it produces a strobe-light effect, where you'll see many "copies" of the moving object. It reminds me of the way video-games are rendered, and it actually creates a really neat effect because you only "see" very small time-slices. Watching running water this way is absolutely fascinating.

From empirical observation I determine that on the lowest setting it seems to be on about a 2-5% duty cycle. The ghost-images produced are remarkably sharp. On Medium, I reckon it's about 25 to 30%.

Something I've noticed very recently is that when I use this flashlight under dark-adjusted conditions, the brightness that is perceived definitely doesn't seem to scale linearly. I have no scientific light intensity equipment to perform measurements with, but I am more or less convinced that a 1000 lumen light on a 2% square-wave duty cycle appears brighter than a 20 lumen light, all else being equal (which would include incident light energy).

I think there may be some biological explanation for this. Is this an effect that has been observed by others?

-
It is very common knowledge, that most (all?) of our senses work with a logarithmic scale. For sound and light this is proven since Helmholtz times. – Georg Oct 5 '11 at 10:35
Yes I am aware of that. The variable I'm concerned with isnt the logarithmic response, it's the relationship between high (well, 120hz isn't that high) frequency modulations which contain the same average energy. – Steven Lu Oct 5 '11 at 10:38
Next thing is the integrating action of the perception. This is maybe different for dark adapted (b/w) and color vision. – Georg Oct 5 '11 at 11:02
How precisely do you know the 1000 lumen light really has 1000 lumen, the 20 lumen one 20 lumen, and the duty cycle is 2%? Under which circumstances did you compare them? What colors are the lights? – leftaroundabout Oct 5 '11 at 11:21
I think a lot of my questions could be completely answered if I just had the proper equipment for performing some scientific testing. An oscilloscope would allow me to figure out the duty cycle, and light power meters too for finding out intensity. – Steven Lu Oct 6 '11 at 14:37